CAT - ['Delhi']Administrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Substantial compliance with tribunal's directions defeats contempt; surviving grievances require separate proceedings in appropriate forum.

Vijay R Haror FILED BY APPLICANT NO. 6 DEEPAK KUMAR SANGALv.SANJAY JAJU SECRETARY M/O INFORMATION AND BROADCASTING

Substantial compliance with tribunal's directions defeats contempt; surviving grievances require separate proceedings in appropriate forum.. Vijay R Haror FILED BY APPLICANT NO. 6 DEEPAK KUMAR SANGAL vs SANJAY JAJU SECRETARY M/O INFORMATION AND BROADCASTING. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the respondents' conduct constituted wilful and deliberate non-compliance with the Tribunal's order dated 08.02.2018 so as to warrant contempt proceedings.

The court held

The Tribunal held that substantial compliance with the order dated 08.02.2018 had been made, and that any surviving grievances on nomenclature, scope, consequential benefits or the departmental examination are to be considered in appropriate proceedings in accordance with law.

It also directed

Both Contempt Petitions (CP No. 809/2024 and CP No. 810/2024) are closed, with liberty to the petitioners to approach an appropriate forum. The MAs seeking impleadment of the CEO, Prasar Bharati (MA Nos. 605/2025 and 606/2025) are allowed. Notices to the alleged contemnors are discharged and no order as to costs is made.

01Facts

The petitioners alleged wilful non-compliance with the Tribunal's order dated 08.02.2018 in O.A. No. 282/2018, which directed the merger of the Engineering Assistant (EA) and Senior Engineering Assistant (SEA) posts and the notification of modified Recruitment Rules.

¶ 2

The order was upheld by the Delhi High Court on 30.04.2024.

¶ 3

The petitioners contended that implementation was delayed and that the Gazette Notification dated 02.09.2026 was only partial because it (i) adopts the nomenclature "Junior Broadcast Engineer" rather than "Broadcast Engineer," (ii) limits the merger benefit to a restricted category of employees, and (iii) does not address consequential promotional benefits.

¶ 3

The petitioners alleged that Prasar Bharati was conducting a departmental examination solely for the SEA post, prejudicing eligible employees of both erstwhile cadres.

¶ 4

The respondents submitted that there was no wilful disobedience. The Department of Expenditure approved the merger in the Grade Pay of Rs. 4600/- on 25.07.2024, draft Recruitment Rules were obtained from Prasar Bharati, and the matter was referred to DoPT and other departments on the applicable procedure.

¶ 5

The Recruitment Rules for the feeder cadre of Senior Broadcast Technician underwent consultation, approval and legal vetting, and the delay was attributed to administrative and procedural requirements.

¶ 6

The petitioners maintained that unresolved issues remained.

¶ 7

The Tribunal allowed impleadment of the CEO, Prasar Bharati, as Respondent No. 2.

¶ 1

02Issues

i.1. Whether the respondents' conduct constituted wilful and deliberate non-compliance with the Tribunal's order dated 08.02.2018 so as to warrant contempt proceedings.

¶ 2, 5, 6, 9

ii.2. Whether the Gazette Notification dated 02.09.2026 and the steps taken towards framing the Recruitment Rules amount to substantial compliance with the Tribunal's directions.

¶ 9, 10

iii.3. Whether the surviving grievances concerning nomenclature, the scope of the merger, consequential promotional benefits and the departmental examination can be adjudicated in contempt or must be pursued in appropriate proceedings.

¶ 9, 10

03Law Applied

The judgment does not cite any statutory provision, the Contempt of Courts Act, or any precedent on the test for contempt or substantial compliance. The reasoning rests on the Tribunal's own order dated 08.02.2018 in O.A. No. 282/2018, which directed merger of the EA and SEA posts and notification of modified Recruitment Rules.

¶ 2

The Tribunal applied the principle that a contempt petition is closed where substantial compliance with the directions is shown, and that residual grievances concerning the scope, correctness or consequential service benefits of the implementation are to be agitated in appropriate proceedings in accordance with law. The Tribunal did not articulate the specific standard for wilfulness, and the principle is not supported by any cited authority. The Delhi High Court's judgment dated 30.04.2024 upholding the order of 08.02.2018 also forms part of the reasoning.

¶ 3, 9, 10

04Reasoning

The Tribunal first found that the respondents had taken "substantial steps" toward compliance, namely the Gazette Notification dated 02.09.2026 and the initiation of the process to frame and notify the corresponding Recruitment Rules.

¶ 9

The delay was explained by documented consultation, approval and legal vetting requirements, which the Tribunal accepted as administrative and procedural rather than deliberate disregard of its order.

¶ 5, 6, 9

The Tribunal then characterised the petitioners' grievances (nomenclature, applicability to similarly situated employees, promotional benefits and the departmental examination) as going to "the scope and correctness of the implementation of the notified Recruitment Rules and the consequential service benefits."

¶ 9

Such issues concern the content of a fresh administrative act, not the failure to obey the operative direction, and therefore fall outside the core of contempt. On that basis the Tribunal held that substantial compliance had been made, while leaving the residual grievances open for adjudication in a proper forum. The order does not expressly record a finding that the respondents were not wilful, so the closure rests on the finding of substantial compliance rather than on an express exoneration.

¶ 9, 10

05Holding

The Tribunal held that substantial compliance with the order dated 08.02.2018 had been made, and that any surviving grievances on nomenclature, scope, consequential benefits or the departmental examination are to be considered in appropriate proceedings in accordance with law.

¶ 10

Both Contempt Petitions (CP No. 809/2024 and CP No. 810/2024) are closed, with liberty to the petitioners to approach an appropriate forum. The MAs seeking impleadment of the CEO, Prasar Bharati (MA Nos. 605/2025 and 606/2025) are allowed. Notices to the alleged contemnors are discharged and no order as to costs is made.

¶ 1, 10
CAT - ['Delhi']

Original Court PDF

Vijay R Haror FILED BY APPLICANT NO. 6 DEEPAK KUMAR SANGALvsSANJAY JAJU SECRETARY M/O INFORMATION AND BROADCASTING

CAT - ['Delhi'] · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment