01Facts
The State acquired 59.57 acres across six villages in Rewari District under notifications dated 1 July 2008 and 20 February 2009, for construction of a connecting road.
¶ 3–6, 12 · pp. 4–5, 8These appeals concerned acquired land in Gokalgarh, Kaluwas, Rewari and Chandawas.
¶ 3–6, 12 · pp. 4–5, 8The Collector assessed compensation at ₹16 lakh per acre; the Reference Court fixed different rates, including ₹1,95,72,960 per acre for three villages and ₹48,93,240 per acre for Chandawas.
¶ 3–6, 12 · pp. 4–5, 8The State challenged the enhanced awards, while landowners sought to sustain or increase compensation.
¶ 3–6, 12 · pp. 4–5, 8Certain landowners also claimed severance damages because the road allegedly divided their remaining land.
¶ 3–6, 12 · pp. 4–5, 8The High Court heard the connected appeals together.
¶ 2 · p. 302Issues
i.1. Whether compensation should be assessed by relying on earlier awards and applying escalation, or by reference to comparable sale deeds relating to the acquisition area.
¶ 14, 19–20 · pp. 9, 15–16ii.2. Whether a uniform market value should be fixed for the land acquired through this linear acquisition.
¶ 28 · p. 22iii.3. Whether claims for severance damages could be determined on the existing record or required remittal to the Reference Court.
¶ 29–31 · pp. 22–2303Law Applied
Under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, compensation is assessed by reference to the market value at the relevant date, and appeals from awards lie under Section 54.
¶ 1, 3–5 · pp. 3–4Earlier awards may be relevant evidence but cannot be adopted mechanically; their factual foundation, comparability and evidentiary basis must be examined (Manoj Kumar v. State of Haryana, 2018 (13) SCC 96; Ram Krishan (Since Deceased) v. State of Haryana, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 715).
¶ 18–19 · pp. 12–15Escalation based on older transactions must be applied cautiously; the Court relied on the principle that escalation is generally unsafe when the time gap is substantial, and rejected the cumulative 12% escalation applied over 16 years (ONGC v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel, 2008 (4) RCR (Civil) 487; Lal Chand v. Union of India, 2009 (15) SCC 769).
¶ 17, 19.1 · pp. 10–11, 15–16Genuine sale transactions relating to the acquired land cannot be disregarded merely because another award suggests a higher value (Special Tehsildar, Land Acquisition, Vishakapatnam v. A. Mangala Gowri, 1991 (4) SCC 218).
¶ 22–23 · pp. 17–18Section 25 operates as a floor on compensation awarded by the Reference Court; it does not make otherwise reliable sale deeds inadmissible merely because they disclose a lower market value than the Collector’s award (Lal Chand).
¶ 24 · pp. 18–20Provisions in the judgment · 6
Land Acquisition Act, 1894 Section 4Section 6Section 11Section 18Section 25Section 54
04Reasoning
The Court held that the Reference Court had mechanically relied on earlier awards founded on a 1990 acquisition and applied cumulative escalation despite an 18-year gap and the availability of contemporaneous sale evidence.
¶ 17–20 · pp. 10–16It therefore declined to use those awards as the basis for valuation.
¶ 17–20 · pp. 10–16Of the landowners’ exemplars, it rejected the 2005 deeds as too early and the 2007 deed as relating to distant land abutting a highway.
¶ 25–27 · pp. 20–22It selected the April 2008 sale deed (Ex.P-10), which concerned land near the starting point of the acquired land and disclosed a higher rate than the March 2008 deed (Ex.P-9).
¶ 25–27 · pp. 20–22Because Ex.P-10 concerned a small parcel abutting a road, the Court applied a 15% deduction, fixing the rate at ₹63,75,800 per acre.
¶ 25–27 · pp. 20–22Given the linear nature of the acquisition, it applied that uniform rate across the villages, including Chandawas.
¶ 28 · p. 22On severance, the Court found that entitlement and quantum depended on individual circumstances—including the area severed, prior and subsequent use, and the effect of the road on the remaining land—and could not be determined uniformly in these appeals.
¶ 30–31 · pp. 22–2305Holding
The Court modified the Reference Court’s awards and fixed uniform compensation at ₹63,75,800 per acre for the acquired land in the villages at issue, with statutory benefits under the 1894 Act.
¶ 28 · p. 22Landowners whose appeals were delayed were not entitled to interest for the period of delay.
¶ 9 · p. 7The severance-damages claims were remitted to the Reference Court for determination on the existing evidence, limited to landowners who had claimed severance in their reference applications and led evidence; no fresh evidence was permitted.
¶ 31 · p. 23The connected appeals and cross-objections were disposed of accordingly.
¶ 32 · p. 23Original Court PDF
State Of Haryana And OthersvsTek Chand And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
