01Facts
The plaintiffs sought a permanent injunction against dispossession from property in khasra No.304//6/1, claiming ownership and possession under a sale deed and subsequent inheritance.
¶ 2, 8Defendant No.4, Naresh Kumar, counterclaimed for removal of a boundary wall, alleging that the plaintiffs had encroached on his adjoining property in khasra Nos.304//5/3 and 6/3.
¶ 3, 11The trial court granted the plaintiffs an injunction concerning khasra No.304//6/1, but also decreed Naresh Kumar’s counterclaim, directing removal of the wall.
¶ 4, 17The first appellate court dismissed the plaintiffs’ appeal against the counterclaim decree.
¶ 5, 18In the second appeal, the plaintiffs did not dispute the Local Commissioner’s report recording 104 square yards of excess possession or the plaintiff No.1’s admission that the plaintiffs had no claim to the disputed khasra numbers.
¶ 1902Issues
i.1. Whether the courts below erred in decreeing Naresh Kumar’s counterclaim and directing the plaintiffs to remove the encroaching wall.
¶ 16–21ii.2. Whether the findings of the courts below raised a substantial question of law warranting interference in the second appeal.
¶ 2103Law Applied
The Court identified no specific statutory provision or precedent as the basis of its decision.
¶ 19–21It applied the principle governing a regular second appeal that interference is not warranted where the concurrent findings of the courts below are supported by the evidence and no substantial question of law arises.
¶ 2104Reasoning
The plaintiffs’ property in khasra No.304//6/1 was distinct from the property covered by Naresh Kumar’s counterclaim.
¶ 19The Local Commissioner’s report showed that the plaintiffs possessed 104 square yards beyond their own land, and plaintiff No.1 admitted that the plaintiffs had no concern with the disputed khasra numbers but possessed approximately 100 square yards of extra land.
¶ 16, 19The High Court found that the courts below had properly assessed the pleadings and evidence, and the appellants failed to show that their findings were perverse, illegal, or based on misreading or misappreciation of the evidence.
¶ 20–2105Holding
The High Court held that no substantial question of law arose for adjudication and declined to interfere with the concurrent findings.
¶ 21The regular second appeal was dismissed, and pending applications, if any, were closed.
¶ 22–23Original Court PDF
Navdeep Kansal And OthersvsSumit Singla And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
