Patna High CourtSocial Security and PensionsEmployment and Labour Law

Patna HC Declines Retired PHED Employee’s Bid to Count Service From 1987, Citing Earlier Ruling Fixing His Service Start in 1990

Rambabu Singhv.The State of Bihar

Patna HC Declines Retired PHED Employee’s Bid to Count Service From 1987, Citing Earlier Ruling Fixing His Service Start in 1990. Rambabu Singh vs The State of Bihar. Patna High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the petitioner could again seek to have his qualifying service counted from 27 May 1987, contrary to the determination in the earlier judgment

The court held

The Court did not grant the requested substantive recalculation of service or benefits.

It also directed

It disposed of the writ petition, leaving the petitioner at liberty to submit a representation to the competent authority for redress of his claims.

The Court noted that the earlier service-date and MACP findings remained in force and that the recovered amount had been refunded.

01Facts

The petitioner, a former Typist in the Public Health Engineering Department, claimed that his qualifying service should run from 27 May 1987, when he first joined, rather than from 28 February 1990, when he was reinstated after termination as surplus.

pp. 2–6, 12–13

In an earlier proceeding, CWJC No. 5786 of 2024, decided with analogous cases on 18 September 2024, the High Court held that his service was to be reckoned from 28 February 1990; it also held that he was not entitled to a third MACP before retirement.

pp. 3–4, 12 · ¶ 3, 12

The petitioner subsequently challenged Office Orders Nos. 64 and 66, dated 1 August and 25 August 2025, which granted him the first ACP from 7 March 2002 and the second MACP from 7 March 2010.

pp. 2–6, 12–13

The State submitted that the impugned orders implemented the earlier judgment and that the previously recovered ₹7,32,487 had been refunded.

pp. 2–6, 12–13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the petitioner could again seek to have his qualifying service counted from 27 May 1987, contrary to the determination in the earlier judgment

pp. 6–7, 12

ii.2. Whether the petitioner was entitled to further revision of his ACP/MACP benefits, pay, pension, gratuity, and other consequential benefits under the orders challenged in this petition

pp. 4–6, 12–13

03Law Applied

The Court relied on the principle that ACP/MACP schemes provide financial upgradation to address stagnation, rather than promotion to a higher post, subject to the scheme’s eligibility requirements, as stated in Union of India v. C.R. Madhava Murthy, (2022) 6 SCC 183, and Amresh Kumar Sinha v. State of Bihar, SLP(C) Nos. 8219–8226 of 2019.

pp. 7–8 · ¶ 9–10

It also applied the rule that pension and gratuity are earned benefits and constitute property protected by Article 300-A of the Constitution, relying on State of Jharkhand v. Jitendra Kumar Srivastava, (2013) 12 SCC 210, and the principles in D.S. Nakara v. Union of India, (1983) 1 SCC 305.

pp. 8–10 · ¶ 11

The judgment further noted that Rule 43(b) permits withholding pension-related benefits only where the requisite finding of grave misconduct has been recorded in departmental or judicial proceedings.

p. 10 · ¶ 11

For the petitioner’s service date and MACP entitlement, the controlling determination was the earlier judgment dated 18 September 2024 in CWJC No. 5786 of 2024.

pp. 3–4, 12 · ¶ 3, 12

04Reasoning

The Court found that the earlier judgment had already determined the petitioner’s qualifying service date as 28 February 1990 and held that he was not entitled to a third MACP.

pp. 7–8, 12–13

As that determination had not been shown to have been set aside or modified, the Court treated it as governing the present claims and declined to reconsider the petitioner’s assertion that service began in 1987.

pp. 7–8, 12–13

It also noted that the respondents had refunded the ₹7,32,487 recovered from the petitioner.

pp. 7–8, 12–13

The principles concerning financial upgradation and pension rights informed the Court’s consideration, but did not displace the earlier determination of the petitioner’s service date and entitlement.

pp. 7–8, 12–13

05Holding

The Court did not grant the requested substantive recalculation of service or benefits.

p. 13 · ¶ 12–14

It disposed of the writ petition, leaving the petitioner at liberty to submit a representation to the competent authority for redress of his claims.

p. 13 · ¶ 12–14

The Court noted that the earlier service-date and MACP findings remained in force and that the recovered amount had been refunded.

p. 13 · ¶ 12–14
Patna High Court

Original Court PDF

Rambabu SinghvsThe State of Bihar

Patna High Court · November 03, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment