Karnataka High CourtInsurance LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Pedestrian's Rs 1.18 Lakh Claim Dismissed as Hospital Records Named 'Unknown Vehicle', HC Finds Car Falsely Implicated

KRISHNAPPAv.UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO., LTD.,

Pedestrian's Rs 1.18 Lakh Claim Dismissed as Hospital Records Named 'Unknown Vehicle', HC Finds Car Falsely Implicated. KRISHNAPPA vs UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO., LTD.,. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in holding the insurer liable to pay compensation, given the alleged false implication of the insured vehicle.

The court held

The court answered Point 1 in the negative, holding that the Tribunal was not justified in fixing liability on the insurer because the insured vehicle's involvement was falsely implicated.

It also directed

Point 2 was not considered.

The orders are: MFA No. 8433/2013 (claimant's appeal) is dismissed; MFA No. 5023/2013 (insurer's appeal) is allowed; the judgment and award dated 23.01.2013 in MVC No. 2825/2011 is set aside and the claim petition is dismissed; and the amount deposited by the insurer is to be transmitted to the Tribunal for refund on request.

01Facts

On 24.01.2011 at about 9:30 p.m., the claimant, Krishnappa, was walking beside BB Road near Green Country School when Car No. KA-05-MF-6666 allegedly struck him from behind, causing grievous injuries and permanent disability

¶ 2

He filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (MV Act) against the owner and insurer.

¶ 2

The owner (R-2) was placed ex parte. Only the insurer contested, denying the accident and the insured vehicle's involvement

¶ 2

The Tribunal (MVC No. 2825/2011, XVI Addl. Judge, MACT-14, Bengaluru) answered the issues in the claimant's favour, awarded ₹1,18,000 with 6% interest, and held the insurer liable

¶ 3–4

The claimant examined himself and Dr. Ramesh Krishna K. (PWs 1–2) and produced Exs. P1–P14. The respondents led no evidence

¶ 4

The insurer argued that: (a) NIMHANS emergency record (Ex. P9) and Victoria Hospital wound certificate (Ex. P3) record the vehicle as "unknown"

¶ 5, 11

(b) the complaint was lodged three days later (24.01.2011) by the claimant's son without disclosing the source of the information

¶ 5, 11

(c) the insured vehicle was inspected only on 08.02.2011 (Ex. P6)

¶ 5

(d) no police officer or seizure mahazar was produced

¶ 5

In cross-examination, PW-1 admitted he was unconscious immediately after the accident and obtained the registration number from one Bettappa, who was not examined

¶ 11

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in holding the insurer liable to pay compensation, given the alleged false implication of the insured vehicle.

¶ 9(i)

ii.2. Whether the assessment of compensation calls for modification.

¶ 9(ii)

03Law Applied

The claim was founded on Section 166 of the MV Act, and the appeals were brought under Section 173(1).

¶ 2, Heading

The court applied the principle from Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Premlata Shukla (2007) 13 SCC 476 that a claimant cannot rely on the contents of a document in part while disowning the remainder.

¶ 11

The insurer's counsel also relied on the Division Bench decision in MFA No. 11443/2006 (decided 18.07.2012), which in turn followed Smt. Revathi & Anr. v. Smt. Kiran P. Suvarna & Anr., ILR 2010 Kar 5394, for the proposition that where a police complaint is delayed, each fact requires strict scrutiny.

¶ 5

The court did not expressly adopt Revathi in its reasoning.

¶ 5

The court applied the principle that a finding which ignores material on record is perverse and liable to be set aside.

¶ 11, no citation to authority

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166

04Reasoning

The court first noted that the complaint (Ex. P2) was filed three days after the accident by the claimant's son, and that the public records relied upon by the claimant (Exs. P3 and P9) describe the vehicle as "unknown".

¶ 11

The claimant had not explained this discrepancy against the police investigation record.

¶ 11

PW-1 had no personal knowledge of the vehicle's number, and the only source, Bettappa, was not examined.

¶ 11

Applying Premlata Shukla, the court held that the claimant could not rely on Ex. P2 for the identity of the vehicle while discounting the medical records that contradicted it.

¶ 11

Read cumulatively, these circumstances substantiated the insurer's suspicion of false implication of the insured vehicle.

¶ 11

The Tribunal had merely referred to the prosecution records and fixed liability without adverting to the entire material on record. The court therefore held the finding perverse.

¶ 11

Since liability failed, the question of quantum did not survive.

¶ 12

05Holding

The court answered Point 1 in the negative, holding that the Tribunal was not justified in fixing liability on the insurer because the insured vehicle's involvement was falsely implicated.

¶ 11

Point 2 was not considered.

¶ 12

The orders are: MFA No. 8433/2013 (claimant's appeal) is dismissed; MFA No. 5023/2013 (insurer's appeal) is allowed; the judgment and award dated 23.01.2013 in MVC No. 2825/2011 is set aside and the claim petition is dismissed; and the amount deposited by the insurer is to be transmitted to the Tribunal for refund on request.

¶ 13
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

KRISHNAPPAvsUNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO., LTD.,

Karnataka High Court · November 11, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment