Facts
The petitioner, engaged in providing Mehendi services outside Hanuman Mandir at BKS Marg, New Delhi, approached the Delhi High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution.
Source reference: p.1–2, paras. 2–4He contended that his Certificate of Vending (“CoV”), bearing Vendor ID V2025200869, incorrectly recorded his vending location and sought correction of the location to Hanuman Mandir Parishar/Compound.
Source reference: p.1–2, paras. 2–4He further sought permission to sell ladies’ wear and cosmetic items in addition to providing Mehendi services.
Source reference: p.1–2, paras. 2–4The New Delhi Municipal Council (“NDMC”) submitted that the petitioner was already providing Mehendi services outside the temple and that any change in his location or vending category could be considered only by Town Vending Committee-II (“TVC-II”).
Source reference: p.4, para. 5The Court noted that the CoV mentioned “Mehdi work” and “Janpath” but did not specify the precise vending location.
Source reference: p.4, para. 6Issues
Whether the petitioner’s Certificate of Vending required correction to accurately record his place of vending outside Hanuman Mandir at BKS Marg, New Delhi.
Source reference: p.4, paras. 6–7Whether the petitioner could be permitted to expand or alter his vending activity to include ladies’ wear and cosmetic items in addition to Mehendi services.
Source reference: p.2, para. 2; p.4, paras. 4–6Whether the petitioner, as a holder of a provisional Certificate of Vending, could be protected from disturbance pending consideration of his request by the competent Town Vending Committee.
Source reference: p.4, paras. 7–8Law Applied
The Court exercised its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution to issue appropriate directions concerning the petitioner’s Certificate of Vending.
Source reference: p.1–2, para. 2The Court applied the principle that matters concerning alteration of the vending location or category fall within the competence of the Town Vending Committee, specifically TVC-II, rather than being determined directly by the Court or NDMC.
Source reference: p.4, para. 5It further recognised that a provisional CoV holder should not be disturbed from the activity for which the provisional CoV had been issued while his request is pending consideration by the competent authority.
Source reference: p.4, para. 8No specific statutory provision or precedent was cited in the judgment.
Source reference: no citationReasoning
The Court examined the photographs and found that the existing vending site did not have adequate space for expansion of the petitioner’s activities.
Source reference: p.4, para. 6Accordingly, it did not grant an immediate direction permitting the sale of ladies’ wear or cosmetic items.
Source reference: p.4, para. 6However, since the CoV referred only to “Janpath” and did not specify the petitioner’s actual place of vending, the Court considered it appropriate for the competent TVC-II to examine the request for correction of location.
Source reference: p.4, para. 6Recognising that TVC-II had yet to be constituted, the Court directed that it consider the petitioner’s request within three months of its constitution.
Source reference: p.4, para. 7In the interim, the petitioner was protected from being disturbed while rendering Mehendi services outside Hanuman Mandir, as he held a provisional CoV.
Source reference: p.4, para. 8Holding
The petition was disposed of.
The Court directed TVC-II, upon its constitution, to consider and decide the petitioner’s request for correction of the place of vending within three months.
Source reference: p.4, para. 7The Court did not grant an immediate change in the petitioner’s vending category or permit expansion into ladies’ wear and cosmetic items.
Source reference: p.4, para. 8Until the competent authority decides the matter, the petitioner was directed not to be disturbed from providing Mehendi services outside Hanuman Mandir at BKS Marg.
Source reference: p.4, para. 8All pending applications, if any, were also disposed of.
Source reference: p.4, para. 9Original Court PDF
Virender GoelvsNew-Delhi Muncipal Council And Anr
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
