01Facts
The plaintiff, a proprietary concern dealing in PVC water stoppers, sued for Rs.1,42,626/- (including interest and notice charges) under O.S. No. 2507/2013.
It alleged that the defendant, a Delhi-based company with a project at MRPL, Mangaluru, ordered 1000 RM of PVC water stoppers by e-mail, worth Rs.1,25,000/- plus VAT.
The goods were dispatched from Bengaluru to Mangaluru on 16.04.2011 under Invoice No. 8891 for Rs.1,42,500/- (incl. VAT and transport).
The defendant paid Rs.49,984/- on 14.07.2011, leaving Rs.92,516/- unpaid despite a legal notice dated 25.01.2012.
¶ 3The defendant admitted the transaction and supply in its written statement, but alleged the goods were sub-standard, causing leakages, reputational harm, and loss of a client, and that it engaged another contractor to rectify defects, so it withheld payment.
¶ 4The defendant objected to the territorial jurisdiction of Bengaluru courts.
¶ 4The defendant's jurisdiction application was dismissed, and it filed a writ petition, but the suit was decreed while the writ petition was pending.
¶ 8The defendant did not cross-examine P.W.1 or lead any evidence.
¶ 5, 13The Trial Court decreed Rs.1,42,626/- with 18% p.a. current interest from suit to judgment and 6% p.a. future interest.
¶ 6The defendant appealed under Section 96 CPC. The respondent was served but remained unrepresented.
¶ 1, 702Issues
i.1. Whether the Bengaluru courts had territorial jurisdiction to try the suit, where the purchase order was allegedly placed from Delhi and goods were delivered to Mangaluru.
¶ 8, 14, 15ii.2. Whether the defendant proved that the supplied goods were sub-standard so as to justify withholding the balance of Rs.92,516/-.
¶ 9, 12, 13iii.3. Whether the impugned judgment and decree suffer from perversity or illegality.
¶ 1103Law Applied
The first appeal is maintained under Section 96 CPC.
¶ 1The place where the purchase order was received and where payment was made is treated as material to determining territorial jurisdiction.
¶ 14A party alleging defects in supplied goods must prove that allegation with admissible evidence, and a defendant who admits the transaction but leads no evidence leaves the plaintiff's unchallenged testimony and documents uncontroverted.
¶ 12, 13The defendant's admitted liability on a commercial transaction entitles the plaintiff to principal, interest, and notice charges.
¶ 13The Court's reasoning rests on general principles, and no specific authorities are cited.
Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96
04Reasoning
The Court found that the defendant's own failure to lead evidence left the plaintiff's assertions unrebutted.
¶ 14The Court accepted the plaintiff's case that the e-mailed purchase order was received at the plaintiff's Bengaluru office on 08.04.2011 and that the defendant paid into the plaintiff's Bengaluru bank account, which supported the Trial Court's finding that Bengaluru had territorial jurisdiction.
¶ 14The Court held that the defendant's admission of supply, together with the unpaid invoice balance, established the transaction.
¶ 12The sub-standard-quality defence was a bare assertion without any admissible document or evidence. The defendant did not cross-examine P.W.1, and it ignored the legal notice, which was served but not answered with payment.
¶ 12, 13The Court found no perversity in the Trial Court's appreciation of evidence and no illegality in its decree.
¶ 13, 15The pendency of the defendant's writ petition is noted in the facts but not addressed in the reasoning.
¶ 805Holding
The Court answered the jurisdiction point against the defendant, holding that the Trial Court correctly found territorial jurisdiction at Bengaluru.
¶ 14, 15The Court held the supply and the outstanding balance of Rs.92,516/- proved, and the defendant liable for Rs.1,42,626/- with interest. It found no perversity or illegality in the impugned judgment.
¶ 13, 15The Regular First Appeal is dismissed, and the Judgment and Decree dated 03.09.2019 in O.S. No. 2507/2013 is confirmed.
¶ 16(i), (ii)The order does not expressly address the interest rates or the pending writ petition.
Original Court PDF
M/S ANCL AND CO (INDIA) PVT LTDvsM/S HI TEC RUBBER INDUSTRIES
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
