01Facts
On 22.04.2011, Madan Lal went to a timber market in Jagadhri for labour work and then proceeded to village Bhedi Chhappar to load wood onto tractor-trolley HR-01C-5087, owned by Parmod Kumar.
¶ 2The trolley was allegedly overloaded with eucalyptus wood. When Madan Lal tried to move it, the tractor lifted from the front and he was trapped between the tractor and trolley and died.
¶ 2The claimants (widow, son and mother) filed a claim under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
¶ 2The owner pleaded that he and his brother Surinder Kumar jointly ran agricultural and other work and jointly used the tractor, and attributed the accident to the deceased's negligence.
¶ 3The insurer disputed the occurrence, alleged commercial use, lack of a driving licence, and breach of policy conditions, and contended that the deceased, not being a third party, could not claim under Section 163-A.
¶ 4The Tribunal (Award dated 21.08.2014) found the accident arose from the use of the vehicle, assessed income at ₹3,200/- per month and age at 42 years, and awarded ₹3,71,200/- with interest at 7.5% from the date of claim, holding the owner and insurer jointly and severally liable.
¶ 1, 5The insurer appealed.
¶ 1, 6–8Policy Ex.R1, valid 11.02.2011 to 10.02.2012, is titled a "Liability Only Policy" and carries an additional premium of ₹25/- under "WC to Employee 1".
¶ 2602Issues
i.1. Whether the deceased, as a borrower or permissive user who stepped into the shoes of the owner, was barred from claiming compensation under Section 163-A against the insurer.
¶ 6, 12(i), 14–17ii.2. Whether the overloading of the tractor-trolley constituted a breach of the insurance policy conditions so as to absolve the insurer of liability.
¶ 7, 12(ii), 18–24iii.3. Whether the insurance policy covered the liability arising from the death of the deceased, and if so, to what extent.
¶ 8, 12(iii), 25–2803Law Applied
Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, under which compensation is payable on a structured formula without proof of negligence.
¶ 13United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sunil Kumar (2019) 12 SCC 398, holding that the insurer cannot defeat a Section 163-A claim by pleading negligence attributable to the vehicle, though the claim must still be one covered by the statute or policy.
¶ 13Ningamma v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (2009) 13 SCC 710 and Ramkhiladi v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (2020) 2 SCC 550, under which a borrower who steps into the owner's shoes cannot claim as a third party, but this principle is not mechanically extended to employees operating the vehicle in the course of employment.
¶ 14–15Jagjinder/Jaspinder Singh v. Munni Devi (FAO-767-2004, decided 30.04.2026), holding that overloading materially contributing to an accident may be a fundamental breach of policy conditions.
¶ 18–19, 20Under Section 149(2) of the Act, the insurer bears the burden of establishing a policy breach or statutory defence, and must show a legally relevant breach (National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh (2004) 3 SCC 297).
¶ 21–22Fahim Ahmad v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (2014) 14 SCC 148, holding that mere transport of goods does not by itself establish commercial use.
¶ 23Under Section 147(1)(b) and its proviso, compulsory cover extends to liability under the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923 for employees driving the insured vehicle, and liability beyond that depends on the policy terms (National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Prembai Patel (2005) 6 SCC 172).
¶ 25Section 4(1)(a) of the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923 (50% of monthly wages multiplied by the Schedule IV factor).
¶ 29Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 163Section 166Section 147
04Reasoning
On the first issue, the Court held that the borrower principle in Ningamma and Ramkhiladi did not apply. The claimants pleaded and proved that the deceased was engaged for labour work and operated the tractor as an employee.
¶ 15–16There was no evidence that he borrowed the vehicle for independent use or exercised owner's rights, and the owner's own written statement admitted joint use by the two brothers.
¶ 16–17On the second issue, the Court accepted that overloading caused the accident, since the claimants' own pleadings linked the tractor lifting to the excessive load.
¶ 19However, the Court distinguished Jagjinder/Jaspinder Singh because that case concerned a passenger atop the trolley under Section 166, whereas here the deceased was an employee operating the tractor under Section 163-A, and the policy carried employee coverage.
¶ 20Relying on Swaran Singh, the Court held that the insurer had not identified any policy condition restricting liability for load carried, nor shown that overloading was a statutory defence under Section 149(2).
¶ 22The commercial-use plea also failed because the insurer did not prove that transporting wood was an independent carriage activity in breach of a policy condition.
¶ 23–24On the third issue, the Court held that the policy, though titled "Liability Only", charged an additional premium for "WC to Employee 1", so it did contemplate employee coverage.
¶ 26The deceased's employment by Surinder Kumar, not the registered owner Parmod Kumar, did not make him an unauthorised user, since the policy was not shown to restrict coverage to a named employee.
¶ 27However, the employee endorsement was tied to workers' compensation liability and did not extend to the full Section 163-A liability.
¶ 26, 28The insurer's liability was therefore limited to the compensation under the Employees' Compensation Act, which the Court computed as ₹1,600 × 178.49 = ₹2,85,584/-.
¶ 29–3105Holding
On the first issue, the Court held that the deceased was not a borrower who had stepped into the owner's shoes, and the bar against claiming did not apply.
¶ 17On the second issue, the Court held that overloading was not, on the facts and policy before it, a proven breach that absolved the insurer.
¶ 22, 24On the third issue, the Court held that the insurer's liability is confined to ₹2,85,584/- under the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923.
¶ 28, 31–32The balance of ₹85,616/- is payable by the owner.
¶ 32The appeal is partly allowed and the award is modified accordingly. The total award of ₹3,71,200/- with 7.5% interest from the date of claim until realisation is unchanged.
¶ 33–34The insurer bears interest on its share of ₹2,85,584/- and the owner on ₹85,616/-. Excess deposits by the insurer are to be adjusted or refunded by the Tribunal, without prejudice to the claimants' entitlement.
¶ 33, 35Original Court PDF
United Inida Insurance Co.Ltd.vsKamlesh And Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
