01Facts
On 29.10.2018, Dogar Ali and Mohammad Ali were riding motorcycle PB-13AV-8945 near Bus Stand Sandaur when bus PB-03AF-6513, driven by Jagtar Singh, struck them, killing both.
¶ 3Their legal representatives filed claim petitions under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 ("the Act").
¶ 4By awards dated 24.02.2021, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sangrur, held the bus driver negligent and awarded ₹3,60,000 and ₹13,12,000 with 9% interest.
¶ 5.1Although M/s Taj Travels Pvt. Ltd. remained the registered owner, the Tribunal found the bus had been sold to M/s Dhuri Motors on 16.10.2018 with possession delivered. It also found the bus was operating outside its permitted route without a temporary or special permit, and therefore directed the insurer to pay in the first instance with recovery rights against Dhuri Motors alone.
¶ 5.2Dhuri Motors appealed. The sale, delivery of possession, and the absence of a registration transfer on the date of accident were undisputed.
¶ 14–18The bus held a valid route permit for Ludhiana–Muktsar, a valid policy, and a valid fitness certificate. Negligence and quantum were not challenged.
¶ 2, 14–1802Issues
i.1. Whether the appellant, as purchaser and person in possession but not the registered owner on the date of accident, could be held liable as "owner" under the Act.
¶ 10, 11ii.2. Whether operation of a bus with a valid permit for one route, but outside its sanctioned route, constitutes a breach sufficient to entitle the insurer to recovery rights.
¶ 10, 2003Law Applied
The court applied Section 2(30) of the Act, which defines "owner" as the person in whose name the vehicle is registered.
¶ 11The court relied on Naveen Kumar v. Vijay Kumar (2018) 3 SCC 1 (three-Judge Bench), holding that the registered owner remains the statutory owner despite unregistered transfer, so that victims need not trace successive transferees.
¶ 11, 12The court relied on Dr. T.V. Jose v. Chacko P.M. (2001) 8 SCC 748, recognising that title may pass on sale and delivery of possession while the registered owner remains liable to third parties until the registration record changes.
¶ 12Prakash Chand Daga v. Saveta Sharma (2019) 2 SCC 747 reaffirmed that the registered owner remains liable notwithstanding sale before the accident or within the Section 50 reporting period.
¶ 13On the permit issue, the court applied K. Nagendra v. New India Insurance Co. Ltd., 2025 INSC 1270, which upheld "pay and recover" liability where a permitted vehicle deviated from its authorised route.
¶ 20The court also relied on National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh (2004) 3 SCC 297.
¶ 20The court invoked Section 173 of the Act and the principles of Order XLI Rule 33 CPC to mould relief in appeal.
¶ 25Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 166Section 2Section 50Section 173
04Reasoning
On the first issue, the court held that Section 2(30) and Naveen Kumar fix statutory liability on the person in whose name the bus stood registered on the accident date. Taj Travels was that person, so the Tribunal erred in absolving it merely because the sale to Dhuri Motors preceded the accident.
¶ 14–16The sale, possession and control were established through testimony and exhibits (Exs. R-16 to R-19, Forms 28–30, and the admission in Dhuri Motors' own written statement), but none of this retrospectively altered the registration record.
¶ 14, 15On the second issue, the court found from the RTA register (Ex. RW5/A) that no temporary or special permit was issued. Payment of the fee (Ex. R-12) did not amount to grant of a permit.
¶ 18, 19Following K. Nagendra, the court held that deviation from a permitted route does not defeat the insurer's "pay and recover" obligation but does preserve its recovery right, balancing third-party protection against contractual protection.
¶ 20–22Because Taj Travels was the registered owner and insured, the recovery right properly lies against it, not Dhuri Motors.
¶ 23However, the sale was complete and the operational breach occurred under Dhuri Motors' control, so the court determined inter se responsibility directly in the appeal rather than requiring separate proceedings.
¶ 24, 2505Holding
The court held that (i) the registered owner on the date of accident, Taj Travels, remains statutorily liable to third parties despite the prior unregistered sale, and (ii) operation outside a permitted route is a breach that does not defeat the insurer's pay-and-recover obligation, but the insurer's recovery right runs against the registered owner and insured.
¶ 16, 21, 23Both appeals were partly allowed and the awards modified as follows: (a) United India Insurance Co. Ltd. must satisfy the awards in the first instance with interest; (b) it may recover only from Taj Travels; (c) Taj Travels may recover the full amount from Dhuri Motors, enforceable in execution without a separate suit; (d) the insurer has no direct recovery right against Dhuri Motors. Findings on negligence, quantum, interest and apportionment were left undisturbed.
¶ 26Original Court PDF
M/S Dhuri Motors Regd.vsRashida And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
