01Facts
On 24.07.2013, an Agricultural Development Officer inspected the shop of M/s Sandeep Fertilizers Sales Corporation (the dealer), Khanna, and found 638 machine-stitched 50 kg bags of imported DAP (N18% P46%) marketed under the "Mosaic" brand and packed by M/s Mosaic India Pvt. Ltd.
¶ 4Six bags were sampled under Clause 28(1)(b) of the Fertilizer (Control) Order, 1985 (FCO). The samples failed in nutrient content and solubility at the primary analysis, and the reference re-analysis also failed in total nitrogen and water-soluble P₂O₅.
¶ 4–5The dealer's authorisation was cancelled for violating Clause 19(a) FCO; in appeal, the licence was partially restored.
¶ 5A complaint (COMA/8865-2015, dated 15.12.2015) was filed before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ludhiana, under Clause 19(a) FCO read with Section 3 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 (ECA), punishable under Section 7, against the dealer, its partner, Mosaic India Pvt. Ltd. and its responsible persons, including its Regional Manager, Manish Gupta.
¶ 5, 12The DAP was supplied by Mosaic's branch to the dealer under Invoice No. 5058000457 dated 18.07.2013.
¶ 12–13Annexure P-14 records that Mosaic India was the importer.
¶ 10The State did not dispute that Mosaic was the importer, that the sample was drawn from original machine-stitched bags, or that the complaint was within limitation.
¶ 7–8, 11CRM-46794-2017 was filed by the dealer and its partner; CRM-32200-2022 was filed by Mosaic India, Mohit Chandra and Manish Gupta.
¶ 2–302Issues
i.1. Whether a dealer can be prosecuted under Clause 19(a) FCO read with Sections 3 and 7 ECA for selling sub-standard fertilizer drawn from original, sealed, machine-stitched bags, absent any allegation of tampering, improper storage, or knowledge of the defect.
¶ 14–22ii.2. Whether the importer/supplier can be held criminally liable for a manufacturing defect where it had no role in manufacturing and no act or omission contributing to the sub-standard quality.
¶ 13, 15–22iii.3. Whether continuation of the proceedings amounts to an abuse of process warranting quashing under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
¶ 22–2303Law Applied
Clause 19(a) of the FCO 1985 and Section 3 of the ECA 1955, which penalise the sale or distribution of non-standard fertilizer, and Section 7 ECA, which prescribes punishment.
¶ 7, 12Section 482 Cr.P.C. for inherent power to quash proceedings.
¶ 22–23A dealer or supplier who did not manufacture the product, and who sold it in original sealed packing with no tampering or improper storage alleged, cannot be held criminally liable for a manufacturing defect: Manoj Grover v. State of Punjab (CRM-M-4582-2008, 15.12.2009); Ghanvir Singh v. State of Punjab (CRM-M-28723-2010, 30.07.2012); Arun Kumar v. State of Punjab, 1995 (3) RCR (Criminal) 231; Kulwinder Singh v. State of Punjab (CRM-M-16232-2010, 09.11.2010); M/s S.S. Fertilizers v. State of Punjab (CRM-M-19185-2019, 23.01.2023); M/s Brij Lal & Sons v. State of Punjab (CRM-M-36052-2021, 19.12.2023); and M/s R.S. Fertilizers v. State of Punjab (CRM-M-19157-2019, 28.05.2024).
¶ 14–19Kisan Beej Bhandar, Abohar v. Chief Agricultural Officer, Ferozepur (1990 SCC (Cri) 623) held that a sample drawn from machine-stitched bags attracts the ratio of Ghanvir Singh; FMC India Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryana, 2026(1) RCR (Criminal) 786 reiterated the same position.
¶ 20Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Essential Commodities Act, 1955 Section 3Section 7Section 11
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482
04Reasoning
The court found the facts undisputed: Mosaic was the importer, the invoice was genuine, and the samples were drawn from original machine-stitched bags.
¶ 13, 21No allegation was made in the complaint of tampering, improper storage, or knowledge of the defect by either set of petitioners. The defect was therefore a manufacturing defect for which neither the dealer nor the importer had any control.
¶ 13, 21–22Following the consistent precedent, the court held that criminal liability under Clause 19(a) FCO and Section 3 ECA cannot be fastened on a dealer or importer who merely sold the product in the condition received, without any act or omission attributable to them.
¶ 21The court noted that Manish Gupta and Mohit Chandra were named only by virtue of their supervisory roles, with no specific allegation of individual culpability beyond the invoice and general responsibility for branch business.
¶ 12–13The State's concession on the sample's source and the offence's classification weakened its position.
¶ 7Since the petitioners could not be prosecuted for the manufacturing defect, subjecting them to a criminal trial would be an abuse of process, and inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. was warranted.
¶ 2205Holding
A dealer and an importer/supplier cannot be prosecuted under Clause 19(a) FCO read with Section 3 and Section 7 ECA for a manufacturing defect in a fertilizer drawn from original, sealed, machine-stitched bags, in the absence of allegations of tampering, improper storage, or knowledge of the defect.
¶ 21–22Both petitions are allowed. Complaint COMA/8865-2015 dated 15.12.2015 under Clause 19(A) FCO read with Section 3 ECA is quashed, and all subsequent proceedings are quashed qua the petitioners.
¶ 23Original Court PDF
M/S Mosaic India Private Limited And OrsvsState Of Punjab
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
