01Facts
The four applicants, who are young college students, were in judicial custody in connection with FIR No. 30 of 2026, PS Bhimtal, District Nainital.
¶ 2Ayush Bora is booked under BNS ss. 109, 117(2), 118(1), 190, 191(2), 324(2), 351(2) and 352. Yash Chaudhary is booked under BNS ss. 110, 115, 118(2), 190, 191(2), 324(2), 351(2) and 352.
¶ 2Section 109(1) BNS was added during investigation.
¶ 4The prosecution alleges that on 06.07.2026 at about 11:26 p.m., after the restaurant owner said it had closed, the applicants assaulted the complainant and his brother. The applicants allegedly intercepted the complainant and his uncle about 1.2 km away and assaulted them again.
¶ 5Ramesh Kirola was placed on ventilator support at Krishna Hospital, shifted to Max Super Speciality Hospital, Delhi, on 09.07.2026, and discharged on 14.08.2026.
¶ 5The applicants contend that a medical record dated 13.07.2026 showed extubation, stable vitals, no focal neurological deficit and GCS E4V5M6, and that Kirola suffered sudden cardiac arrest on 14.07.2026.
¶ 8The initial examination at CHC Bhimtal allegedly disclosed no injury indicating intention or knowledge to cause death, and no lethal weapon was used.
¶ 9The complainant opposed bail, citing a head injury, brain swelling and nasal fracture.
¶ 702Issues
i.1. Whether the applicants have made out a case for bail, given the contention that the essential ingredients of s. 109(1) BNS (intention or knowledge to cause death) are not attracted.
¶ 6, 10ii.2. Whether the subsequent deterioration and cardiac arrest of the injured person, and the absence of lethal injuries in the initial medical examination, are relevant to bail at this stage.
¶ 8, 9, 1103Law Applied
The court relied on s. 109(1) BNS (attempt to murder) as the offence in issue, while leaving its ingredients of intention or knowledge to be determined at trial.
¶ 4, 10The court relied on the BNS sections mentioned in the FIR, which were not discussed in detail.
¶ 2Bail may be granted where a prima facie case is not made out on the material at this stage, considering the absence of premeditation, prior enmity, the nature of the weapons, the medical record, and the applicants' youth.
¶ 10–11The court expressly declined to express any opinion on the merits or on the medical causation of the injured person's later condition.
¶ 11–12The court imposed standard bail conditions and reserved the complainant's right to seek cancellation of bail.
¶ 13–14Provisions in the judgment · 10 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 10 provisions
Section 109Section 110Section 115Section 117Section 118Section 190Section 191Section 324Section 351Section 35204Reasoning
The court found that the incident arose from a sudden altercation at a restaurant, with no alleged previous enmity between the parties.
¶ 10Applying the bail framework, the court treated the presence or absence of intention or knowledge to cause death under s. 109(1) BNS as a question for trial, not for bail.
¶ 10The court weighed the lack of premeditation, the nature of the weapons, the initial medical record and the applicants' status as students in favour of bail.
¶ 10The court acknowledged the seriousness of Kirola's injuries and prolonged treatment.
¶ 11The court did not resolve the defence contention that the cardiac arrest was an intervening medical event, deferring that causation question to trial.
¶ 8, 11The judgment does not address the applicants' plea that they were not present at the scene.
¶ 6The court's reasoning rests on the cumulative assessment of facts and circumstances rather than on any single factor.
¶ 1105Holding
Without expressing any opinion on the merits, the court held that the applicants had made out a case for bail, and it allowed all four applications.
¶ 11–12Each applicant is to be released on executing a personal bond and furnishing two sureties of the like amount, to the satisfaction of the concerned Court, subject to conditions: (i) regular attendance before the Trial Court without unnecessary adjournments; (ii) no inducement, threat or promise to persons acquainted with the facts; and (iii) no departure from India without the Trial Court's prior permission.
¶ 13The complainant may apply for cancellation of bail upon misuse or breach of conditions.
¶ 14Original Court PDF
YASH CHAUDHARYvsSTATE OF UTTARAKHAND
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
