Uttarakhand High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Uttarakhand HC Grants Bail to Two Students in Bhimtal Restaurant Assault Case, Leaves Intent to Kill for Trial

AYUSH BORAv.STATE OF UTTARAKHAND

Uttarakhand HC Grants Bail to Two Students in Bhimtal Restaurant Assault Case, Leaves Intent to Kill for Trial. AYUSH BORA vs STATE OF UTTARAKHAND. Uttarakhand High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether, at the bail stage, the ingredients of intention or knowledge under Section 109(1) BNS are prima facie attracted against the applicants, such that bail should be refused.

The court held

The Court held that the applicants had made out a case for bail, without expressing any opinion on the merits or on the medical causation of the injured person's later condition.

It also directed

Both bail applications are allowed.

Each applicant is to be released upon executing a personal bond and furnishing two sureties of equal amount to the satisfaction of the Court concerned, subject to the three conditions in para. 13(i)–(iii).

The complainant may move for cancellation of bail on misuse or breach of conditions.

01Facts

The two applicants, who are in judicial custody in FIR No. 30 of 2026, Police Station Bhimtal, District Nainital, sought bail.

Ayush Bora is charged under Sections 109, 117(2), 118(1), 190, 191(2), 324(2), 351(2) and 352 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), and Yash Chaudhary under Sections 110, 115, 118(2), 190, 191(2), 324(2), 351(2) and 352 BNS.

¶ 2

Section 109(1) BNS was added during investigation.

¶ 4

The prosecution alleges that on 06.07.2026 at about 11:26 p.m., after the restaurant owner said it was closed, the applicants assaulted the complainant and his brother.

¶ 5

The applicants later allegedly intercepted the complainant and his uncle about 1.2 km away and assaulted them again.

¶ 5

Ramesh Kirola was placed on ventilator support, shifted to Max Super Speciality Hospital, Delhi, on 09.07.2026, and discharged on 14.08.2026.

¶ 5

The defence contends the incident was a sudden quarrel without premeditation or prior enmity, that the applicants are college students, and that they were not present at the scene.

¶ 6

The complainant states that the injured suffered a head injury, brain swelling and a nasal fracture requiring prolonged treatment.

¶ 7

The defence relies on a 13.07.2026 medical record showing extubation, stable vitals, no focal neurological deficit and GCS E4V5M6, and on a sudden cardiac arrest on 14.07.2026 at about 4:30 a.m.

¶ 8

The initial CHC Bhimtal examination allegedly disclosed no injury indicating intention or knowledge to cause death, and no lethal weapon was used.

¶ 9

02Issues

i.1. Whether, at the bail stage, the ingredients of intention or knowledge under Section 109(1) BNS are prima facie attracted against the applicants, such that bail should be refused.

¶ 6 · ¶ 10

ii.2. Whether the alleged absence of premeditation, the sudden nature of the altercation, the absence of prior enmity, the nature of injuries and weapons, and the applicants' status as students warrant the grant of bail.

¶ 10 · ¶ 11

iii.3. Whether the subsequent deterioration and cardiac arrest of the injured person, and the CHC examination findings, must be considered in deciding bail, without conclusively attributing death or injury to the incident.

¶ 8 · ¶ 9 · ¶ 11

03Law Applied

The Court decided bail on the basis of the BNS provisions charged, namely Section 109(1) (attempt to murder) and the other listed offences.

¶ 2 · ¶ 4

Section 109(1) BNS is treated as attempt to murder for the purpose of the bail determination.

The Court treated the question of intention or knowledge to cause death as a matter for trial, not for bail determination.

¶ 10

Bail considerations include the absence of premeditation, the circumstances of the occurrence, the nature of weapons, the medical record and the youth of the accused.

¶ 10

The grant of bail was subject to personal bond, two sureties, attendance at trial without unnecessary adjournment, non-inducement of witnesses, and no departure from India without the Trial Court's permission.

¶ 13

The complainant may seek cancellation for misuse or breach of conditions.

¶ 14

No judgment or precedent was cited.

Provisions in the judgment · 10 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 10 provisionsSection 109Section 110Section 115Section 117Section 118Section 190Section 191Section 324Section 351Section 352

04Reasoning

The Court first held that the alleged incident arose from a sudden restaurant altercation with no prior enmity pleaded.

¶ 10

The Court then held that whether the applicants possessed the requisite intention or knowledge under Section 109(1) BNS was a question for trial and could not be decided at this stage.

¶ 10

This avoided a prima facie finding on the mental element, even though the Court was "conscious" of the seriousness of the injuries and prolonged treatment.

¶ 11

The Court weighed the medical record and the submission that the injured had been stabilised and later suffered cardiac arrest, but expressly declined to express any opinion on the medical causation of the later condition.

¶ 11

The Court also relied on the initial CHC findings and the absence of a lethal weapon, although its reasoning on these points is stated only as "relevant considerations."

¶ 9 · ¶ 10

The youth and student status of the applicants was treated as a relevant factor.

¶ 10

Taken together, these factors led the Court to find a prima facie case for bail.

The Court did not analyse the statutory bail threshold or the risk of tampering or flight.

05Holding

The Court held that the applicants had made out a case for bail, without expressing any opinion on the merits or on the medical causation of the injured person's later condition.

¶ 11 · ¶ 12

Both bail applications are allowed.

¶ 12

Each applicant is to be released upon executing a personal bond and furnishing two sureties of equal amount to the satisfaction of the Court concerned, subject to the three conditions in para. 13(i)–(iii).

¶ 13

The complainant may move for cancellation of bail on misuse or breach of conditions.

¶ 14
Uttarakhand High Court

Original Court PDF

AYUSH BORAvsSTATE OF UTTARAKHAND

Uttarakhand High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment