01Facts
The appellant, a commission agency at the New Grain Market, Ladwa, sued brothers Jasmer Singh and Ram Parshad for ₹7,09,090/- (principal ₹4,63,730/- and interest ₹2,45,360/-).
¶ 2It alleged a joint account, an acknowledgment of ₹10,80,730/- on 03.05.2007, a further advance of ₹33,000/- the same day, and adjustment of Ram Parshad's cheque for ₹6,50,000/- dated 19.11.2007 against the outstanding balance.
¶ 2Jasmer Singh denied the liability and the genuineness of the entries.
¶ 3Ram Parshad pleaded that he had no joint account and that the cheque was a loan to the firm.
¶ 3Ram Parshad separately sued the firm for ₹8,85,806/-.
¶ 4The suits were consolidated. The trial court decreed ₹33,000/- against Jasmer Singh alone with 6% interest, dismissed the claim against Ram Parshad, and decreed Ram Parshad's suit for ₹6,50,000/- with 6% interest.
¶ 5The first appellate court dismissed both appeals on 11.03.2022.
¶ 6The firm's evidence included account entries Ex.P3–P25, income tax records Ex.P26–P31, a partner, a handwriting expert and two accountants. The respondents' evidence included a handwriting expert.
¶ 13–1402Issues
i.1. Whether the account entry Ex.P3 (acknowledgment of ₹10,80,730/-) was duly proved so as to establish the respondents' liability.
¶ 12, 14–16ii.2. Whether the income tax returns (Ex.P26–P31) showing the respondents as debtors independently establish the liability.
¶ 19–22iii.3. Whether the ₹6,50,000/- cheque issued by Ram Parshad could lawfully be appropriated towards Jasmer Singh's debt.
¶ 23–26iv.4. Whether the claim is barred by limitation, or whether the acknowledgment and part-payment under Sections 18 and 19 of the Limitation Act, 1963 saved it.
¶ 27–28v.5. Whether the concurrent findings warrant interference in regular second appeal under Section 100 CPC.
¶ 29–3103Law Applied
Section 34 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 makes regularly kept account entries relevant but provides that they alone are not sufficient to charge a person with liability.
¶ 17Hira Lal v. Badkulal, AIR 1953 SC 225: a clear, duly proved acknowledgment of an existing liability is material evidence against its maker, but its execution, contents and connection with the liability must first be established.
¶ 14Chandradhar Goswami v. Gauhati Bank Ltd., AIR 1967 SC 1058: the need for supporting evidence of liability recorded in account entries.
¶ 17Income tax returns prepared by a creditor are its own statements and do not prove the debtor's acceptance of liability.
¶ 20Brotherhood creates no presumption of joint liability or of appropriation of one brother's payment towards the other's debt.
¶ 23The appropriation principle presupposes a debt and a payment on the debtor's behalf or authority.
¶ 25Sections 18 and 19 of the Limitation Act, 1963 require a valid acknowledgment or part-payment, which must be established as a threshold fact.
¶ 27Under Section 100 CPC, interference with concurrent findings of fact is permissible only for perversity, disregard of material evidence, or an error of law giving rise to a substantial question of law, as stated in Kondiba Dagadu Kadam, Santosh Hazari and Hero Vinoth.
¶ 29Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 18Section 19
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
Ex.P3 was not reliable. The entry did not show the dates or particulars from which the ₹10,80,730/- balance arose, and the accountant (PW3) admitted he was not present at the transactions and could not explain the figures.
¶ 15The courts below had examined the entry's contents, the handwriting evidence and the testimony together, and the appellant did not show these findings were perverse.
¶ 16The ₹33,000/- advance was separately proved and was rightly decreed, which showed the courts had not rejected the account books wholesale.
¶ 18The income tax returns could not cure the defects in Ex.P3 or establish joint liability, because they reflected only the firm's own claim.
¶ 20–21On the cheque, the firm's entries did not show it was paid towards Jasmer Singh's debt, and no authorisation from Ram Parshad was produced. The concurrent finding that the cheque was Ram Parshad's loan to the firm was therefore sustained.
¶ 24–26Because the acknowledgment and part-payment were not established, the limitation argument failed at its threshold.
¶ 28The appellant's challenge sought re-appreciation of evidence, which is impermissible in second appeal absent a substantial question of law.
¶ 30–3105Holding
No substantial question of law arose, and the concurrent findings were free from illegality or perversity. Ex.P3 was not proved, the income tax returns did not establish liability, the ₹6,50,000/- cheque could not be appropriated towards Jasmer Singh's debt, and limitation was not saved under Sections 18–19 of the Limitation Act.
¶ 28, 31–32Both regular second appeals (RSA-2059-2022 and RSA-2061-2022) were dismissed. The judgments and decrees dated 11.03.2022 (First Appellate Court) and 22.03.2016 (trial court) were upheld. Pending miscellaneous applications stood disposed of.
¶ 32–33Original Court PDF
Registered Partnership Firm M/S Sunder Singh Sher Singh Commission AgentsvsJasmer Singh And Anr.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
