01Facts
The petitioner, appointed as an Assistant Teacher (Science) on 9 October 2015, sought approval of her appointment and admission to grant-in-aid.
pp. 4–6, 13The authorities rejected her request by communication dated 16 March 2023 and endorsement dated 12 May 2023, relying on the Karnataka Education Department Services (Department of Public Instructions) (Recruitment) (Amendment) Rules, 2016.
pp. 4–6, 13In an earlier petition, the High Court had directed reconsideration of her qualifications obtained from Karnataka University.
pp. 4–6, 13The petitioner challenged the 2023 decisions, relying on a coordinate Bench decision that the 2016 Rules operated prospectively.
pp. 4–6, 1302Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner’s request for approval and grant-in-aid could be rejected by applying the 2016 Amendment Rules to an appointment made on 9 October 2015.
p. 13ii.2. Whether the authorities should reconsider the petitioner’s case under the rules in force on the date of her appointment.
p. 1303Law Applied
The Court applied the coordinate Bench’s decision in W.P. No. 106596 of 2017 (EDN-RES), disposed of on 29 January 2026, which held that the 2016 Amendment Rules operated prospectively and could not affect eligibility accrued under the unamended rules before their publication on 29 September 2016.
pp. 6–12Accordingly, the petitioner’s case was to be considered under the rules prevailing on her appointment date.
p. 1304Reasoning
The petitioner’s appointment pre-dated the 2016 Amendment Rules.
p. 13Applying the coordinate Bench’s ruling on prospective operation, the Court held that the authorities’ reliance on those Rules to reject her request was legally unsustainable.
p. 13The Court did not itself determine that the petitioner was entitled to approval or grant-in-aid; it directed the authorities to consider her case under the rules in force on 9 October 2015.
p. 1305Holding
The writ petition was allowed.
pp. 13–14The respondents were directed to consider the petitioner’s case for admission to grant-in-aid under the rules prevailing on her appointment date, 9 October 2015, and pass appropriate orders.
pp. 13–14The exercise was to be completed within six weeks, with a compliance report filed thereafter.
pp. 13–14Original Court PDF
SMT UJWALA VETALKAR W/O SHAHU NANGNURKARvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
