TDSATAdministrative and Public LawTechnology, Cybercrime, and Data Privacy

Adjudicating officer must record reasons and findings on each party's liability; unreasoned order set aside.

RAMESH G SHAH (DIRECTOR)v.RBL BANK LTD AND ORS

Adjudicating officer must record reasons and findings on each party's liability; unreasoned order set aside.. RAMESH G SHAH (DIRECTOR) vs RBL BANK LTD AND ORS. TDSAT. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the impugned order, which contains no findings, reasons, or discussion of evidence, can be sustained.

The court held

The Tribunal held that the impugned order of 31.03.2021 is unreasoned and cannot stand, because it contains no findings on the liability of the Banks, the TSP, or the Complainant.

It also directed

The appeal is allowed, the impugned order is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the LAO, Gandhi Nagar, Gujarat. The LAO must frame points for determination, examine the pleadings and evidence, and record specific findings on the liability of each Bank, the TSP, and the Complainant, in accordance with RBI guidelines. The LAO must dispose of the complaint preferably within six months of receipt of the order, without bias from the Tribunal's observations. The parties are directed to appear before the LAO on 07.01.2027.

No enhancement of compensation was granted.

01Facts

The Appellant, Ramesh G. Shah (Director), a Gujarat-based complainant (described in places as a "Complainant Company"), lost about Rs. 82,00,000 through unauthorised transactions.

¶ 1

The fraud followed the issue of a duplicate SIM by a franchisee of Vodafone Idea Ltd. (Respondent No. 6) to an unauthorised person, which compromised OTP-based authentication.

¶ 1

After the complaint and a police complaint, part of the amount was recovered, leaving a stated balance of about Rs. 43,00,000.

¶ 1

The Learned Adjudicating Officer (LAO), in Special Civil Complaint No. 8/2019, imposed a penalty of Rs. 2,00,000 on the Telecom Service Provider (TSP) alone, by order dated 31.03.2021.

¶ 1

The order made no finding on the Banks, which held the complainant's account and through which funds were siphoned.

¶ 1

The Complainant claimed Rs. 1,64,00,000 in damages.

¶ 3

The TSP did not appeal, the penalty was deposited, and no Bank appealed.

¶ 1

The Complainant appealed for enhancement, and the Banks were impleaded as Respondents.

¶ 1

By order dated 04.08.2026, the Tribunal confined the appeal to enhancement of compensation.

¶ 1

The Tribunal notes that the impugned order contains no reasons for the Rs. 2,00,000 award, and that the unrecovered balance was left unaddressed.

¶ 2–3

The Tribunal records a figure of Rs. 30,00,000 for the unaddressed sum in para. 2, which conflicts with the Rs. 41,00,000 figure in para. 1.

¶ 1–2

02Issues

i.1. Whether the impugned order, which contains no findings, reasons, or discussion of evidence, can be sustained.

¶ 2 · ¶ 3

ii.2. Whether the liability of the Banks (the account-holding bank and subsequent banks through which funds were withdrawn) required determination.

¶ 3

iii.3. Whether the liability of the TSP and any contributory negligence of the Complainant required specific findings.

¶ 3

iv.4. Whether the matter should be remanded for fresh adjudication, with a time-bound disposal, or whether enhancement of compensation was warranted.

¶ 3–5

03Law Applied

The Tribunal's jurisdiction rests on Section 57 of the Information Technology Act, 2000, read with Section 14(c) of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997.

¶ 1

The judgment proceeds on the principle that an adjudicating order must frame points for determination, consider the pleadings and evidence, and record reasons for its conclusions, failing which it is liable to be set aside.

¶ 3

The judgment relies on the Reserve Bank of India's guidelines and directions on securing customers' confidential personal data and on preventing fraud and cyber-crime siphoning, which the adjudicator was required to consider when assessing bank liability.

¶ 3

The judgment cites no judicial precedent.

The judgment does not expressly state a standard for apportioning liability among the TSP, the banks, and the complainant.

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Information Technology Act, 2000 Section 57

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 Section 14

04Reasoning

The Tribunal first observed that the impugned order rests on a single cryptic conclusion. It frames no issues, discusses no pleadings or evidence, and gives no reasons for the Rs. 2,00,000 penalty on the TSP.

¶ 2–3

The order also omits any finding on the Banks, which were neither held liable nor exonerated.

¶ 3

The Tribunal treated the Complainant's alleged negligence, mentioned in one line, as unsupported by any finding or evidentiary discussion.

¶ 3

On these defects, the Tribunal declined to assess the merits of enhancement. It held that the order could not be sustained as a reasoned adjudication and that the liability of each party had to be determined on the record by the LAO.

¶ 3, 5

Because the Tribunal did not reach the merits, it did not fix a quantum of enhanced compensation. Its direction for a six-month disposal reflects the delay since the 2019 complaint, which the Tribunal described as causing the Complainant continuing hardship.

¶ 4

The Tribunal's statement that the appeal was "not on the merits" shows that the remand was a procedural corrective and not a finding on liability.

¶ 4

The unexplained difference between the Rs. 41,00,000 and Rs. 30,00,000 figures for the unaddressed loss was left for the LAO to resolve on the evidence.

¶ 1–2

05Holding

The Tribunal held that the impugned order of 31.03.2021 is unreasoned and cannot stand, because it contains no findings on the liability of the Banks, the TSP, or the Complainant.

¶ 2–3

The appeal is allowed, the impugned order is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the LAO, Gandhi Nagar, Gujarat. The LAO must frame points for determination, examine the pleadings and evidence, and record specific findings on the liability of each Bank, the TSP, and the Complainant, in accordance with RBI guidelines. The LAO must dispose of the complaint preferably within six months of receipt of the order, without bias from the Tribunal's observations. The parties are directed to appear before the LAO on 07.01.2027.

¶ 3, 4–5

No enhancement of compensation was granted.

TDSAT

Original Court PDF

RAMESH G SHAH (DIRECTOR)vsRBL BANK LTD AND ORS

TDSAT · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment