01Facts
The Petitioner, Hathway Digital Ltd., an MSO licensed under the Cable Television Networks Act, and the Respondent, Sonar Bangla, a broadcaster and partnership firm, executed an MOU dated 08.02.2019 for channel promotion in West Bengal at Rs. 30,00,000 per annum plus taxes, payable monthly in advance, for 01.02.2019 to 31.01.2020
¶ 1 · ¶ 2 · ¶ 10The MOU expired on 31.01.2020
¶ 11The Petitioner alleged that the Respondent verbally requested continuation on the same terms, promising payment and a fresh agreement, and that services continued until disconnection on 12.08.2020
¶ 2 · ¶ 11The Petitioner issued a legal notice dated 10.03.2020, a demand notice dated 14.07.2020 for Rs. 20,65,000 (covering 01.02.2020 to 31.07.2020), and a disconnection notice dated 20.07.2020
¶ 2 · ¶ 3 · ¶ 11The Respondent's email of 30.06.2020 offered to pay dues only up to March 2020, subject to a 30% discount and conditions, and the Petitioner alleged that this email admitted Rs. 8,85,000
¶ 2 · ¶ 3The Respondent denied receipt of invoices, denied any renewal or consent, and contended that it was not liable for charges from February 2020 onward because of the COVID-19 lockdown and Cyclone Amphan
¶ 3The Respondent's affidavit (Para 8) stated that the demand for Rs. 8,85,000 was conditional and that the Rs. 20,65,000 demand was made only in July 2020
¶ 11The Petitioner sought Rs. 20,65,000 with 20% interest and an interim order for the admitted Rs. 8,85,000 under Order XII Rule 6 CPC
¶ 1 · ¶ 202Issues
i.1. Whether the petition is maintainable in its present form.
¶ 5(1) · decided at para. 10ii.2. Whether the petition is liable to be dismissed for concealment of material facts, including the demand notice dated 10.03.2020.
¶ 5(2) · decided at para. 11iii.3. Whether the Respondent is in breach of the MOU.
¶ 5(3) · decided at para. 11iv.4. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to a decree for Rs. 20,65,000 with interest at 24% p.a.
¶ 5(4) · decided at paras. 11–12v.5. What other relief, if any, the Petitioner is entitled to.
¶ 5(5) · decided at Order03Law Applied
The Tribunal's jurisdiction arises under Sections 14 and 14A of the TRAI Act, 1997
¶ 1The Tribunal applied the Clause 17 disconnection mechanism of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services Interconnection (Addressable Systems) Regulations, 2017
¶ 11On burden of proof, the Tribunal relied on Section 102 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872
¶ 9The party asserting a fact bears the initial onus, which shifts upon discharge (Anil Rishi v. Gurbaksh Singh)
¶ 9Once both sides have led all evidence, the burden question loses importance, but misplacing it vitiates findings (Premlata v. Arhant Kumar Jain)
¶ 9The burden of proof never shifts while the onus of proof does (Lakshman v. Venkateswarlu; Raghvamma v. A. Cherry Chamma)
¶ 9A plaintiff must succeed on its own evidence, not on the defendant's weakness (State of J v. Hindustan Forest Co.)
¶ 9Civil claims are decided on preponderance of probabilities (M. Krishnan v. Vijay Singh)
¶ 9On interest, the Tribunal applied its own consistent practice of awarding 9% simple interest in comparable petitions
¶ 12Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 Section 14
04Reasoning
The Tribunal first held that the Petitioner, an MSO and "service provider" under the TRAI Act, and the Respondent, a channel provider, were in a commercial relationship under the MOU. The dispute over promotional charges fell within jurisdiction and limitation, so Issue 1 was decided for the Petitioner
¶ 10On Issues 2–4, the Tribunal treated the MOU's existence, its terms and its expiry on 31.01.2020 as undisputed
¶ 11The Tribunal treated the Respondent's continued use of the service after expiry, its verbal request for continuation, and its unanswered assurances on renewal as an implied consent to continue on the MOU terms. It attributed the failure to execute a formal renewal to the pandemic, not to a termination of the relationship
¶ 11The Tribunal relied on the Respondent's own admission in its reply (Para 2) that the Petitioner carried the channel until 12.08.2020
¶ 11The Tribunal found the Respondent's Para 8 position that its offer was conditional to be an admission of liability, not a rebuttal
¶ 11Because the Respondent produced no statement of account, the Tribunal accepted the Petitioner's statement of account, under which the undisputed MOU-period balance was Rs. 2,95,000. It held that this balance was payable and that the Respondent had not shown otherwise
¶ 11The Tribunal did not separately address the concealment objection under Issue 2, the Respondent's denial of receipt of invoices, or the Petitioner's failure to file a statement of account. It also did not state its reasons for awarding 9% rather than the 24% sought
¶ 11–1205Holding
All issues were decided in the Petitioner's favour. The Tribunal held that the petition is maintainable, the Respondent is in breach of the MOU by non-payment for services availed after its expiry, and the Petitioner is entitled to recovery
¶ 10–11The Tribunal decreed the petition and directed the Respondent to pay Rs. 20,65,000 within two months, with 9% simple interest pendente lite and future, failing which execution would follow
¶ 12 · OrderThe Tribunal did not separately address the Petitioner's interim application for the admitted Rs. 8,85,000
Original Court PDF
HATHWAY DIGITAL LTDvsSONAR BANGLA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
