01Facts
The appellant, a sole proprietor trading as M/s Gupta Infotech (manufacturer of compact fluorescent lamps), insured his plant, machinery, stock and goods with Respondent No. 1 (insurer) under a fire and burglary policy, No. YB00013052000102, valid 04.09.2015 to 03.09.2016, with a sum insured of Rs. 14.5 crore.
¶ 4Respondent No. 2 is the appellant's bank, which extended credit facilities.
¶ 4A fire occurred at the appellant's premises in the SEZ on 08.06.2016.
¶ 5, 27The appellant's auditor assessed the loss at Rs. 10,74,79,736/-.
¶ 6The insurer's surveyor assessed it at Rs. 1,94,46,960/- in two reports dated 12.05.2017 (original and supplementary).
¶ 6A draft settlement agreement was handed over on 20.06.2017, and the appellant signed the final agreement at the insurer's Chennai office on 23.06.2017.
¶ 7–9The appellant alleged misrepresentation, force and undue influence, and lodged a police complaint at Ramnagar PS, Kolkata, on 27.06.2017.
¶ 10The amount was remitted to his account with Respondent No. 2 and adjusted against his credit facilities.
¶ 11The Single Judge dismissed the suit, holding that the appellant failed to prove vitiation of the settlement.
¶ 14The appellant appealed.
¶ 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the written settlement agreement dated 23.06.2017 is void or voidable on account of misrepresentation, force or undue influence, and is therefore not binding on the appellant.
¶ 17, 28, 32–33, 36ii.2. Whether the surveyor's assessment of quantum, including the deduction of depreciation, can be reopened despite the settlement.
¶ 16, 34iii.3. Whether the reliance by the Single Judge on the NOC documents, admittedly not formally exhibited, vitiates the judgment.
¶ 18, 35iv.4. Whether the surveyor's supplementary report was shaped at the insurer's instance and is therefore not an objective assessment.
¶ 19, 37v.5. Whether Respondent No. 2 (bank) can be held liable under the contract of insurance, having regard to Section 230 of the Contract Act, 1872.
¶ 26, 3803Law Applied
Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, under which an agent acting for a disclosed principal cannot be sued on the contract made on the principal's behalf.
¶ 26, 38The principle, drawn from National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Boghara Polyfab Pvt. Ltd., (2009) 1 SCC 267, that a settlement or discharge voucher is void if its executant establishes fraud, coercion or undue influence, but that this is conditional on proof, and the civil court must examine the evidence before rejecting the claim.
¶ 36The general principle that a written instrument may be avoided on proof of fraud, coercion or undue influence, and that a party who signed a written settlement is otherwise bound by it.
¶ 33The burden of establishing the vitiating circumstance lies on the party alleging it.
¶ 31, 33, 36Facts not pleaded and not proved cannot be relied upon.
¶ 14, 24, 36A police complaint is not, by itself, proof of its contents.
¶ 31A settled quantum cannot be reopened while the settlement stands.
¶ 34Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 230
04Reasoning
The Court held that the appellant's case rested on the settlement, and that the vitiation plea failed for want of proof.
¶ 28The Court found that the appellant had notice of the surveyor's assessment and received the draft agreement three days before execution, and that both drafts carried the same amount.
¶ 33, 36The agreement was signed on every page before two witnesses, one of whom was the appellant's own representative, and none of the witnesses was examined by the appellant.
¶ 30, 33, 36The alleged influencing representative was never identified, and the promise of a higher payment was neither pleaded nor proved; the assurance that the balance would be "dealt with favourably" was treated as an expression of hope, not a misrepresentation or coercion.
¶ 36The Court distinguished Boghara Polyfab as conditional on proof, which was absent here.
¶ 36The appellant's post-execution conduct undermined his claim: he did not complain at Chennai, where the cause of action arose, and lodged a complaint in Kolkata only four days later, with no evidence of any resulting investigation.
¶ 29, 31On the supplementary report, the Court held that it was prepared at the appellant's own request after a joint meeting in which he advanced his own contentions, which reflects a negotiating party rather than one whose will was overborne.
¶ 37On the NOC documents, the Court held that even if the Single Judge erred, the error would not assist the appellant because the case rests on the admitted written settlement.
¶ 35Since the settlement resolved quantum, the depreciation challenge did not arise.
¶ 34On the bank's liability, the Court held that Respondent No. 2 acted as agent of the disclosed principal, Respondent No. 1, in the insurance contract, so no decree on that contract could lie against it under Section 230.
¶ 3805Holding
The Court held that the appellant failed to prove misrepresentation, force or undue influence, and that the settlement agreement dated 23.06.2017 binds him.
¶ 33, 36The surveyor's assessment cannot be reopened, and the alleged procedural defects regarding the NOC documents are immaterial.
¶ 34–35Respondent No. 2 cannot be sued on the insurance contract under Section 230 of the Contract Act.
¶ 38No ground for interference was found, and the appeal was dismissed, with the Single Judge's judgment and decree affirmed. Connected applications were disposed of, and interim orders, if any, were vacated.
¶ 39–42Original Court PDF
SAURABH GUPTAvsROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED AND ORS.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
