Calcutta High CourtAdministrative and Public LawConstitutional Law

Appellate rejection of Scheduled Tribe certificate cancellation set aside for failure to consider old ancestral records.

BHUPATI MAJHI AND ORS.v.STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Appellate rejection of Scheduled Tribe certificate cancellation set aside for failure to consider old ancestral records.. BHUPATI MAJHI AND ORS. vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the non-issuance of a show-cause notice under Rule 3(3) of the 1995 Rules vitiates the cancellation proceedings, where the ground was not raised before the Appellate Authority and no prejudice is shown.

The court held

On issue 1, the Rule 3(3) violation did not afford relief because the ground was not raised before the Appellate Authority and no prejudice was shown.

It also directed

On issues 2 and 3, the Appellate Authority's order was liable to be set aside because it failed to consider the 1950 deed and the Record of Rights, which are vital to the caste inquiry.

The impugned order dated 04.09.2025 is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the Appellate Authority. The Appellate Authority must determine (a) whether the Joyram in the Election Commission identity card is the same person as the Joyram Majhi in the Record of Rights and the 1950 deed, and (b) whether that Joyram was the petitioners' ancestor. The authority must afford the petitioners a hearing within six weeks of communication of the order, pass a reasoned order within two weeks of the hearing, and may call for original records. The petitioners may produce further records. The writ petition is disposed of without costs.

01Facts

The petitioners claimed to belong to the Santal Scheduled Tribe.

¶ 4

The Sub-Divisional Officer (SDO), Khatra, issued Scheduled Tribe certificates to petitioner no. 1 on 24.06.2022 and to the other petitioners on 30.11.2022.

¶ 5

Following complaints from fifty-three persons alleging fraudulent procurement, the SDO initiated proceedings under Rule 3 of the West Bengal Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Identification) Rules, 1995 ("1995 Rules") and, on 10.12.2024, cancelled the certificates under Rule 5.

¶ 6–8, 17–19

The SDO found inconsistencies in the petitioners' accounts of social structure, language, deities and rituals.

¶ 9

The petitioners' writ petition (WPA 5368 of 2025) was dismissed with liberty to appeal.

¶ 10

Their appeal under Rule 7G was rejected by the Appellate Authority on 04.09.2025, which found discrepancies in family-tree statements, the absence of ancestral documents, inability to speak Santali or write Olchiki, and conflicting deity accounts.

¶ 11, 2

Before the High Court, the petitioners contended that no show-cause notice under Rule 3(3) was issued and relied on a Record of Rights (p. 17) recording Joyram Majhi as "Santal," a 1950 deed (p. 21) recording Babulal Majhi as "Santal," and a Gram Panchayat lineage chart.

¶ 12–15

The State argued that the certificates were issued during the Duare Sarkar scheme and were obtained fraudulently.

¶ 17–21

02Issues

i.1. Whether the non-issuance of a show-cause notice under Rule 3(3) of the 1995 Rules vitiates the cancellation proceedings, where the ground was not raised before the Appellate Authority and no prejudice is shown.

¶ 24–30

ii.2. Whether the Appellate Authority's rejection of the appeal is amenable to judicial interference, given the limited scope of judicial review over administrative and quasi-judicial decisions.

¶ 31, 36

iii.3. Whether the Appellate Authority was bound to consider the old Records of Rights and the 1950 deed, which bear on whether the petitioners' ancestors were Santal, before concluding that the petitioners do not belong to the Santal tribe.

¶ 33–37

03Law Applied

Rule 3(3) of the 1995 Rules requires a show-cause notice before action against a certificate holder, and is treated as a statutory precondition to proceedings.

¶ 12, 25, 29

Where a statute prescribes a manner of performance, the act must be done in that manner or not at all.

¶ 25

A point not raised before the appellate forum cannot be raised for the first time in writ proceedings.

¶ 28

The settled limits of judicial review of administrative or quasi-judicial decisions are illegality, excess of power, error of law, breach of natural justice, unreasonableness, or perversity.

¶ 31

Anand v. Committee for Scrutiny and Verification of Tribe Claims, 2012 (1) SCC 113 holds that pre-Independence documents carry greater probative value on caste status, that the first generation to attend school may receive the benefit of doubt, and that doubts on documents must be tested through oral evidence with an opportunity to the applicant.

¶ 16, 32

Whether two persons with the same name are the same individual is a disputed question of fact.

¶ 34

04Reasoning

The court held that the absence of a Rule 3(3) notice was a genuine violation.

¶ 24

The petitioners had not raised this ground in their appeal memorandum before the Appellate Authority, so they could not raise it for the first time in writ proceedings.

¶ 28

The petitioners had been heard, no procedural unfairness was alleged, and they were given later opportunities to substantiate their claims, so no prejudice was shown.

¶ 30

The court therefore declined to set aside the proceedings on this ground.

¶ 26, 30

The Appellate Authority's findings rested on discrepancies in oral statements and the absence of ancestral documents.

¶ 11

The court found that the Appellate Authority had not considered the 1950 deed and the Record of Rights recording Joyram as Santal, which the court treated as "vital pieces of evidence" under Anand.

¶ 32–33, 35

Because the material was not considered, the court held that the order was vitiated by non-consideration of relevant material, which falls within the recognised grounds of review.

¶ 31, 36

The court refrained from deciding whether the Joyram in the Record of Rights is the petitioners' ancestor, since that is a disputed fact for the authority to determine.

¶ 34, 37

The petitioners' rights were held to be at stake, so remand was appropriate rather than a final determination.

¶ 36

05Holding

On issue 1, the Rule 3(3) violation did not afford relief because the ground was not raised before the Appellate Authority and no prejudice was shown.

¶ 28, 30

On issues 2 and 3, the Appellate Authority's order was liable to be set aside because it failed to consider the 1950 deed and the Record of Rights, which are vital to the caste inquiry.

¶ 35–36

The impugned order dated 04.09.2025 is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the Appellate Authority. The Appellate Authority must determine (a) whether the Joyram in the Election Commission identity card is the same person as the Joyram Majhi in the Record of Rights and the 1950 deed, and (b) whether that Joyram was the petitioners' ancestor. The authority must afford the petitioners a hearing within six weeks of communication of the order, pass a reasoned order within two weeks of the hearing, and may call for original records. The petitioners may produce further records. The writ petition is disposed of without costs.

¶ 36–41
Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

BHUPATI MAJHI AND ORS.vsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Calcutta High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment