Calcutta High CourtAdministrative and Public LawBanking and Finance Law

Bank must give borrowers the full forensic audit report before classifying account as fraud: Calcutta HC quashes PNB's order

RAJARAM SEVAK MULTIPURPOSE COLD STORAGE (P) LTD. AND ORS.v.PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.

Bank must give borrowers the full forensic audit report before classifying account as fraud: Calcutta HC quashes PNB's order. RAJARAM SEVAK MULTIPURPOSE COLD STORAGE (P) LTD. AND ORS. vs PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the procedure adopted by the Bank before classifying the petitioners' loan accounts as "fraud" satisfied the requirements of natural justice, the applicable RBI framework, and settled law.

The court held

The Bank was bound to furnish the FAR to the petitioners, subject only to reasoned redaction of portions affecting third-party rights, and the classification made without such disclosure violated natural justice.

It also directed

The writ petition was disposed of with the following directions: (i) the communication dated 21.03.2024 is set aside; (ii) the show-cause notice stands revived; (iii) the Bank must furnish the FAR, recording reasons for any redaction; (iv) the petitioners must be given a reasonable opportunity to make a representation on the FAR; (v) the competent authority must then decide afresh by a reasoned, speaking order under the RBI Directions. The Court made no finding on the merits of the fraud allegations. The DRT proceedings are not affected. No costs were awarded.

01Facts

The petitioners, a borrower company and its directors engaged in manufacturing organic manure, challenged a show-cause notice dated 27.12.2023 and a later communication classifying their loan accounts as "fraud".

¶ 1

The credit facilities were taken over from United Bank of India, which later amalgamated with the respondent Bank.

¶ 2, 7

The petitioners attributed their financial stress to demonetisation and market conditions, and alleged that restructuring requests were ignored and accounts were wrongly classified as NPA.

¶ 3–5

Earlier SARFAESI proceedings (WPO 9820 of 2021 and MAT 643 of 2021) and a Debts Recovery Tribunal application (OA 440 of 2022) remained pending in parallel.

¶ 6–7, 12–13

The Bank issued the show-cause notice on 27.12.2023 under the RBI Master Directions on Frauds, 2016 and FRMD Circular No. 70/2023, after appointing a forensic auditor.

¶ 11, 14

The petitioners' request for documents, including the FAR, went unanswered.

¶ 8, 20

The Bank asserted that only extracts of the FAR were furnished with the notice.

¶ 15, 19

The Bank then classified the accounts as fraud by an order dated 21.03.2024, which it disclosed only in its later affidavit, and reported the classification to the RBI on 16.03.2024.

¶ 16, 21–23

The petitioners pleaded that the order was "For Approval," was never dispatched, and was not referred to in the 04.04.2024 intimation.

¶ 17, 23

A coordinate Bench had quashed the classification on 29.04.2024. The Division Bench remanded the matter on 16.09.2025 so the Bank could file its affidavit-in-opposition.

¶ 22

The Bank admitted that the entire FAR had not been supplied and that parts were withheld as relating to bank officials and third parties.

¶ 38

02Issues

i.1. Whether the procedure adopted by the Bank before classifying the petitioners' loan accounts as "fraud" satisfied the requirements of natural justice, the applicable RBI framework, and settled law.

¶ 31

ii.2. Whether the Bank could withhold the FAR, or the bulk of it, on the ground that it contained information about bank officials and third parties, and whether the FRMD Circular's internal procedure could validate a non-compliant classification.

¶ 39–41, 43

03Law Applied

State Bank of India v. Rajesh Agarwal ((2023) 6 SCC 1) holds that fraud classification carries serious civil consequences and requires the principle of audi alteram partem to be read into the RBI Master Directions, so that the borrower must be given notice, the forensic audit findings, and an opportunity to make a representation before a reasoned decision.

¶ 32–33

State Bank of India v. Amit Iron Private Limited (2026 INSC 323) holds that no right to a personal hearing exists, but that furnishing audit reports, including the FAR, is mandatory. Withholding is permitted only for specific portions affecting third-party privacy, for reasons recorded, and the power of redaction must not be used unreasonably.

¶ 34–37, 44

Article 141 of the Constitution provides that Supreme Court law binds all authorities, so internal circulars cannot override it.

¶ 40

Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel ((1985) 3 SCC 398) sets out principles on disclosure of allegations, evidence, and documents.

¶ 33

Jurisdiction under Article 226 is confined to the decision-making process and does not extend to the merits of the fraud allegations.

¶ 42–43

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Recovery Of Debts And Bankruptcy Act, 1993 Section 19

04Reasoning

The FRMD Circular, though unchallenged, is an internal guideline and does not immunise action taken under it from judicial review. The question was therefore whether the procedure met the Supreme Court's standard, not whether the Bank had followed its own circular.

¶ 39–40

The Bank admitted that the FAR was not supplied in full and gave only a general justification for withholding it. It did not identify the particular portions withheld or record reasons for each, as Amit Iron requires. The presence of statements by bank officials did not by itself justify withholding the whole report.

¶ 38, 41

The Court therefore found that the petitioners had not been given a meaningful opportunity to answer the case against them, and that the 21.03.2024 communication could not stand.

¶ 43, 45

The Court expressly declined to examine the merits of the fraud allegations, leaving them to the competent authority.

¶ 42, 48

05Holding

The Bank was bound to furnish the FAR to the petitioners, subject only to reasoned redaction of portions affecting third-party rights, and the classification made without such disclosure violated natural justice.

¶ 43, 45

The writ petition was disposed of with the following directions: (i) the communication dated 21.03.2024 is set aside; (ii) the show-cause notice stands revived; (iii) the Bank must furnish the FAR, recording reasons for any redaction; (iv) the petitioners must be given a reasonable opportunity to make a representation on the FAR; (v) the competent authority must then decide afresh by a reasoned, speaking order under the RBI Directions. The Court made no finding on the merits of the fraud allegations. The DRT proceedings are not affected. No costs were awarded.

¶ 46–49, 51
Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

RAJARAM SEVAK MULTIPURPOSE COLD STORAGE (P) LTD. AND ORS.vsPUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.

Calcutta High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment