01Facts
The petitioner, a respondent before the West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal (LRTT) in O.A. 442 of 2024, challenged the Tribunal's order dated 11 April 2025, which set aside a notice issued by the BL&LRO.
¶ 2, 5The petitioner advanced three grounds. First, respondent nos. 4, 5 and 7 before the Tribunal (Motijaan Bibi, Jamat Molla and Labujan Bibi) were allegedly deceased when the order was passed, rendering it a nullity.
¶ 3Second, the petitioner's engaged advocate could not appear on the relevant date, so the petitioner's version was not placed before the Tribunal.
¶ 4Third, the Tribunal's setting aside of the notice rested on the premise that two suits were pending over the same dispute, whereas no suit was pending on the relevant date.
¶ 5–6The private respondents (applicants before the Tribunal) were the contesting parties.
¶ 902Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal's order dated 11 April 2025 is vitiated, as a nullity or otherwise, because certain respondents were allegedly deceased on the date it was passed.
¶ 3, 7, 8ii.2. Whether the non-appearance of the petitioner's advocate on the relevant date prevented the petitioner's case from being placed before the Tribunal, warranting re-hearing.
¶ 4, 7iii.3. Whether the Tribunal's basis for setting aside the BL&LRO notice, namely the pendency of two suits over the same subject matter, was sustainable when no suit was allegedly pending.
¶ 5, 6, 10, 1103Law Applied
The judgment cites no statute, rule, or precedent.
A tribunal order passed without bringing the legal heirs of a deceased party on record may be challenged for want of proper representation, and the defect is curable by substitution or impleadment of the heirs under the Tribunal's procedure.
¶ 3, 8, 9A party's right to be heard requires that both sides be given an opportunity to present evidence before a jurisdictional or adjudicatory finding is made.
¶ 8, 10The pendency of a suit concerning the same subject matter is a fact to be established on evidence, not assumed, before it can ground the setting aside of an administrative notice.
¶ 10, 1104Reasoning
The Court did not decide the merits of any ground. It accepted that the two questions raised, the deceased-respondent issue and the absence of any pending suit, were substantial enough to require the Tribunal's reconsideration.
¶ 7Because the Tribunal's conclusion on the BL&LRO notice depended on the premise that two suits were pending, and the petitioner asserted that no suit existed on the relevant date, the Court held that this factual premise must be tested on evidence.
¶ 5, 6, 10The Court addressed the deceased-respondent point by requiring the Tribunal first to determine whether respondents were dead on the date of the order. If so, the private respondents must be given an opportunity to apply for substitution or impleadment of the legal heirs.
¶ 8, 9The advocate-absence ground is not separately ruled upon; it is subsumed within the general direction to re-hear both parties on merits.
¶ 7, 8The Court left the nullity question, and the factual finding on pendency of suits, entirely to the Tribunal.
05Holding
The Court answered none of the three issues on their merits. It held that the Tribunal ought to consider the questions raised, and it allowed the writ petition on contest.
¶ 7, 8It set aside the Tribunal's order dated 11 April 2025 in O.A. 442 of 2024 and directed a fresh hearing with opportunity to both parties, specifically addressing whether any respondent was deceased on the date of the order. If so, the Tribunal must permit substitution or impleadment of the heirs. The Tribunal must then determine, on evidence, whether any suit was pending on the same subject matter. If none was pending, it must adjudicate the validity of the BL&LRO notice on merits. The Tribunal was asked to conclude within eight months of communication of the order. M.A. 785 of 2025 and M.A. 786 of 2025, which sought review of the same order, were deemed disposed of. No order as to costs was made.
¶ 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14Original Court PDF
KANGAL MOLLAvsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
