Calcutta High CourtArbitration and MediationAdministrative and Public Law

Writ courts will not adjudicate MSME classification; the objection that a claimant was unregistered at contract date lies with the arbitral tribunal.

ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICEv.STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Writ courts will not adjudicate MSME classification; the objection that a claimant was unregistered at contract date lies with the arbitral tribunal.. ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether respondent no. 3 can claim the status of a "micro or small enterprise" or "supplier" under the MSMED Act, 2006, so as to invoke Section 18, where it was not registered on the date of the contract and registered only subsequently.

The court held

The Court did not finally decide whether respondent no. 3 is a "micro or small enterprise" or "supplier" under the MSMED Act.

It also directed

The Court held that the question whether the claimant was a "supplier" on the contract date is jurisdictional and must first be decided by the Arbitral Tribunal, which had been constituted under Section 18(3).

The Court directed the Tribunal to decide the maintainability and jurisdictional issues, preferably within eight weeks of receipt of the order.

The writ petition and all connected applications were disposed of.

The objection to the Facilitation Council member sitting on the Tribunal (Tamil Nadu Cements reference pending before a Larger Bench) was not adjudicated.

The Court noted an inconsistency in the record on the Udyam registration date (23.03.2022 at para. 13, 21–22; 23.03.2023 at para. 4), which the Tribunal should resolve on the evidence.

The outcome of the Larger Bench reference on Tamil Nadu Cements is pending.

01Facts

The petitioner invited tenders on 10.10.2018 for the supply, implementation and maintenance of a DMR Tier III Trunked Wireless Communication System in Thrissur District, valued at Rs. 14.728 crores.

Respondent no. 3 was the successful bidder, and an agreement was executed on 22.03.2019.

¶ 2

Under Clause 12(1), the work was to be completed within six months, i.e., by 22.09.2019.

¶ 3

The petitioner alleges that the work was not completed and the system was never commissioned.

¶ 4

Respondent no. 3 was not registered under the MSMED Act, 2006 on the date of the agreement. Its Udyam registration is recorded as 23.03.2022 in one place and 23.03.2023 in another.

¶ 13, 21, 22 · ¶ 4

Respondent no. 3 filed a reference before the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council (MSEFC) on 16.10.2023.

¶ 21

The Council terminated conciliation on 28.03.2024 and referred the dispute to arbitration under Section 18(3) without deciding the petitioner's maintainability objection.

¶ 6, 23

The petitioner raised the objection in its defence statement, contending that respondent no. 3 was not a "supplier" on the contract date and was not a manufacturer.

¶ 5, 22–23

The petitioner also objected to Mr. Alok Tibrewal, a former Facilitation Council member, sitting on the Arbitral Tribunal.

¶ 8

The petitioner filed this writ petition on 09.08.2024.

¶ 12

The arbitral proceedings had continued, with respondent no. 3's statement of claim filed on 16.04.2024 and the petitioner's defence filed on 02.05.2025.

¶ 12

02Issues

i.1. Whether respondent no. 3 can claim the status of a "micro or small enterprise" or "supplier" under the MSMED Act, 2006, so as to invoke Section 18, where it was not registered on the date of the contract and registered only subsequently.

¶ 1, 21, 24

ii.2. Whether the MSEFC/Arbitral Tribunal has jurisdiction to proceed with arbitration when the jurisdictional objection was raised before it and remains undecided.

¶ 23, 25

iii.3. Whether a former member of the Facilitation Council may sit as a member of the Arbitral Tribunal, as raised by the petitioner under Tamil Nadu Cements. (Raised but not adjudicated by the Court.)

¶ 8–9

03Law Applied

Sections 18(1)–(5) of the MSMED Act, 2006 provide for reference to the MSEFC for disputes over amounts due under Section 17, and for conciliation and arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

¶ 14

Jharkhand Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan (2021) 19 SCC 206 holds that conciliation and arbitration under Section 18 are distinct processes that cannot be clubbed, and that the Council must follow Arbitration Act procedure in arbitration.

¶ 15

India Glycols Ltd. v. S.R. Technologies (2025) 5 SCC 780 describes the statutory remedy under Sections 18–19 of the MSMED Act.

¶ 16

Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd. v. Mahakali Foods Pvt. Ltd. (2023) 3 SCC 401 (quoting Silpi Industries) holds that a party cannot become a micro/small enterprise or "supplier" for MSMED benefits by later registration, as such registration operates only prospectively, and that a Facilitation Council may decide whether a party was a "supplier" on the contract date as a jurisdictional issue acting as Arbitral Tribunal.

¶ 24

Section 18(4) confers arbitral jurisdiction on the Council in disputes between a supplier and buyer.

¶ 14

Classification of enterprises under Sections 2, 7 and 8 of the MSMED Act is for the authorities designated under the Act, not the High Court in writ proceedings.

¶ 18–20

Provisions in the judgment · 33 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 Section 2Section 7Section 8Section 15Section 16Section 17Section 18Section 19

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 24 provisionsSection 7Section 16Section 20Section 23Section 24Section 25Section 34Section 65Section 66Section 67Section 68Section 69Section 70Section 71Section 72Section 73Section 74Section 75Section 76Section 77Section 78Section 79Section 80Section 81

Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951 Section 1

04Reasoning

The classification of an enterprise under the MSMED Act is a function of the statutory authorities, not of the writ court, and the Court therefore declined to determine whether respondent no. 3 was an MSME.

¶ 20

The Court recorded the admitted position that respondent no. 3 was not registered on the date of the 22.03.2019 agreement.

¶ 21

Applying Gujarat State Civil Supplies (para. 51), the Court observed that subsequent registration cannot operate retrospectively, but that the jurisdictional question of whether a party was a "supplier" on the contract date may be decided by the Council acting as Arbitral Tribunal.

¶ 24–25

Because the petitioner had already raised the maintainability and jurisdictional objections in its defence statement before the Tribunal, the Court found the proper course was to have the Tribunal decide them first.

¶ 25

The Court did not decide the merits of the MSME status question and did not address the Tamil Nadu Cements objection to the Facilitation Council member sitting on the Tribunal.

¶ 8–9

The Court's observations on the respondents' delay and the petitioner's failure to inform the Tribunal of the writ petition were recorded as party submissions, not findings.

¶ 12

The Court did not expressly rule on the maintainability of the writ petition, though it recorded the competing authorities on that point.

¶ 15–16

05Holding

The Court did not finally decide whether respondent no. 3 is a "micro or small enterprise" or "supplier" under the MSMED Act.

¶ 24–25

The Court held that the question whether the claimant was a "supplier" on the contract date is jurisdictional and must first be decided by the Arbitral Tribunal, which had been constituted under Section 18(3).

¶ 24–25

The Court directed the Tribunal to decide the maintainability and jurisdictional issues, preferably within eight weeks of receipt of the order.

¶ 26

The writ petition and all connected applications were disposed of.

¶ 27

The objection to the Facilitation Council member sitting on the Tribunal (Tamil Nadu Cements reference pending before a Larger Bench) was not adjudicated.

¶ 8–9, 26

The Court noted an inconsistency in the record on the Udyam registration date (23.03.2022 at para. 13, 21–22; 23.03.2023 at para. 4), which the Tribunal should resolve on the evidence.

¶ 4, 13, 21–22

The outcome of the Larger Bench reference on Tamil Nadu Cements is pending.

Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICEvsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Calcutta High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment