01Facts
On the night of 17–18.03.2024, a five-storied under-construction building at J-506B/C, Azhar Molla Bagan, Kolkata, collapsed, damaging adjoining single-storey tiled structures and trapping occupants.
Seven persons were found dead initially, and the prosecution later stated that 15 persons died.
p. 2 · p. 5 · p. 7 · p. 28The petitioner, Md. Wasim @ Wassi, was described by locals as the promoter/developer.
p. 2Garden Reach P.S. Case No. 55 of 2024 was registered under Sections 302/307/288/427/34 IPC.
p. 3The Kolkata Municipal Corporation reported that no permission had been obtained for construction.
p. 9A Jadavpur University interim report found concrete quality doubtful, column dimensions below IS-code minima, and steel substandard.
p. 9The petitioner was described as a financer, while day-to-day work was run by Abdul Rauf Nizami @ Sheru (deceased) and co-accused Sk. Ripon, and witnesses stated that Ripon directed construction.
p. 4 · p. 9The charge-sheet (No. 66 of 2024, dated 13.06.2024) alleges that the petitioner directed labourers to mix materials in improper proportions and used inferior materials.
pp. 3–4 · p. 28The petitioner has a criminal history, including a conviction under Sections 395/397 IPC and the Arms Act.
p. 10The Trial Court (ASJ, 14th Court, Alipore; Sessions Trial No. 127 of 2024) framed charges under Sections 120B/302/307/427 IPC on 11.12.2024, and the petitioner challenged that order in revision.
pp. 1–302Issues
i.1. Whether the charge framed under Sections 302/307/120B IPC is vitiated because the prosecution did not open its case under Section 226 CrPC and the charge was framed on a draft charge without hearing the accused.
p. 8 · ¶ 8 · ¶ 13–15ii.2. Whether the ingredients of murder (Section 302) and attempted murder (Section 307) are absent on the material, such that the charge should be altered to culpable homicide not amounting to murder (Section 304 Part II) or Section 304A IPC.
p. 8 · ¶ 8 · ¶ 16–17iii.3. Whether framing a charge for the graver offence, without a lesser alternative, causes prejudice to the accused warranting interference.
pp. 20–24 · ¶ 19–21 · ¶ 2303Law Applied
Sections 226, 227 and 228 CrPC require the prosecution to open its case and the Court to discharge or frame charges on the basis of the record after hearing both sides, and framing is a prima facie satisfaction, not a finding of guilt.
p. 10 · pp. 14–15 · pp. 19–20Following Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander (2012) 9 SCC 460, Section 228 framing is tentative, and certainty of guilt is not required at that stage.
p. 14Sajjan Kumar v. CBI (2008) 11 SCR 669 holds that the Court may sift material only to find grave suspicion, and must not conduct a roving enquiry.
pp. 11–13Ashok Shambhubhai holds that Section 226 compliance is mandatory where the prosecution is directed to open its case, and a draft charge alone is insufficient.
pp. 16–17Dr. Mani Kumar Chhetri v. State of W.B. (CRR 1918/2016) holds that culpable homicide requires a degree of certainty as to the likelihood of death, with knowledge as the direct and motivating force of the act.
p. 18Yuvraj Laxmilal Kanther (2025) 3 SCR 502 and Uphaar Cinema are cited on discharge and conviction-stage challenges.
pp. 18–19Rafiq Ahmed v. State of U.P. (2011) 8 SCC 300 holds that cognate lesser offences may be punished without a specific charge where no prejudice results, and that a Section 302 charge does not cause prejudice merely because a conviction may follow for a lesser offence.
pp. 20–24Willie Slaney v. State of M.P. (AIR 1956 SC 116) defines prejudice from a charge defect as a substantial likelihood of misleading the accused, with the absence of early objection being material.
pp. 21–22Ghulam Hasan Beigh v. Mohammad Maqbool Magrey (2022 INSC 750) holds that the murder/culpable homicide distinction is determined only after evidence at trial, not at the framing stage on the postmortem alone, and that the prosecution leads evidence only per the charge framed.
pp. 24–27Provisions in the judgment · 25 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 20 provisions
Section 34Section 35Section 36Section 201Section 288Section 299Section 300Section 302Section 304Section 307Section 308Section 323Section 325Section 326Section 337Section 338Section 395Section 396Section 397Section 427Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 161Section 226Section 227Section 228
Arms Act, 1959 Section 25
04Reasoning
The Court found the procedural objection unpersuasive. The impugned order records that the Trial Court considered the case diary in the presence of both prosecution and defence counsel, and no objection was raised, no discharge application was filed, and no prayer under Section 226 was made before the revision was filed in January 2025. The Court distinguished the petitioner's authorities: Banti @ Guddu concerned non-examination of witnesses at trial, not framing; Sajjan Kumar, Manishaben, and Ashok Shambhubhai concerned non-compliance with Section 226 or refusal of discharge where the accused had sought compliance, which was absent here; and Mani Kumar Chhetri, Yuvraj Laxmilal Kanther, and Uphaar arose from discharge refusals or convictions, not from framing orders.
pp. 10–11 · pp. 11–17 · pp. 15–17 · pp. 18–19 · ¶ 13–15On the substantive question, the Court held that at the framing stage it need only assess whether the material raises a prima facie case. The material here (absence of sanction, the expert report, alleged instructions on mixing materials, the scale of deaths, and the petitioner's antecedents) supports the charge. The Court noted that the mens rea issues (Mani Kumar Chhetri) and the murder/culpable homicide distinction (Ghulam Hasan Beigh) are matters for trial on evidence. Applying Rafiq Ahmed and Ghulam Hasan Beigh, the Court reasoned that reducing the charge at this stage would leave the prosecution with little scope to prove the graver offence, whereas framing the maximum-punishment charge caused the petitioner no prejudice, since a lesser offence could still be considered at conviction. The Court did not expressly address the petitioner's objection regarding the Garden Reach P.S. case number discrepancy (55 vs. 56).
p. 9 · p. 18 · pp. 22–24 · pp. 25–28 · ¶ 23 · pp. 5–605Holding
The charge under Sections 120B/302/307/427 IPC was validly framed, the petitioner suffered no procedural or substantive prejudice, and no ground exists to alter the charge to a lesser offence at this stage.
pp. 16–17 · pp. 27–28 · ¶ 13–15, 23The revision is dismissed and the order dated 11.12.2024 is upheld. The Court left the petitioner's culpability to be determined on the evidence adduced at trial. No costs were awarded, and connected applications stand disposed of.
p. 28 · ¶ 24, 25, 26–27Original Court PDF
MD. WASIM @ WASSIvsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
