01Facts
The Revenue Officer (B.L. & L.R.O.) granted mutation of plot no. 1048/1477 in favour of the petitioners, relying on their gift deed and the chain deed through which their donor acquired the property.
¶ 5The Appellate Authority set aside the mutation, and the West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal affirmed that order in OA Nos. 2495 and 2496 of 2022 (LRTT).
¶ 4The petitioners' gift deed, on which mutation was sought, conveys parent Dag no. 1048, not bata plot no. 1048/1477.
¶ 6The vendor's title deed did refer to plot no. 1048/1477.
¶ 6A partition suit is pending before the civil court.
¶ 10The petitioners filed writ petitions challenging the Tribunal's judgments.
¶ 1, 902Issues
i.1. Whether mutation of bata plot no. 1048/1477 can be sustained on the strength of a gift deed that describes only parent Dag no. 1048.
¶ 6ii.2. Whether the vendor's title deed, which refers to bata plot no. 1048/1477, can cure the description defect in the petitioners' own gift deed.
¶ 6iii.3. Whether a bata plot and its parent plot are legally distinct for the purpose of mutation.
¶ 703Law Applied
The judgment does not cite any statute, rule, or precedent expressly.
The Court applied the principle that the instrument on which mutation is founded controls the land claimed, so that a title deed of the predecessor cannot supply a description absent from the petitioners' own gift deed.
¶ 6The Court treated a bata plot as a sub-divided or fractional plot carved out of a parent plot, with the residual portion of the parent plot retaining the original plot number after sub-division.
¶ 7The writ jurisdiction was exercised to review the legality of the Tribunal's order affirming the Appellate Authority's setting aside of mutation.
¶ 4, 804Reasoning
The Court held that the petitioners' gift deed, which is the very instrument invoked for mutation, refers to parent Dag no. 1048 and not to bata plot no. 1048/1477.
¶ 6Because the petitioners rely on their own deed, the vendor's title deed describing the bata plot could not be used to remedy that mismatch.
¶ 6The Court emphasised the "gulf of difference" between a parent plot and a bata plot, since sub-division creates a distinct fractional plot while the parent retains its original number.
¶ 7On that basis, the Court found no illegality in the Tribunal's affirmance of the Appellate Authority's order setting aside mutation of plot 1048/1477.
¶ 805Holding
The Court answered the issues against the petitioners: a gift deed describing parent Dag 1048 does not support mutation of bata plot 1048/1477, and the vendor's title deed cannot cure that defect.
¶ 6A bata plot and its parent plot are distinct.
¶ 7Both writ petitions were dismissed on contest, affirming the Tribunal's judgments dated March 19, 2026 in OA Nos. 2495 and 2496 of 2022 (LRTT).
¶ 8, 9The dismissal does not bar the petitioners from seeking fresh mutation if a civil court decree in their favour is passed in the pending partition suit or any other civil suit. Any such application must be decided by the authority after notice and hearing to all interested persons, including the private respondents. No order as to costs was passed.
¶ 10, 11Original Court PDF
ASIRUDDIN SK.vsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
