01Facts
The appellants, husband and wife, were convicted by the Additional District and Sessions Judge, 5th Court, Alipore, in Sessions Trial No. 01(02)12 under s. 302 IPC and s. 120B IPC.
¶ 1–4Each received life imprisonment and a fine of ₹5,000, with concurrent sentences.
¶ 1–4The prosecution alleged that the wife was in an illicit relationship with the deceased, her husband's cousin, who had forced himself on her and threatened her husband. The husband complained to PW-4, the deceased's eldest brother, who responded dismissively.
¶ 5, 77The couple then planned the killing.
¶ 5, 111On 30 April 2011 the wife lured the deceased to Gourdaha railway station, taking their minor daughter PW-7 along. She served him food and a drink laced with sleeping pills. The husband then attacked him with a da (sharp agricultural instrument).
¶ 20, 51(v), 112–113The body was found on 1 May 2011 and identified on 3 May 2011.
¶ 6, 9The post-mortem showed homicidal incised wounds, the fatal one being on the neck.
¶ 37–38On 4 May 2011 the appellants confessed extra-judicially before villagers, including PWs 4–6.
Following this, the police recovered a bloodstained da and saree and pills.
¶ 10, 21, 71On 6 May 2011 both appellants made judicial confessions before PW-12, the Judicial Magistrate, after being cautioned and given a day for reflection.
¶ 40–41PW-7's s. 164 statement, recorded on 5 May 2011, said she was in her mother's arms when the husband struck.
¶ 11, 39At trial, the appellants and PW-7 retracted. PW-7 also claimed the deceased was alive, and PW-8 supported her.
¶ 31–33, 94–95The FSL report found no blood on the da or saree, but found blood on the deceased's clothing.
¶ 4502Issues
i.1. Whether the extra-judicial confession and the retracted judicial confession under s. 164 CrPC of the appellants are admissible, voluntary, and reliable, and whether they can found a conviction when corroborated by other evidence.
¶ 52–83ii.2. Whether the retracted s. 164 statement of PW-7, the child eyewitness, can be relied upon in the face of her in-court retraction.
¶ 94–106iii.3. Whether the prosecution's circumstantial evidence, including the alleged illicit relationship as motive and the absence of blood on the weapon and saree in the FSL report, forms a complete and unbroken chain pointing solely to the guilt of the appellants.
¶ 84–93, 107–11603Law Applied
The court applied s. 302 IPC (murder) and s. 120B IPC (criminal conspiracy, an independent offence), and treated the charge under s. 34 IPC as framed.
¶ 12, 50On confessions, the court relied on Sahadevan v. State of T.N. (2012) 6 SCC 403, which holds that an extra-judicial confession is weak evidence that must be voluntary, truthful, and corroborated.
¶ 54The court relied on Nikhil Chandra Mondal v. State of W.B. (2023) 6 SCC 605, which holds that a s. 164 confession may found a conviction only with caution and independent corroboration.
¶ 55–56Parmananda Pegu v. State of Assam (2004) 7 SCC 779, Subramania Goundan v. State of Madras (1958 SCR 428), and Pyare Lal Bhargava (1963 Supp (1) SCR 689) hold that a retracted confession requires the court's satisfaction on voluntariness and truth, and general corroboration in material particulars.
¶ 57–58Rabindra Kumar Pal v. Republic of India (2011) 2 SCC 490 lays down the s. 164 safeguards, which are illustrative indicators of voluntariness and not a rigid statutory checklist. Jamiluddin Nasir (2014) 7 SCC 443 is cited to the same effect.
¶ 60–62On related or interested witnesses, the court applied Baban Shankar Daphal (2025 INSC 97), which holds that a relative is not automatically interested and that evidence should be scrutinised, not discarded.
¶ 87On child witnesses and tutoring, the court applied State of M.P. v. Balveer Singh (2025) 8 SCC 545 and Anees v. State NCT (2024 INSC 368).
¶ 99–101On circumstantial evidence and motive, the court applied Kukapalli Mohan Rao (2013) 11 SCC 713 (direct proof of illicit intimacy need not exist), Ram Avtar v. State (Delhi Admn.) (1985 Supp SCC 410) (chain to be read as an integrated whole), Mehtab v. State of Uttarakhand (2026 INSC 578) and Allarakha Habib Memon (FSL corroboration is not independently conclusive), and Balwan Singh v. State of Chhattisgarh (2019) 7 SCC 781 (serological difficulties do not automatically benefit the accused).
¶ 91, 108–110Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 34Section 302
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 164Section 165Section 281Section 311Section 313Section 428
04Reasoning
The court held the judicial confessions admissible and voluntary. PW-12 cautioned both appellants, granted a day of reflection, and recorded their insistence on confessing, and the defence did not allege coercion during that period. A s. 313 CrPC assertion of police pressure was held insufficient without particulars.
¶ 59, 64–65, 72–73The failure to ask why they were confessing was found not fatal, since the litmus test under Rabindra Pal is the magistrate's satisfaction as to voluntariness.
¶ 62The court also drew support from timing: the appellants were produced immediately after arrest, and the arrest followed the villagers' confrontation, so the police did not have time to coerce a confession.
¶ 66–67The confessions were treated as corroborated by PWs 4–6 (who saw the couple leave and return without the deceased), the recoveries of the da and saree, the pills, and the medical evidence.
¶ 68–71, 105The court found the PWs' presence at the extra-judicial confession natural, given their proximity and kinship, and held that they had no motive to falsely implicate the appellants.
¶ 86–88The motive of illicit relationship was established by the confessions and the consistent testimony of PWs 4–5.
¶ 92–93PW-7's retraction was rejected: the court found it likely tutored, given that she was living with her paternal relatives, and that the retraction was in the parents' interest. Her s. 164 statement was consistent with the confessions and the injuries, and it was recorded promptly, not after reflection.
¶ 96–106The absence of blood on the da and saree was explained by the three-day gap before recovery, which made washing plausible. The FSL report was treated only as a corroborative link.
¶ 107–109The court then read the circumstances as an integrated chain, noting that the taking of the minor daughter to the station was a deliberate device to disarm the deceased's suspicion and to allay bystanders' doubts. This pointed irresistibly to the appellants' guilt.
¶ 110–11605Holding
The court answered all three issues in the affirmative against the appellants. The judicial confessions under s. 164 CrPC were voluntary and reliable and, with general corroboration from PWs 4–6, the recoveries, and the medical evidence, sufficed for conviction.
¶ 73–83, 116PW-7's retraction was held to be tutored, and her s. 164 statement was preferred.
¶ 102–106The circumstantial chain was held complete and conclusive. The motive of illicit relationship was proved, and the absence of blood on the weapon did not negate the case.
¶ 93, 107–116The appeal was dismissed, the conviction under ss. 302 and 120B IPC and the sentence of life imprisonment with fines were upheld, and the trial court record was to be returned. Any appellants on bail were to surrender within seven days.
¶ 117–119Original Court PDF
TAPAN NASKAR & ANRvsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
