Calcutta High CourtEmployment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

Judicial review of disciplinary action is confined to procedure; lack of monetary loss does not make removal disproportionate.

AMIT KUMAR MULLICKv.UNITED BANK OF INDIA & ORS

Judicial review of disciplinary action is confined to procedure; lack of monetary loss does not make removal disproportionate.. AMIT KUMAR MULLICK vs UNITED BANK OF INDIA & ORS. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether documents marked without the charged officer's prior objection were legally admissible, rendering the EO's findings perverse and based on no evidence.

The court held

The Court held that the enquiry was conducted fairly, that there was sufficient evidence linking the appellant to the charges, and that removal from service was not disproportionate

It also directed

The Court found no basis to interfere with the Single Judge's judgment, which it described as supported by specific findings and detailed reasons

The appeal (FMA 1814 of 2018) is dismissed

The applications CAN 3 of 2022 and CAN 4 of 2022 were already disposed of by the order dated 28 July 2025, and the Registry is directed to record that disposal

There is no order as to costs

01Facts

The appellant, Amit Kumar Mullick, joined the United Bank of India as a Cash Clerk on 13 August 1976, was promoted over time, and had no antecedents

¶ 2

While posted as Manager at Survey Park Branch (17 May 2010 to 13 July 2011), he sanctioned 19 loans, seven of which went to borrowers who were the same person or relatives of one another

¶ 15

He was served a Charge Sheet dated 6 June 2014, shortly before his scheduled retirement on 30 September 2017

¶ 2

The Enquiry Officer (EO) held the charges proved on the basis of 41 documents marked through a management witness, without objection from the appellant, who had inspection and cross-examination opportunities

¶ 4, 8, 15

The Disciplinary Authority (DA), by order dated 31 October 2014, imposed removal from service under Regulation 4(i) of the United Bank of India Officer Employees' (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976

¶ 2

The Appellate Authority (AA) dismissed the statutory appeal on 20 November 2015

¶ 2

The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition (WPA 2982 of 2016) by judgment dated 29 February 2016

¶ 1–2

The appellant challenged that judgment in the present appeal

¶ 2

02Issues

i.1. Whether documents marked without the charged officer's prior objection were legally admissible, rendering the EO's findings perverse and based on no evidence.

¶ 3, 15, 17

ii.2. Whether the EO's failure to call for official records and the biased tenor of the ER vitiated the enquiry and caused prejudice.

¶ 3, 4, 15

iii.3. Whether the DA and AA failed to apply their minds, to consider the appellant's reply and appeal grounds, and to record reasons.

¶ 5, 6, 12

iv.4. Whether the enquiry violated principles of natural justice or statutory rules.

¶ 8, 15, 16

v.5. Whether the punishment of removal from service was disproportionate, particularly as no monetary loss was caused.

¶ 7, 18

vi.6. Whether the High Court's interference is warranted in appellate review.

¶ 9, 10, 19

03Law Applied

The United Bank of India Officer Employees' (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976, under which Regulation 4(i) authorised removal from service as a major penalty

¶ 2

Fairness, rather than rigid form, governs natural justice, so no breach arises where the delinquent has been fairly treated

¶ 16

"Sufficiency of evidence" requires some evidence linking the delinquent to the charge

¶ 17

Interference in appellate review is warranted only where the decision is wholly without jurisdiction, excessive, unsupported by reasons, or perverse, and not merely because it is wrong

¶ 19

04Reasoning

The Court found that the appellant had been given inspection of all documents, had raised no objection when the documents were marked through the management witness, and had been allowed to cross-examine the witness, and therefore rejected the procedural and natural justice challenges

¶ 15

On evidence, the Court held that the documents disclosed a "clear nexus" between the appellant and the charges, so the sufficiency-of-evidence requirement was met

¶ 17

The Court rejected the "no monetary loss" argument, reasoning that the loans exposed the bank to aggregated financial risk exceeding ₹2 crore, and that a bank officer must maintain high standards of honesty and integrity

¶ 18, 13

On proportionality, the Court held that the punishment was not disproportionate to the established charges

¶ 18

The Court did not separately address the appellant's contentions that the EO was biased, that the DA's order was mechanical, or that the AA's order was perfunctory; its disposal of these points rests on the findings that the charges were proved and that the Single Judge had given reasoned findings

¶ 4, 5, 6, 19

Applying the narrow appellate standard, the Court held that the Single Judge's reasoned findings were not clearly wrong, perverse, or without jurisdiction

¶ 19

05Holding

The Court held that the enquiry was conducted fairly, that there was sufficient evidence linking the appellant to the charges, and that removal from service was not disproportionate

¶ 15, 17, 18

The Court found no basis to interfere with the Single Judge's judgment, which it described as supported by specific findings and detailed reasons

¶ 19

The appeal (FMA 1814 of 2018) is dismissed

¶ 20

The applications CAN 3 of 2022 and CAN 4 of 2022 were already disposed of by the order dated 28 July 2025, and the Registry is directed to record that disposal

¶ 21

There is no order as to costs

¶ 22
Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

AMIT KUMAR MULLICKvsUNITED BANK OF INDIA & ORS

Calcutta High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment