01Facts
The opposite party no. 2, M/s Wide Range Sales Pvt. Ltd., advanced ₹1,00,00,000 as an inter-corporate deposit to the accused company, M/s Tantia Constructions Ltd., on 14.06.2012.
¶ 3–4The deposit was renewed, and the latest renewal (01.04.2014, 91 days, 17% p.a.) fell due on 30.06.2014.
¶ 3–4The accused company issued cheque no. 008233 dated 01.07.2014 for ₹1 crore, drawn on Allahabad Bank, in part repayment.
¶ 5The cheque was presented on 10.09.2014 and dishonoured with the remark "Exceeds Arrangement" by memo dated 11.09.2014.
¶ 6A demand notice was issued to the accused persons as persons in charge of the company's business, but payment was not made.
¶ 7The Chief Metropolitan Magistrate transferred the complaint (C.S. 23882 of 2015) to the Metropolitan Magistrate, 14th Court, Calcutta, who issued process under Sections 138/141 of the N.I. Act on 20.07.2015.
¶ 8Twelve individuals, including the company, were arraigned.
¶ 14Seven accused (nos. 2, 3, 6, 7, 8, 11, 12) sought quashing in CRR 2828/2017; two (nos. 9, 10) in CRR 142/2016.
¶ 1–2The complaint did not specify who signed the cheque, when it was issued, or any individual role in the transaction.
¶ 25–26The petitioners' designations were: Md. Jamshed Alam (Company Secretary); Tarun Chaturvedi and Madhuchhanda Chatterjee (non-executive independent directors, per Form 32).
¶ 14, 28The remaining petitioners were described in the complaint as full-time/additional directors, a position the petitioners did not conclusively disprove.
¶ 3602Issues
i.1. Whether a full-time director can be prosecuted under Sections 138/141 of the N.I. Act in the absence of any specific averment or particular role attributed to them.
¶ 24(i)ii.2. Whether a director or independent director can be prosecuted under Sections 138/141 of the N.I. Act in the absence of any specific averment or particular role attributed to them.
¶ 24(ii)iii.3. Whether a company secretary can be prosecuted under Sections 138/141 of the N.I. Act in the absence of any specific averment or particular role attributed to them.
¶ 24(iii)03Law Applied
The court relied on Sections 138 and 141 of the N.I. Act, under which vicarious liability attaches to persons in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the company's business at the relevant time.
¶ 20, 30Under S.M.S. Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Neeta Bhalla, liability arises from being in charge of and responsible for business at the time of the offence, not from holding a designation, and it would be a travesty of justice to prosecute directors not connected with the cheque's issuance or dishonour merely because of their designation.
¶ 20, 30The court also relied on Sunita Palita v. Panchami Stone Quarry and Susela Padmavathy Amma v. Bharti Airtel Ltd. for the same proposition.
¶ 30Section 149(12) of the Companies Act, 2013 provides that an independent director, or a non-executive non-promoter director, is liable only for acts done with his knowledge, consent, connivance, or lack of diligence.
¶ 32–33Under Section 141(2) of the N.I. Act, such officers require a specific, direct, and distinct role to be attributed, and a bald allegation is insufficient.
¶ 34Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. permits quashing to prevent abuse of process and secure the ends of justice.
¶ 37Quashing a cheque-dishonour complaint based on documentary evidence is a serious matter, and petitioners must show that no offence is made out against them.
¶ 36Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138Section 141
Companies Act, 2013 Section 149
04Reasoning
The court held that the complaint contained no averment of any individual role in the transaction or in issuing the cheque, and did not identify the signatory.
¶ 26For Md. Jamshed Alam (Company Secretary), the record, including Form 32, confirmed his designation. Nothing showed that he was an active director, shareholder, or responsible for day-to-day management, and he was not a signatory to the dishonoured cheque. His statutory role was therefore limited and did not extend to managing the company's day-to-day affairs.
¶ 28, 30For Tarun Chaturvedi and Madhuchhanda Chatterjee (non-executive independent directors), the court applied Section 149(12) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Section 141(2) of the N.I. Act. Neither was shown to be in charge of or responsible for the company's business, and the complaint attributed no specific role to either.
¶ 31, 34Accordingly, the court treated proceedings against these three petitioners as an abuse of process.
¶ 35For the remaining petitioners, the court found that they were described as full-time or additional directors. The petitioners' attempt to rebut this, through an unauthenticated annual report and without Form 32 or equivalent documents for some co-accused, was insufficient.
¶ 36The court held that a bare averment of directorship is ordinarily sufficient to proceed to trial, and that role may be developed at trial.
¶ 36The court did not separately discuss the authorities cited by the opposite party on full-time directors (Gunmala Sales, S.P. Mani, HDFC Bank), but its reasoning on that group rests on the sufficiency of the basic averment.
¶ 22–23, 3605Holding
(i) Full-time directors: a bare averment of full-time directorship is sufficient to proceed. The petitioners failed to show that no offence is made out, so their prosecution continues.
¶ 36(ii) Independent and non-executive directors: they cannot be prosecuted in the absence of specific, direct, and distinct role attribution. Tarun Chaturvedi and Madhuchhanda Chatterjee are therefore discharged from the proceedings.
¶ 31, 34–35(iii) Company secretary: a non-executive company secretary with no role in management, the cheque, or its dishonour cannot be prosecuted. Md. Jamshed Alam's proceedings are quashed.
¶ 30–31, 35CRR 2828 of 2017 is partly allowed, quashing proceedings against Md. Jamshed Alam, Tarun Chaturvedi and Madhuchhanda Chatterjee under Section 482 Cr.P.C. The case against the remaining accused continues in accordance with law.
¶ 37–38CRR 142 of 2016 is allowed.
¶ 38Interim orders stand vacated, and the trial court is directed to take necessary steps.
¶ 39–40Original Court PDF
TARUN CHATURVEDI & ORSvsM/S WIDE RANGE SALES PVT LTD
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
