Calcutta High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Settlement Cheques Bounced, But Original Cheque Case Survives: Calcutta HC Upholds Conviction of Simoco Firm Officials

SIMOCO TELECOMMUNICATION(SOUTH ASIA) LIMITED AND OTHERSv.STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR

Settlement Cheques Bounced, But Original Cheque Case Survives: Calcutta HC Upholds Conviction of Simoco Firm Officials. SIMOCO TELECOMMUNICATION(SOUTH ASIA) LIMITED AND OTHERS vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the High Court, in revisional jurisdiction, may re-appreciate evidence and upset the concurrent findings of the trial and appellate courts absent perversity or jurisdictional error.

The court held

The High Court held that no perversity or jurisdictional error was shown in the concurrent findings, so it would not re-appreciate the evidence.

It also directed

The petitioners failed to rebut the s. 139 presumption, and the settlement cheques and Gimpex did not subsume or bar the complaint.

CRR 3762 of 2023 is dismissed, and CRR 3940 of 2023 is dismissed on the same analogy and for want of proof of liquidation of the debt.

The judgment does not expressly address the s. 141 challenge of Petitioners 3 and 4.

01Facts

Petitioner No. 1, a company, purchased imported mobile phones and accessories from Opposite Party (OP) No. 2 under contractual arrangements and issued post-dated cheques in payment.

¶ 2

To settle a running account, the petitioners issued seven account payee cheques totalling Rs. 36,12,174/-.

¶ 2

On dishonour ("exceeds arrangement"), OP No. 2 issued a statutory notice dated 24.07.2008 and filed Complaint Case No. 23410 of 2008.

¶ 2

During pendency, the parties executed a settlement agreement dated 02.10.2008 under which the company issued nine further cheques; these were also dishonoured.

¶ 3–4

The petitioners pleaded payment of the balance through RTGS transfers of Rs. 30,73,550/- (14.11.2008) and Rs. 4,00,000/- (04.12.2008), and an unpaid residue of Rs. 1,39,624/-.

¶ 5

The Metropolitan Magistrate (08.11.2019) convicted the petitioners under ss. 138/141 NI Act, and the Additional Sessions Judge affirmed on 10.08.2023.

¶ 1, 17–18

The trial court relied on the accounts statement (Exhibit 8) and OP's letter admitting liability (Exhibit 9).

¶ 17

The appellate court held the petitioners failed to prove payment under the reverse onus.

¶ 18

The petitioners sought revisional relief under ss. 401/482 CrPC (BNSS s. 528), contending that the balance sheets did not show the debt as a sundry debtor, that payments were made, and that the settlement subsumed the original complaint.

¶ 6–10

OP No. 2 contended that the debt was continuing, the claimed payments (Rs. 57,720/- and Rs. 2,52,200/-) related to other transactions, and the RTGS payments were not linked to the present cheques.

¶ 11–15

02Issues

i.1. Whether the High Court, in revisional jurisdiction, may re-appreciate evidence and upset the concurrent findings of the trial and appellate courts absent perversity or jurisdictional error.

¶ 19 · ¶ 20

ii.2. Whether the petitioners rebutted the presumption under s. 139 NI Act, including through the non-disclosure of the debt in the complainant's balance sheets and proof of payment during pendency.

¶ 6–8, 22–24

iii.3. Whether the settlement dated 02.10.2008 and the dishonour of the nine subsequent cheques extinguished or subsumed the original complaint, such that the prosecution could not continue.

¶ 10, 25–28

03Law Applied

The court applied s. 138 NI Act (dishonour and statutory notice) and s. 139 NI Act, which raises a rebuttable presumption of law that a cheque was issued for a legally enforceable debt, with s. 118A NI Act and s. 103 of the Evidence Act placing the burden of proving payment on the accused.

¶ 13, 17, 20, 24

Under Southern Sales & Services v. Sauermilch Designed and Handels GmbH and Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar, a revisional court will not disturb concurrent findings or re-analyse evidence absent perversity or jurisdictional error.

¶ 19–21

Kumar Exports v. Sharma Carpets reiterates that the s. 139 presumption is rebuttable only by evidence establishing a reasonable probability of non-existence of the debt.

¶ 20

Lalita Kumar Sharma v. State of U.P. was relied upon by the trial court for the proposition that a settlement during pendency does not bar prosecution where the settlement cheques fail to fructify.

¶ 17, 27

Gimpex (P) Ltd. v. Manoj Goel was relied upon by the petitioners for the proposition that a compromise subsumes the earlier cause of action.

¶ 10, 25–26

Charan Singh v. State of U.P. and Punjab University v. Bijay Singh Lamba hold that a decision is an authority only for what it decides, on its facts.

¶ 29

Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138Section 141Section 139Section 118

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 401Section 482Section 313

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 528

04Reasoning

The court first held that the concurrent findings of the two courts below, that the cheques related to a legally enforceable debt, were supported by the record (Exhibits 3, 7, 8, 9), and that the petitioners' repayment plea was a question of fact.

¶ 19, 22

Non-disclosure of the debt in the complainant's balance sheets did not extinguish the debt or defeat the s. 139 presumption, since the petitioners had to rebut it with positive evidence.

¶ 23

The court further reasoned that mere non-disclosure in balance sheets "does not amount to discharge of burden" absent rebuttal evidence.

¶ 24

On the payments, the court accepted the courts below's view that the Rs. 57,720/- and Rs. 2,52,200/- payments related to other transactions, that the RTGS payment of 04.12.2008 was linked to a separate proceeding, and that the petitioners failed to produce documents tying the payments to the present debt.

¶ 13, 23–24

On the subsumption argument, the court distinguished Gimpex, where a second complaint on settlement cheques was pending alongside the first; here OP No. 2 filed no second complaint.

¶ 25–27

The court held that accepting the petitioners' position would leave the complainant without remedy and subvert justice.

¶ 28

It also held that Gimpex did not overrule Lalita Kumar Sharma and applied only on its facts.

¶ 27, 29

05Holding

The High Court held that no perversity or jurisdictional error was shown in the concurrent findings, so it would not re-appreciate the evidence.

¶ 19, 21

The petitioners failed to rebut the s. 139 presumption, and the settlement cheques and Gimpex did not subsume or bar the complaint.

¶ 24, 27–29

CRR 3762 of 2023 is dismissed, and CRR 3940 of 2023 is dismissed on the same analogy and for want of proof of liquidation of the debt.

¶ 31

The judgment does not expressly address the s. 141 challenge of Petitioners 3 and 4.

¶ 16(vi)
Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

SIMOCO TELECOMMUNICATION(SOUTH ASIA) LIMITED AND OTHERSvsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR

Calcutta High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment