01Facts
The petitioners, Dhoot Realtors Pvt. (Petitioner No. 1, a company) and its director (Petitioner No. 2), sought quashing under Section 482 CrPC (now Section 528 BNSS) of Complaint Case No. 3407/2022 under Sections 406/420 IPC, pending before the JMFC, Bidhannagar, North 24 Parganas, along with the orders dated 24.08.2022 and 09.04.2024.
¶ 1 · pp. 1–2The ACJM took cognizance on 24.08.2022 and transferred the case. On 09.04.2024, after examining the complainant under Section 200 CrPC, the Magistrate issued process.
¶ 2 · p. 2Petitioner No. 2 was granted exemption from personal appearance under Section 205 CrPC, and the matter was fixed for evidence before charge.
¶ 3 · p. 2The dispute concerns non-payment of a balance under landscaping work orders for the petitioners' project "Prathama." The complainant raised a bill of ₹27,77,840 on completion of the work; the petitioners paid ₹17,50,000 and withheld ₹10,27,840.
¶ 4 · pp. 2–3Demand notices were issued on 26.08.2020, 03.12.2020 and 19.07.2021. A complaint to the police on 10.05.2022 produced no action, after which the written complaint was filed.
¶ 4 · p. 3The petitioners contended that the dispute was commercial, that the balance was a civil liability, and that the Magistrate issued process without recording reasons.
¶ 5 · pp. 3–5 · ¶ 6 · pp. 4–5The opposite party contended that the petitioners induced the work order from the outset with intent to deceive, and that the complainant's sworn statement established repeated demands.
¶ 7–8 · pp. 5–602Issues
i.1. Whether the complaint discloses the ingredients of cheating under Sections 415/420 IPC, where the grievance is non-payment of a balance under a commercial transaction and no fraudulent or dishonest intention at inception is alleged.
¶ 5, 9, 14 · pp. 3–4, 6–7, 11–12ii.2. Whether the complaint discloses criminal breach of trust under Sections 405/406 IPC, where there is no entrustment of property or dominion over property.
¶ 5, 15 · p. 4, 12iii.3. Whether the order issuing process is vitiated for want of reasons under Section 204 CrPC, and whether the delay in lodging the complaint is material.
¶ 6 · pp. 4–503Law Applied
The Court applied Section 415 IPC, which defines cheating as deception that fraudulently or dishonestly induces delivery of property or consent to retention, or intentional inducement causing damage or harm, with deception as a necessary ingredient. Section 420 IPC was assessed on that basis.
¶ 9 · pp. 6–7 · ¶ 14 · p. 12Section 406 IPC requires entrustment of property or dominion over it.
¶ 15 · p. 12Under Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma v. State of Bihar and M.N.G. Bharateesh Reddy v. Ramesh Ranganathan, the distinction between breach of contract and cheating is fine; mere breach does not give rise to criminal liability unless a fraudulent or dishonest intention existed at the time of the inducement, which cannot be presumed from later non-performance.
¶ 11–12 · pp. 7–9Dalip Kaur v. Jagnar Singh holds that allegations of breach of contract that do not disclose deception or inducement are civil in nature.
¶ 12 · pp. 9–10Vijay Kumar Ghai v. State of West Bengal and the principles of Indian Oil Corporation disapprove converting civil disputes into criminal prosecutions; mere breach of contract is not itself a criminal offence.
¶ 10 · p. 7Yogesh Premjibhai Suvariya v. State of Gujarat holds that fraudulence, dishonesty or intentional inducement are sine qua non for Section 415.
¶ 13 · p. 10The Court also relied on the Calcutta High Court decision in Rupayan Bhattacharya v. State of West Bengal, cited by the opposite party.
¶ 12 · p. 8The test is whether the complaint itself discloses a criminal offence, and the existence of a civil remedy does not bar relief.
¶ 15 · p. 12Provisions in the judgment · 9 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482Section 200Section 204Section 205
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 528
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 406Section 420Section 405Section 415
04Reasoning
The Court examined the complaint and found that the work order was issued, the work was completed, a bill of ₹27,77,840 was raised, and ₹17,50,000 was paid, leaving a balance of ₹10,27,840 unpaid. Applying the Hridaya Ranjan and Bharateesh Reddy tests, the Court held that the complaint contained no averment of deception or dishonest intention at inception, and no allegation that the complainant was induced to deliver property or consent to retention. Partial payment and non-payment of the balance were treated as a contractual dispute, not evidence of fraud at the time of the work order. The Court therefore held that the ingredients of Section 420 were absent. On Section 406, the Court held that no entrustment of property or dominion existed, so the offence was not made out.
¶ 12, 14–15 · pp. 9–12The Court did not separately rule on the Section 204 reasoning argument or on the delay argument. Its decision rests on the absence of criminal ingredients in the complaint itself, making the Section 204 and delay issues unnecessary to decide. The Court also did not expressly distinguish Rupayan Bhattacharya, which the opposite party relied on.
¶ 12, 14–15 · p. 8, 1205Holding
The Court answered both issues in the negative: the complaint does not disclose the ingredients of cheating under Section 420 IPC, nor criminal breach of trust under Section 406 IPC. The dispute is civil in nature and the civil remedy is the appropriate forum.
¶ 14 · p. 12 · ¶ 15 · p. 12The criminal revisional application is allowed, and the entire proceedings of Complaint Case No. 3407/2022 under Sections 406/420 IPC, pending before the JMFC, Bidhannagar, are quashed against the petitioners. Connected applications are disposed of, and urgent certified copies are to be supplied on compliance with formalities.
¶ 16–19 · p. 12Original Court PDF
DHOOT REALTORS PRIVATE LIMITED AND ANOTHERvsAPURBA KUMAR JANA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
