Calcutta High CourtAdministrative and Public LawContract Law

Calcutta HC Rejects Poor-Quality Plea Raised 1.5 Years Late, Orders Payment for 4,824 Walls

BHAGIRATH ENGINEERS COOP. SERVICE CONSTR. SOCIETY LTD & ANRv.STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS

Calcutta HC Rejects Poor-Quality Plea Raised 1.5 Years Late, Orders Payment for 4,824 Walls. BHAGIRATH ENGINEERS COOP. SERVICE CONSTR. SOCIETY LTD & ANR vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the DPO's order dated 13 August 2015, a quasi-judicial order, is liable to be interfered with under the limited scope of writ review (arbitrariness, perversity, excess of jurisdiction, violation of natural justice, or unreasonableness).

The court held

The DPO's order dated 13 August 2015 was arbitrary and is set aside, because the authority's unexplained delay of about one and a half years, with no inventory or enquiry, precluded a belated plea of poor quality.

It also directed

The court directed the DPO to release the proportionate amount for the 4,824 walls within two weeks of communication of the order, with 10% per annum interest from 11 November 2013 until actual disbursement.

As to the remaining walls, the petitioners may file a civil suit, as those issues involve disputed questions of fact. The writ petition is disposed of with no order as to costs.

01Facts

The petitioner No. 1, a co-operative society, bid for a tender floated on 12 October 2012 by the District Project Officer (DPO), Sarva Shiksha Mission, Murshidabad, for wall writing work across the district. The work order was issued on 18 March 2013.

¶ 1

By memo dated 8 May 2013, the petitioners were informed that the rate per wall was Rs. 631.27 and the total bill for 26 blocks was Rs. 38,49,484, to be billed block-wise.

¶ 2

A Block Development Officer certified completion of work at the CPC, Bhagwangola-II block.

¶ 3

The petitioners submitted bills, requested payment on 11 November 2013, and sent a reminder on 22 September 2013.

¶ 4

Further representations dated 30 October 2013, 22 January 2014 and 26 May 2014 went unanswered. The petitioners then filed W.P. 23673(W) of 2014, and on 16 June 2015 a coordinate Bench directed the DPO to consider payment after hearing the petitioners.

¶ 5

By order dated 13 August 2015, the DPO rejected the claim. He recorded that only 1,274 of 6,098 walls were completed, that the remaining 4,824 walls were not executed per specification, and that the writing was poor, done by stencil rather than by hand, and not in Asian Paints colour. He directed the petitioners to redo all 6,098 walls.

¶ 6

The petitioners challenged that order in this writ petition.

¶ 7

The State contended that only 4,824 walls were completed, and those in violation of the tender specifications.

¶ 9

02Issues

i.1. Whether the DPO's order dated 13 August 2015, a quasi-judicial order, is liable to be interfered with under the limited scope of writ review (arbitrariness, perversity, excess of jurisdiction, violation of natural justice, or unreasonableness).

¶ 11–12

ii.2. Whether the DPO could, after an unexplained delay of about one and a half years, rely on alleged deficiencies in the quality of work to deny payment for work completed before November 2013.

¶ 14–16

iii.3. Whether the petitioners are entitled to payment for the 4,824 walls executed, and whether disputed questions concerning the remaining walls can be decided in writ proceedings.

¶ 13, 17–19

03Law Applied

The court applied the established principles of judicial review of administrative and quasi-judicial orders, under which a writ court may interfere if the order is arbitrary or perverse, the authority has exceeded its jurisdiction, natural justice has been violated, or no reasonable authority could have reached the decision.

¶ 11

The principle that a public authority must decide claims within a reasonable time, and that a failure to do so amounts to arbitrariness.

¶ 15

The maxim that an authority cannot take advantage of its own inaction, so a belated plea of defective execution cannot defeat a claim when the authority neither inspected the work nor held an enquiry at the relevant time.

¶ 15–16

The principle that writ proceedings are not suited to disputed questions of fact, which must be left to a civil suit.

¶ 19

No specific statutory provisions or precedents are cited in the judgment.

04Reasoning

The court held that the petitioners had not shown any procedural impropriety in the DPO's order, but found that the order could not stand on the merits.

¶ 12

The DPO admitted that 4,824 walls had been completed, but the deficiencies he relied on were recorded in August 2015, more than one and a half years after the work was finished and after the petitioners' November 2013 payment request.

¶ 13–14

No inventory or enquiry was conducted during the relevant period, and the DPO did not decide the bills within a reasonable time despite repeated representations and the earlier writ direction. The court characterised this inaction as an arbitrary approach that deprived the petitioners of a legitimate claim.

¶ 15

Applying the maxim that the authority cannot take advantage of its own inaction, the court refused to accept the belated quality objection.

¶ 16

For the 4,824 walls, the court found no genuine dispute requiring evidence and ordered payment. For the remaining walls, the court found that the questions involved disputed facts and left the petitioners to a civil suit.

¶ 17, 19

05Holding

The DPO's order dated 13 August 2015 was arbitrary and is set aside, because the authority's unexplained delay of about one and a half years, with no inventory or enquiry, precluded a belated plea of poor quality.

¶ 15–17

The court directed the DPO to release the proportionate amount for the 4,824 walls within two weeks of communication of the order, with 10% per annum interest from 11 November 2013 until actual disbursement.

¶ 18

As to the remaining walls, the petitioners may file a civil suit, as those issues involve disputed questions of fact. The writ petition is disposed of with no order as to costs.

¶ 19–21
Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

BHAGIRATH ENGINEERS COOP. SERVICE CONSTR. SOCIETY LTD & ANRvsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS

Calcutta High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment