01Facts
The petitioner, the elderly mother of the opposite party no. 2 (OP-2), complained to the Sub-Divisional Officer (SDO), Kandi, alleging ill-treatment by OP-2, her eldest son, and that a 2019 deed (No. 1125 of 2019) transferring 11 decimals of property (LR Plot No. 6050) to OP-2's family was procured through his fraud, as she was illiterate and the deed was not explained to her.
¶ 3–4The SDO registered the complaint under Rule 4(1) of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 ("the Act").
¶ 5On 12.05.2022, the SDO declared the 2019 deed void for fraud and directed cancellation.
¶ 6OP-2 filed Criminal Revision No. 15 of 2022 before the Additional Sessions Judge, Kandi, which was entertained and allowed by judgment dated 06.01.2023, setting aside the SDO's order.
¶ 2, 7, 9The Sessions Judge held that the petitioner had not sought maintenance and had sufficient means, and that s. 23 was not satisfied.
¶ 8, 15The petitioner then filed the present petition under s. 482 Cr.P.C.
¶ 1, 10The judgment records the complaint as filed on 13.07.2022 yet registered in a case number variously stated as 30/2020 and 30/2022.
¶ 2, 3, 5The petitioner contended that the Act provides no revision against a Tribunal's order to a son, and that s. 23 covers basic physical needs, not merely maintenance.
¶ 11–13OP-2 contended that the deed contained no conditions, that he cared for the petitioner, and that the revision was maintainable.
¶ 16–1702Issues
i.1. Whether a revisional application under the Cr.P.C. filed by OP-2, a son against whom the Tribunal (SDO) passed an order under the Act, was maintainable, given that s. 16 of the Act confers an appeal only on a senior citizen or parent aggrieved by such an order.
¶ 18–20ii.2. Whether the Additional Sessions Judge acted without jurisdiction in entertaining the revision and setting aside the SDO's order, warranting interference under s. 482 Cr.P.C.
¶ 20–2103Law Applied
Section 15 of the Act provides for constitution of one Appellate Tribunal per district, presided over by an officer not below the rank of District Magistrate.
¶ 18Section 16(1) of the Act permits "any senior citizen or a parent" aggrieved by a Tribunal's order to appeal within sixty days, and the remaining sub-sections regulate the appellate procedure.
¶ 18Section 23(1) of the Act provides that a transfer made by a senior citizen, subject to the transferee providing basic amenities and physical needs and failing to do so, is deemed to have been made by fraud, coercion or undue influence and is void at the transferor's option.
¶ 18Section 23(2)–(3) of the Act concern enforcement of maintenance rights and action on behalf of incapacitated seniors.
¶ 18The court invoked its inherent power under s. 482 Cr.P.C. to correct an order passed without jurisdiction and prevent abuse of process.
¶ 20Where a statute provides a specific remedy to a defined class, that remedy is exhaustive and a revision is not available to persons outside that class.
¶ 19–20Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482
Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 Section 4Section 5Section 15Section 16Section 23
04Reasoning
Section 16 confers an appeal only on a senior citizen or parent aggrieved by a Tribunal order.
¶ 19OP-2 was the son against whom the order was passed. He was neither a senior citizen nor a parent, so s. 16 gave him no remedy, and the Act provides no revision. The Sessions Judge's revisional jurisdiction therefore had no statutory foundation.
¶ 20The court treated the defect as jurisdictional rather than procedural, so the impugned judgment was "palpable and ex facie illegal" and could be set aside under s. 482 Cr.P.C.
¶ 20Because the infirmity lay in maintainability, the court declined to examine the merits, including the s. 23 arguments on basic physical needs, maintenance, and the terms of the deed, and expressly left those questions open.
¶ 2205Holding
The revisional application at the instance of OP-2 was not maintainable under the Act, and the Additional Sessions Judge acted without jurisdiction in entertaining it and setting aside the SDO's order.
¶ 20The impugned judgment dated 06.01.2023 is set aside under s. 482 Cr.P.C., the CRR is allowed, and pending applications are disposed of.
¶ 21The merits of the SDO's order and the s. 23 issues remain undecided.
¶ 22OP-2 may pursue appropriate recourse before the appropriate forum within two weeks of obtaining a certified copy, with any delay to be dealt with in accordance with law, and such proceedings are to be decided without being influenced by the judgment's observations. A copy is to be sent to the Tribunal for information.
¶ 22–23Original Court PDF
CHABI RANI BANDHOPADHYAY @ CHHABI RANI BANOPADHYAYvsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
