01Facts
The petitioner, a Scheduled Caste employee of Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. (a public sector insurer), served at the Magma/Broker Business Cell, Kolkata, from 2010 to 2014
¶ 2He was charged with approving and issuing over 500 Motor TP stand-alone policies under the Misc-D head instead of commercial vehicle policies, causing an alleged loss of about Rs. 67 lakhs
¶ 4A disciplinary inquiry under the OICL (Conduct, Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 2014 followed. The Enquiry Officer found Charges 2 to 5 fully proved and Charge 1 partially proved; the Disciplinary Authority treated Charge 1 as fully proved
¶ 6On 08.03.2021, the Disciplinary Authority imposed reduction of basic pay by three increments
¶ 3, 8The appeal was rejected on 20.12.2021 by a cryptic order that did not address the CBI material
¶ 9, 12The memorial representation was rejected on 30.08.2022
¶ 16, 40Meanwhile, the CBI filed a closure/charge-sheet report on 28.09.2019 finding no criminality against the petitioner, and the Special CBI Court dropped the proceedings on 21.04.2022
¶ 10, 14On the National Commission for Scheduled Castes' advice, the petitioner filed a mercy petition on 13.03.2023
¶ 18, 19The Appellate Authority reduced the penalty to reduction by two increments by order dated 25.09.2023, without reasons on the merits
¶ 20, 21, 30The petitioner filed this writ in 2024 challenging that order as non-speaking and arbitrary
¶ 2202Issues
i.1. Whether the findings and penalty in the disciplinary proceedings call for interference under Article 226?
¶ 33(i)ii.2. Whether the CBI final report and the Special Court's order dated 21.04.2022 have any bearing on the findings of the Disciplinary Authority?
¶ 33(ii)03Law Applied
The settled principle that a disciplinary proceeding and a criminal prosecution are distinct, with different forums, objects and standards of proof, so an acquittal or discharge in the criminal case does not automatically affect the departmental finding
¶ 36, 37Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Ltd. v. C. Nagaraju (2019) 10 SCC 367, which holds that a criminal court's acquittal does not preclude departmental action, that the disciplinary authority is not bound by the criminal verdict where the departmental evidence differs, and that the departmental standard of proof is not strictly that of the law of evidence
¶ 38An order reducing penalty on a mercy petition is an act of clemency, not a fresh adjudication on merits, and requires no detailed reasons
¶ 40A party who has sought and obtained such clemency cannot later contest the penalty on merits
¶ 42A closed-mind or Article 14 challenge fails where the authority has granted partial relief
¶ 41The petitioner's authorities (Satya Narayan Kushwaha, Raj Kishore Jha (2003) 11 SCC 519, and Vishnu Dev Sharma (2008) 3 SCC 172) were distinguished as factually different
¶ 3904Reasoning
The charges were proved in the departmental inquiry and the findings survived appeal and the memorial representation, which the petitioner did not challenge in any forum
¶ 34, 35, 40Applying the distinction between disciplinary and criminal proceedings, the CBI closure and the Special Court's discharge did not undermine the departmental finding, because the disciplinary authority is not bound by the criminal outcome and the evidence before it differed
¶ 36–38The petitioner's mercy petition sought, in substance, re-examination of guilt already upheld on appeal and memorial; the authority was entitled to decline that and to grant only a humanitarian reduction
¶ 41Because the reduction benefited the petitioner and did not revisit merits, the absence of detailed reasons did not render it bad in law
¶ 40Having accepted this relief and allowed the earlier orders of 20.12.2021 and 30.08.2022 to stand unchallenged, the petitioner was estopped from contesting the penalty on merits, and the writ was filed late in 2024
¶ 4205Holding
The findings and penalty do not call for interference
¶ 34The CBI final report and the discharge order of 21.04.2022 have no bearing on the departmental findings, since the two proceedings are independent
¶ 36, 38The order of 25.09.2023 reducing the penalty to two increments is an act of clemency that needs no elaborate reasons, does not disturb the finding of guilt, and is not arbitrary or violative of Article 14
¶ 40, 41WPA No. 14467 of 2024 was dismissed without costs, and the interim order, if any, was vacated
¶ 42–44Original Court PDF
AJOY DEB MANDALvsTHE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED AND ORS.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
