01Facts
The petitioners, a developer and the landowner (respondent no. 8), sought sanction for a G+IV residential building at Holding No. 80/2, Kshetra Mohan Banerjee Lane, Ward No. 33, Howrah, at a proposed height of 15.49 m.
¶ 3The property lies within 500 m of Nabanna, notified as a "Security Zone" under Sections 243–244 of the Howrah Municipal Corporation Act, 1980.
¶ 3–4The building plan was submitted on 27.02.2020.
¶ 3The Commissioner of Police raised concerns about pollution and labour-related security risks.
¶ 4Following a series of writ proceedings, the Commissioner, by order dated 24.09.2024 passed under the directions in WPO 477 of 2024, held that sanction could not be refused on height grounds and granted conditional permission subject to 17 conditions.
¶ 5–6, 11–12A Coordinate Bench, by order dated 11.03.2026 in WPA 2445 of 2025, struck down conditions 4, 5 and 16 as arbitrary, disproportionate and violative of Articles 14 and 19(1)(g), and directed the HMC to finalise the sanction without insisting on the quashed conditions.
¶ 7–8The HMC had not raised any objection based on offline processing before that Bench.
¶ 13By a cryptic order dated 29.05.2026, the Executive Engineer (Building) directed the petitioners to re-apply through the Online Building Plan Approval System (OBPAS), stating that offline approval was not possible.
¶ 8The HMC relied on a Government of West Bengal notification dated 31.12.2024 requiring OBPAS for plans approved on or after 01.01.2025.
¶ 9, 1302Issues
i.1. Whether the Executive Engineer's order dated 29.05.2026, directing fresh application through OBPAS, is arbitrary and overreaches the Coordinate Bench's directions dated 11.03.2026.
¶ 8, 13, 15–16ii.2. Whether the HMC can rely on the notification dated 31.12.2024 to refuse processing of a pending application, having accepted the earlier order and not raised the issue before the Court.
¶ 9–10, 13, 15iii.3. Whether the petitioners are entitled to a direction for finalisation of the building plan, and on what terms.
¶ 14, 1603Law Applied
Sections 243 and 244 of the Howrah Municipal Corporation Act, 1980, under which the Nabanna security zone restricts building height.
¶ 3–4Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, under which conditions that are intrusive, disproportionate, or lack a rational nexus to the building permit are arbitrary and ultra vires.
¶ 7The principle that a public authority must act in accordance with the directions of a court and cannot resile from its prior stance or the conduct it adopted before the court to defeat a right already recognised.
¶ 13, 15The Government of West Bengal notification dated 31.12.2024, which makes OBPAS applicable to plans approved on or after 01.01.2025.
¶ 9, 13The earlier orders of the Coordinate Bench dated 24.05.2024 and 11.03.2026, which are relied upon without any binding precedent being expressly cited beyond them.
¶ 5, 7Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Howrah Municipal Corporation Act, 1980 Section 243Section 244
04Reasoning
The Commissioner had already concluded that the 15.4 m height did not breach the Nabanna limit and that sanction could not be refused on that ground. The HMC had only withheld sanction pending compliance with the 17 conditions, and it never contended before the Coordinate Bench that offline processing was barred.
¶ 11, 13Since three conditions were struck down, what remained outstanding was only the petitioners' readiness to comply with the rest. The 29.05.2026 order, which required fresh OBPAS filing, overreached the direction to consider and process the existing application.
¶ 13–14Although the notification of 31.12.2024 pre-dated the 11.03.2026 order, the HMC did not invoke it then, accepted the order, and did not seek review. Permitting it to be raised now would undo the sanction-process in principle already agreed to, and would therefore be arbitrary. The OBPAS requirement was therefore treated as inapplicable to this pending application on the peculiar facts.
¶ 1505Holding
The HMC cannot, at this stage, insist on fresh offline or OBPAS filing, and the 29.05.2026 communication is arbitrary and unsustainable.
¶ 15The communication dated 29.05.2026 is quashed. The Commissioner, HMC, is directed to finalise the petitioners' building plan forthwith, subject to the petitioners furnishing an undertaking to comply with the remaining conditions within two weeks of communication of the order. Upon such compliance, the Commissioner must process the application without insisting on any other compliance, expeditiously and within 10 days of receipt. The writ petition is disposed of accordingly.
¶ 16–18Original Court PDF
AMBEE ENGINEERING PRIVATE LIMITED AND ANRvsHOWRAH MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
