01Facts
The petitioners, a borrower company and its directors, challenged a show-cause notice dated 21.12.2023 and a communication dated 21.03.2024 classifying their loan account as a "fraud account" under the RBI Master Directions on Frauds, 2016
¶ 1Their credit facilities, originally with Canara Bank and later United Bank of India, were enhanced and extended to several entities
¶ 2-3Following financial stress, the accounts were classified as NPA, and the Bank initiated SARFAESI proceedings
¶ 4-5, 11-12A prior writ (WPA 9820 of 2021) and its appeal (MAT 643 of 2021) led to a status quo order, and the Bank later filed OA 410 of 2022 before the DRT under Section 19 of RDDBFI Act, 1993
¶ 6-7, 13The Bank's show-cause notice dated 21.12.2023 was based on a forensic audit report (FAR)
¶ 8, 14The Bank said extracts of the FAR were enclosed with the notice; the petitioners contended that only the full report was relevant and that even extracts were not received
¶ 15, 19The petitioners' letter dated 04.01.2024 requesting documents, including the FAR, was not acceded to
¶ 8, 20The Bank classified the account as fraud, reported it to the RBI on 16.03.2024, and intimated the petitioners by letter dated 21.03.2024, which gave no reasons
¶ 16, 21The Bank first disclosed an internal order dated 11.03.2024, marked "For Approval," in its affidavit-in-opposition after remand; the petitioners alleged it was anterior-dated and never communicated
¶ 17, 22-23A Coordinate Bench had set aside the 21.03.2024 letter on 29.04.2024, but the Division Bench remanded the matter on 16.09.2025 for the Bank to file its affidavit-in-opposition
¶ 2202Issues
i.1. Whether the Bank's procedure before classifying the petitioners' account as "fraud" (including furnishing only extracts of the FAR) satisfied the requirements of natural justice, the applicable RBI framework and settled law.
¶ 31, 38-41ii.2. Whether the petitioners' failure to challenge the Bank's internal FRMD Circular No. 70/2023 and the RBI Master Directions makes that circular binding and immune from judicial scrutiny.
¶ 39-40iii.3. Whether the Bank's partial disclosure of the FAR, on the ground that it contained information about bank officials and third parties, was a permissible basis for withholding it.
¶ 28, 37, 4103Law Applied
The Court applied the principle of audi alteram partem, as laid down in Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel, (1985) 3 SCC 398, under which a person must know the allegations and the evidence relied on against him and be allowed to respond
¶ 33It relied on State Bank of India v. Rajesh Agarwal, (2023) 6 SCC 1, which held that classification as fraud carries serious civil consequences and requires notice, an opportunity to explain the forensic audit findings, and a reasoned decision
¶ 32It followed State Bank of India v. Amit Iron Private Limited (2026 INSC 323, as cited by counsel) as the authoritative clarification of that principle: there is no right to a personal hearing, but the audit report, including the FAR, must be furnished as the rule, and portions may be withheld only for reasons recorded that protect third-party privacy or rights, and redaction must not be used unreasonably
¶ 34-37, 44The Court also relied on Article 141 of the Constitution, under which Supreme Court law binds all authorities, so that compliance with an internal circular cannot validate action inconsistent with that law
¶ 40Its jurisdiction under Article 226 is limited to examining the decision-making process, not the merits of the fraud allegations
¶ 42-43Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Recovery Of Debts And Bankruptcy Act, 1993 Section 19
04Reasoning
The Court first rejected the Bank's contention that the petitioners could not challenge the FRMD Circular because they had not impugned it. An internal circular cannot override binding Supreme Court law, so the question was whether the Bank's procedure complied with that law
¶ 39-40The Bank admitted that the entire FAR was not supplied and that only extracts were furnished, and it relied on its internal policy to justify withholding. The Court held that the presence of statements by bank officials does not, by itself, justify withholding the whole report
¶ 38, 41Under Amit Iron, the Bank had to identify the particular portions that could lawfully be withheld to protect third-party rights and record reasons for doing so, and it had not done so
¶ 38, 41Because the petitioners were denied the material on which the classification rested, they could not effectively respond. The Court therefore held that the petitioners were entitled to the FAR, subject only to justified redaction
¶ 43The Court did not decide the merits of the alleged diversion or misappropriation, and it did not examine the authenticity of the 11.03.2024 order, which the petitioners disputed
¶ 17, 42, 48The Court's narrow focus was on procedural fairness. It recorded that the petitioners are not entitled to a personal hearing, so a written representation after disclosure, duly considered in a reasoned decision, would satisfy natural justice
¶ 4405Holding
The Court held that the Bank's procedure did not satisfy the requirements of natural justice because the entire FAR was not furnished without reasons for redaction
¶ 41, 43The communication dated 21.03.2024 is set aside, and the show-cause notice dated 21.12.2023 is revived
¶ 45-46The Bank must furnish the FAR, subject to permissible redaction under Amit Iron. Any withheld portion must be identified with reasons. The petitioners must then be allowed a reasonable opportunity to make a representation on the FAR and other relied-upon material. The competent authority must consider that representation independently and pass a fresh, reasoned, speaking order under the RBI Directions
¶ 46-47The Court expressed no opinion on the merits of the fraud allegations or on whether the account should ultimately be classified as fraud, and those questions are left to the Bank. The DRT proceedings are not affected. The writ petition is disposed of in these terms, with no order as to costs
¶ 48-51Original Court PDF
SIDDHI VINAYAK HIMGHAR (P) LTD. AND ORS.vsPUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
