Calcutta High CourtBanking and Finance LawAdministrative and Public Law

Banks must share the full forensic audit report with borrowers before labelling their loan accounts as fraud, Calcutta HC rules

RIDHI SIDHI COLD STORAGE PVT. LTD AND ORS.v.PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.

Banks must share the full forensic audit report with borrowers before labelling their loan accounts as fraud, Calcutta HC rules. RIDHI SIDHI COLD STORAGE PVT. LTD AND ORS. vs PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the procedure adopted by the bank before classifying the petitioners' loan account as "fraud" satisfies the requirements of natural justice, the applicable RBI framework, and settled principles of law.

The court held

The procedure was held deficient because the complete FAR was not furnished, and the bank's internal circular could not justify withholding it.

It also directed

The communication classifying the account as "fraud" (dated 21.3.2024 per the court) is set aside, and the show-cause notice dated 12.12.2023 is revived.

The bank must furnish the FAR, subject only to redaction on recorded reasons under Amit Iron, and the petitioners must then be given a reasonable opportunity to make a written representation.

The competent authority must pass a fresh, reasoned, speaking order under the RBI Directions.

The court expressed no opinion on the merits of the fraud allegations, and the bank may continue its DRT proceedings.

The writ petition is disposed of with no order as to costs.

01Facts

The petitioners are a borrower company and its directors engaged in manufacturing organic manure.

Petitioner nos. 2 and 4 were earlier partners of a firm that held a credit facility from Canara Bank, later taken over by United Bank of India and enhanced to Rs. 50 lakhs.

¶ 2

At the bank's instance, the petitioners acquired several NPA/closed cold storage units through different companies, which increased their exposure.

¶ 3

Accounts were classified as NPA, and the petitioners' restructuring requests were allegedly not considered.

¶ 4–5

Earlier proceedings (WPA 9820 of 2021 and MAT 643 of 2021) concerned SARFAESI measures; the writ petition was later allowed on 5.8.2025 and the bank's appeal (MAT 1887 of 2025) is pending. The bank's recovery proceedings (OA 407 of 2022) before the DRT are also pending.

¶ 6–7, 12–13

The bank appointed a forensic auditor after alleging diversion of funds and suspicious transactions, and issued a show-cause notice dated 12.12.2023 proposing fraud classification.

¶ 14, 8

The bank asserts that extracts of the forensic audit report (FAR) were enclosed with the notice.

¶ 15

The petitioners sought the FAR and other documents by letter, which the bank did not supply.

¶ 8, 20

By letter dated 29.12.2023, the petitioners were informed of the fraud classification.

¶ 8

The bank relies on an internal order dated 11.3.2024, marked "For Approval," which the petitioners say was never communicated.

¶ 17, 22–23

A Coordinate Bench earlier set aside the classification on the ground that the FAR was not furnished; the appellate court remanded the matter for fresh consideration.

¶ 22

The court later refers to the impugned communication as dated 21.3.2024.

¶ 45–46

The bank admits that the entire FAR was not supplied, relying on the FRMD Circular No. 70/2023 and withholding portions concerning bank officials and third parties.

¶ 26–28, 38

02Issues

i.1. Whether the procedure adopted by the bank before classifying the petitioners' loan account as "fraud" satisfies the requirements of natural justice, the applicable RBI framework, and settled principles of law.

¶ 31

ii.2. Whether the petitioners were entitled to the complete forensic audit report, or whether supply of extracts, and the bank's internal circular, were sufficient.

¶ 36–41

iii.3. Whether the petitioners are entitled to a personal or oral hearing before classification.

¶ 44

03Law Applied

The principle of audi alteram partem requires that a person facing an adverse decision be informed of the allegations and the material relied upon, and be given an opportunity to respond, as laid down in Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel, (1985) 3 SCC 398.

¶ 32–33

State Bank of India v. Rajesh Agarwal, (2023) 6 SCC 1, holds that fraud classification entails serious civil consequences, that the borrower must be heard on the FAR findings before classification, and that the decision must be a reasoned order.

¶ 32

In State Bank of India v. Amit Iron Private Ltd., 2026 INSC 323, the Supreme Court held that no personal hearing is required, that the FAR must be furnished as a rule (mere findings are insufficient), and that redaction is permitted only for third-party privacy or rights, for reasons recorded, and without unreasonable use.

¶ 34–37

Under Article 141, Supreme Court law binds all authorities, so an internal circular cannot override it.

¶ 39–40

The RBI Master Directions on Frauds (2016, as updated in 2024) and the bank's FRMD Circular No. 70/2023 are relevant procedural frameworks.

¶ 11, 27–28

Review under Article 226 is confined to the decision-making process, not the merits of the fraud allegations.

¶ 42

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Recovery Of Debts And Bankruptcy Act, 1993 Section 19

04Reasoning

The court held that the bank's reliance on the FRMD Circular and the absence of a challenge to it did not immunise the procedure from judicial review, because the circular cannot dilute the law declared by the Supreme Court.

¶ 39–40

The bank admitted that the complete FAR was withheld and gave only extracts.

¶ 38

The bank's justification, that the report contained statements about bank officials, did not meet the Amit Iron requirement that redaction be limited to portions affecting third-party privacy or rights, identified specifically and supported by recorded reasons.

¶ 41

Because the petitioners were not given the report on which the classification rested, they could not meaningfully respond, and the natural-justice requirement was not satisfied.

¶ 41, 43

On the hearing issue, the court held that a written representation after disclosure of the relied-upon material suffices, and that no personal hearing is required.

¶ 44

The court did not decide whether the petitioners had committed fraud, which is for the competent authority.

¶ 42, 48

The court did not decide the disputed authenticity of the 11.3.2024 order or the alleged misstatements in the affidavit, which it did not address in its reasoning.

05Holding

The procedure was held deficient because the complete FAR was not furnished, and the bank's internal circular could not justify withholding it.

¶ 39–41

The communication classifying the account as "fraud" (dated 21.3.2024 per the court) is set aside, and the show-cause notice dated 12.12.2023 is revived.

¶ 45–46

The bank must furnish the FAR, subject only to redaction on recorded reasons under Amit Iron, and the petitioners must then be given a reasonable opportunity to make a written representation.

¶ 46–47

The competent authority must pass a fresh, reasoned, speaking order under the RBI Directions.

¶ 47

The court expressed no opinion on the merits of the fraud allegations, and the bank may continue its DRT proceedings.

¶ 48–49

The writ petition is disposed of with no order as to costs.

¶ 50–51
Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

RIDHI SIDHI COLD STORAGE PVT. LTD AND ORS.vsPUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.

Calcutta High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment