01Facts
The petitioners, a borrower company and its directors, challenged a show-cause notice dated 28.12.2023 proposing to classify their loan account as a "fraud account" and a communication dated 21.03.2024 classifying it as such.
¶ 1The petitioners alleged that their accounts were classified as NPA despite restructuring requests during and after the COVID-19 period.
¶ 5Earlier proceedings (WPA/WPO 9820 of 2021 and MAT 643 of 2021) concerned SARFAESI measures, and the Bank later initiated O.A. 401 of 2022 before the DRT.
¶ 6–7, 12–13The Bank stated that a forensic audit report (FAR) had been commissioned, and that extracts of it were annexed to the show-cause notice.
¶ 14–15The petitioners' letter dated 13.01.2024 requesting documents, including the FAR, was not acceded to.
¶ 8, 20The petitioners pleaded that only one-page cryptic intimation was received.
¶ 21The Bank relied on an internal order dated 11.03.2024, marked "For Approval," which the petitioners contended was never communicated to them, relying on a postal receipt recording a consignment weight of 15 grams.
¶ 17, 23The Bank's position was that it followed the FRMD Circular No. 70/2023 and withheld portions of the FAR relating to bank officials and third parties.
¶ 11, 2802Issues
i.1. Whether the procedure adopted by the Bank before classifying the petitioners' loan account as "fraud" satisfied the requirements of natural justice, the applicable RBI framework, and settled principles of law.
¶ 31ii.2. Whether the petitioners, having not challenged the FRMD Circular or the RBI Master Directions, were bound by the Bank's internal procedure and precluded from questioning it.
¶ 39–40iii.3. Whether the Bank's failure to furnish the complete FAR, without recording reasons for redaction, vitiated the classification.
¶ 38, 41, 4303Law Applied
Article 141 of the Constitution, under which Supreme Court decisions bind all authorities.
¶ 40State Bank of India v. Rajesh Kumar Agarwal, (2023) 6 SCC 1, which holds that fraud classification entails serious civil consequences, so the borrower must be heard on the material relied upon, including the FAR, and that the decision must be reasoned.
¶ 32Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel, (1985) 3 SCC 398, for the audi alteram partem rule, requiring notice of allegations and evidence, inspection of documents, and an opportunity to adduce a defence.
¶ 33State Bank of India v. Amit Iron Private Ltd., 2026 INSC 323, which holds that: no personal hearing is a right; furnishing audit reports, including the FAR, is mandatory; furnishing only findings is insufficient; redaction is permissible only for reasons recorded to protect third-party privacy and must not be exercised unreasonably; and internal RBI-compliant procedure must still satisfy natural justice.
¶ 34–37, 44The FRMD Circular is an internal guideline that cannot override Supreme Court law.
¶ 39Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Recovery Of Debts And Bankruptcy Act, 1993 Section 19
04Reasoning
The FRMD Circular's non-challenge did not immunise the Bank's action from judicial review, and compliance with an internal circular cannot validate action inconsistent with binding Supreme Court law.
¶ 39–40The Bank admitted that the entire FAR was not supplied, only extracts were furnished, and portions were withheld on the ground that they referred to bank officials and third parties.
¶ 38The Court held that the mere presence of bank officials' statements does not justify withholding the report in its entirety, and that the Bank was required to identify specific portions and record reasons for redaction.
¶ 41Because the petitioners were not furnished the FAR, they were not placed in a position to submit an effective representation on the report's findings, and the natural justice requirement was not satisfied.
¶ 41, 43The Court expressly declined to examine the merits of the fraud allegations, as that determination lies with the competent authority.
¶ 42–4305Holding
The Bank's procedure did not comply with the natural justice requirements laid down in Rajesh Agarwal and Amit Iron, because the complete FAR was not furnished and no reasons for redaction were recorded.
¶ 38, 41, 43The communication dated 21.03.2024 classifying the account as fraud was set aside, and the show-cause notice dated 28.12.2023 was revived.
¶ 45–46The Bank was directed to furnish the FAR, subject to reasoned and Amit Iron-compliant redaction, to permit the petitioners to submit a representation within a reasonable time, and to pass a fresh reasoned order.
¶ 46–47The Court expressed no opinion on the merits of the fraud allegations or on whether the account warrants fraud classification.
¶ 48The Bank may pursue O.A. 401 of 2022 before the DRT.
¶ 49The writ petition was disposed of with no order as to costs.
¶ 50–51Original Court PDF
SIDDHANTH VEDANT COLD STORAGE (P) LTD AND ORS.vsPUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
