01Facts
The petitioner, a Customer Assistant at the Bally Durgapur Branch of State Bank of India until 2013, was alleged to have caused a Rs.1,000 double debit to a customer's account on 2 September 2013
¶ 2He was called upon to explain on 5 and 16 September 2013 and, after a reminder dated 6 December 2013, allegedly did not respond
¶ 3He was transferred to Chandanpur Branch on 15 January 2014
¶ 4He was called upon on 17 September 2014 to explain further irregularities, was suspended on 7 January 2015, and was served a charge-sheet on 23 April 2015 describing the allegations as major misconduct under Clause 7(c) of the Memorandum of Settlement (MoS)
¶ 5–6The charge-sheet contained six articles of charge
¶ 7The petitioner contended that Clause 7(c) concerns minor misconduct, that the charge-sheet lacked lists of documents and witnesses, and that his document requests went unanswered
¶ 8–9A departmental enquiry was instituted on 28 May 2015, and three charges were modified by corrigendum
¶ 15The Enquiry Officer (EO) held five charges proved and Charge No. 3 not proved
¶ 17The Disciplinary Authority (DA) imposed removal from service without disqualification on 5 December 2015
¶ 19The Appellate Authority (AA) dismissed the appeal on 17 March 2016
¶ 20The respondents admitted that Charge No. 3 could not be established
¶ 26The petitioner sought reinstatement and back wages
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the disciplinary proceeding stood vitiated by the charge-sheet's reference to Clause 7(c) of the MoS (minor misconduct) instead of Clause 5(j) (major misconduct)
¶ 47–48ii.2. Whether the delay in initiating proceedings rendered the charges stale and prejudicial to the petitioner
¶ 46iii.3. Whether non-furnishing of documents and lists of witnesses vitiated the enquiry
¶ 49iv.4. Whether the change in the incumbent Disciplinary Authority vitiated the proceedings
¶ 50v.5. Whether the DA and AA orders were cryptic or non-speaking
¶ 51vi.6. Whether the findings of the EO were perverse or unsupported by evidence
¶ 52vii.7. Whether the absence of financial loss to the Bank, or subsequent refund, absolves the misconduct
¶ 54–55viii.8. Whether the penalty of removal from service was disproportionate
¶ 5603Law Applied
The Court reiterated that judicial review of disciplinary action is confined to the decision-making process, but extends to perversity, irrationality, no-evidence findings, disproportionality, and breach of natural justice or statutory rules, relying on B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India and Union of India v. P. Gunasekaran.
¶ 44The Court held that a mere erroneous reference to a clause in a charge-sheet does not vitiate proceedings where the substance of the charge and its nature are clear and no real prejudice is shown, relying on the decisions cited earlier by the Bank, including P.K. Palanisami and Union of India v. S.C. Parashar.
¶ 48 · ¶ 38Delay alone does not invalidate proceedings; the test is whether it was unreasonable and prejudicial.
¶ 46A charged employee must demonstrate specific prejudice from non-supply of documents, consistent with State Bank of Patiala v. S.K. Sharma and State Bank of India v. Bidyut Kumar Mitra, cited at para. 41.
¶ 49 · ¶ 41A change of Disciplinary Authority is not invalid absent prejudice or failure to consider the record.
¶ 50The DA need not reproduce the enquiry report, but must show application of mind; the AA must consider the grounds of appeal.
¶ 51Financial loss is not a precondition for misconduct; a bank employee must observe prescribed safeguards, and subsequent refund cannot legitimise an unauthorised transaction, relying on the decisions cited at para. 42, including State Bank of India v. Bela Bagchi and TNCS Corpn. v. K. Meerabai.
¶ 54–55 · ¶ 42Penalty must bear a reasonable relationship to the gravity of the proved misconduct.
¶ 56Relevant provisions of the MoS are Clauses 5(j), 6(b), 7(c) and 12(B).
04Reasoning
The Court held that the Clause 7(c) reference was an inadvertent error because the charge-sheet expressly described the allegations as major misconduct, set out each transaction, and the petitioner replied in detail and participated in the enquiry; he showed no real prejudice.
¶ 48On delay, the sequence of events from September 2013 to April 2015 did not amount to stale charges, and the petitioner identified no prejudice, as the transactions were traceable through records.
¶ 46On documents, the petitioner did not show which essential document was withheld or how its absence impaired his defence.
¶ 49On the DA change, the petitioner showed no failure of the successor to consider the record.
¶ 50The DA and AA orders were held to reflect application of mind, notwithstanding their brevity.
¶ 51The EO's rejection of Charge No. 3 was treated as evidence of separate consideration of charges, not mechanical acceptance, and the remaining findings were not shown to be unsupported by evidence.
¶ 52The Court characterised the charges as repeated handling of customers' funds without authority, distinct from isolated negligence, and therefore "strike at the very foundation of the trust" reposed in the employee.
¶ 53Subsequent refund and customer letters did not dilute the obligation to follow procedure at the time of transactions.
¶ 54Absence of financial loss was immaterial because the integrity obligation does not depend on monetary loss.
¶ 55Given the cumulative nature of several proved irregularities, removal was not shockingly disproportionate.
¶ 5605Holding
The Court held that the Clause 7(c) reference, delay, non-supply of documents, change of Disciplinary Authority, and alleged non-speaking orders did not vitiate the disciplinary proceedings, that the EO's findings, the DA's order and the AA's order were not perverse, and that the penalty was not disproportionate.
¶ 46–52 · ¶ 56–57Holding: the writ petition is dismissed for lack of merit, and the removal from service is upheld.
¶ 58No order as to costs. The prayers for reinstatement and back wages are refused as a consequence.
¶ 57–58Original Court PDF
PRASANTA BISWASvsSTATE BANK OF INDIA & ORS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
