01Facts
Jayanta Kumar Basu and Anita Basu were joint owners of Flat No. A-3 in a multi-storied building at Galf Green Urban Complex.
¶ 2(a)On 19.11.1992, the Basus applied to the West Bengal Housing Board ("Board") for a car parking space in the same complex, depositing Rs. 7,000 by cheque.
¶ 2(b)On 18.12.1992, the Board provisionally allotted car parking space BG-3 to the Basus, subject to certain conditions.
¶ 2(c)On 29.10.1997, the Board decided to allot car parking space BG-9 in the name of Mr. Basu and stated it would prepare a conveyance deed in due course. The judgment refers variously to BG-3/BG-19 and BG-9 for the same car parking space; the record is not consistent on this point.
¶ 2(d), 2(g), 1By a registered deed of conveyance dated 30.03.1993, the Basus transferred Apartment No. 3-A to the petitioner, who took possession.
¶ 2(e)The conveyance schedule does not mention any car parking space.
¶ 11By a letter dated 30.03.1993, the Basus undertook to hand over the car parking space to the petitioner once the Board allotted it to them.
¶ 2(f)By a memo dated 19.09.2019, the Board revoked its earlier memo dated 29.10.1997 on the ground that the original allottee no longer owned Flat A-3, and declined to allot the car parking space to the petitioner.
¶ 1, 2(g)The petitioner challenged the 2019 memo and sought relief through CAN 5 of 2026.
¶ 1, 602Issues
i.1. Whether, upon transfer of Flat No. A-3 by registered conveyance, the car parking space allotted to the vendors passed to the petitioner as an incident of the property under Section 8 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, so as to entitle him to allotment of that space.
¶ 3, 4, 5, 12ii.2. Whether the petitioner, not being the allottee or transferee of the car parking space, is aggrieved by the Board's non-transfer of that space and the 2019 memo, such that he is entitled to the reliefs sought.
¶ 7, 13, 1403Law Applied
Section 8 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provides that, unless a different intention is expressed or necessarily implied, a transfer passes to the transferee all interest the transferor is capable of passing in the property and its legal incidents.
¶ 9For a house, the legal incidents include annexed easements, rent accruing after transfer, and locks, keys, bars, doors, windows, and other things provided for permanent use with it.
¶ 9, 10Section 8 requires that the claimed right be an inseparable incident of the conveyed property, and not merely a right the vendor was promised or had been allotted.
¶ 10, 13No separate precedent is cited in the judgment; the decision rests on the statutory text and the terms of the conveyance deed.
Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 8
04Reasoning
The court first examined the registered conveyance and found that it transferred Apartment No. 3-A with its fittings and furniture but made no reference to any car parking space.
¶ 11Counsel for the petitioner did not contend that the car parking space formed part of the conveyed property. He argued instead that the space should be allotted to the petitioner because he stepped into his vendors' shoes.
¶ 12The court held that the petitioner had not shown the car parking space to be an inseparable incident of Flat A-3 under Section 8.
¶ 13The court noted that the Board never conveyed the space to the vendors, so the promised transfer never took effect.
¶ 13, 14The court further held that if any party was aggrieved by the non-transfer, it was the vendors, not the petitioner, because the petitioner was not a party to the allotment and had no vested right in the space.
¶ 13The 2019 memo was therefore not shown to infringe any right of the petitioner.
¶ 13, 1405Holding
A car parking space allotted to the vendors does not pass to the purchaser of the flat under Section 8 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, where the conveyance deed does not include it and the Board never transferred it to the vendors.
¶ 13, 14The petitioner has no standing to claim the space in these circumstances.
¶ 13The writ petition (WPA 2129 of 2020) is dismissed. CAN 5 of 2026 is dismissed. The interim order is vacated, with no order as to costs. A certified copy is to be supplied on application.
¶ 15, 16, 17, 18Original Court PDF
SHRAWAN KUMAR AGARWALvsW.B. HOUSING BOARD & ORS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
