Calcutta High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawAdministrative and Public Law

Section 57B bar does not apply to declaration-of-title suits; Tribunal cannot sit in judgment over civil court decrees.

SUKUMAR DEYASHI AND ANRv.STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Section 57B bar does not apply to declaration-of-title suits; Tribunal cannot sit in judgment over civil court decrees.. SUKUMAR DEYASHI AND ANR vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether Section 57B of the Act bars a civil suit for declaration of title and consequential reliefs, so as to preclude recognition of a civil court decree in favour of the petitioners.

The court held

Section 57B does not bar a suit for declaration of title and consequential reliefs.

It also directed

The Tribunal acted beyond jurisdiction by sitting in judgment over a competent civil court's decree.

No notice or hearing was afforded to the petitioners or original owners under Section 44(2a), which the Court treated as a material defect.

The writ petition was allowed, the Tribunal's judgment and order in OA No. 150 of 2012 was set aside, and the Block Land and Land Reforms Officer, Amta, Howrah was directed to incorporate the petitioners' names in the ROR for the suit properties.

No order as to costs was made.

01Facts

The petitioners claim title through Harimati Dasi, who was recorded as a possessor in the CS Records of Rights (ROR) and later as a raiyat in the RS ROR.

¶ 2

She allegedly settled the suit properties by two deeds of settlement and a deed of gift, and the petitioners acquired title through these instruments.

¶ 2, 7

The State initiated proceedings under Section 44(2a) of the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, 1953 ("the Act"), contending that the transfers occurred after vesting, making the petitioners post-vesting transferees.

¶ 3

The RS ROR was rectified accordingly.

¶ 3

The petitioners sought mutation in the LR ROR and filed a title suit (Title Suit No. 60 of 1993) against the State.

¶ 4, 8

The State filed a written statement but later did not contest, and the suit was decreed ex parte declaring the petitioners' title.

¶ 4

The State argued that Harimati Dasi did not exercise her Form B option to retain the lands, and that the title suit was in substance a barred suit for correction of ROR under Section 57B of the Act.

¶ 5, 6

The Tribunal, in OA No. 150 of 2012 (LRTT), decided against the petitioners on May 13, 2026, holding that Section 57B barred consideration of the decree and that no inaction could be alleged because the State had no authority to correct ROR for vested land.

¶ 8

The petitioners contended that no notice was ever served on them or the original owners in the Section 44(2a) proceedings.

¶ 12

02Issues

i.1. Whether Section 57B of the Act bars a civil suit for declaration of title and consequential reliefs, so as to preclude recognition of a civil court decree in favour of the petitioners.

¶ 6, 8, 13

ii.2. Whether the Tribunal acted beyond its jurisdiction by sitting in judgment over an ex parte decree passed by a competent civil court declaring the petitioners' title.

¶ 13, 14

iii.3. Whether the State's revision of the RS ROR under Section 44(2a) was vitiated by the absence of notice and an opportunity of hearing to the persons interested.

¶ 11, 12

03Law Applied

Section 44(2a) of the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, 1953 empowers a specially authorised officer to revise a finally published record-of-rights entry, on application within nine months or on his own motion within sixty years, but only "after giving the persons interested an opportunity of being heard and after recording reasons therefor," and subject to a proviso barring revision where an appeal is pending before the tribunal.

¶ 10, 11

Section 57B of the Act bars suits for correction of record of rights; the Court held that this bar does not extend to a suit for declaration of title and consequential reliefs.

¶ 6, 13

The Tribunal's reliance on an unidentified "ratio of the decision referred to above" was noted but not examined.

¶ 8

The judgment cites no case law.

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

west bengal estates acquisition act, 1953 Section 44

04Reasoning

The Court first observed that Section 44(2a) mandates a hearing before revision, and that the petitioners and original owners were given no notice, so the Section 44(2a) proceeding was procedurally deficient on the face of the record.

¶ 11, 12

The Court then treated the civil court's decree as a valid adjudication of title, holding that Section 57B does not bar a suit for declaration of title and consequential reliefs, and that the Tribunal could not treat the decree as an impermissible correction of ROR.

¶ 13

Having found the decree valid, the Court held that the Tribunal exceeded its jurisdiction by effectively reviewing and disregarding a competent civil court's declaration of title.

¶ 14

The judgment does not expressly address the State's Form B argument, nor does it expressly decide the validity of Section 44(2a) proceedings beyond noting the absence of hearing.

05Holding

Section 57B does not bar a suit for declaration of title and consequential reliefs.

¶ 13

The Tribunal acted beyond jurisdiction by sitting in judgment over a competent civil court's decree.

¶ 14

No notice or hearing was afforded to the petitioners or original owners under Section 44(2a), which the Court treated as a material defect.

¶ 12

The writ petition was allowed, the Tribunal's judgment and order in OA No. 150 of 2012 was set aside, and the Block Land and Land Reforms Officer, Amta, Howrah was directed to incorporate the petitioners' names in the ROR for the suit properties.

¶ 15, 16

No order as to costs was made.

¶ 17
Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

SUKUMAR DEYASHI AND ANRvsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Calcutta High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment