01Facts
The writ petitioner No. 1 is a registered housing cooperative society. The respondent KMDA issued a possession certificate dated 06.04.2015 delivering open car parking space No. 23 in Dakshini Phase-I Housing Complex, Baishnabghata Patuli Township, to private respondent No. 4
¶ 1The KMDA brochure provided for 18 open car parking spaces and 28 covered spaces
¶ 3 · ¶ 29By memo dated 09.04.2009, the KMDA decided that common services and common areas would be handed over to the society before individual possession of apartments
¶ 4 · ¶ 30A possession certificate dated 02.06.2009 handed these common areas to the society, and the annexed sketch map showed 22 open car parking spaces
¶ 4 · ¶ 30A later sketch map dated 22.04.2015 showed space No. 23 carved out of the common area
¶ 5 · ¶ 33The petitioner contended that this allotment diminished the members' proportionate common interest
¶ 6 · ¶ 8The KMDA argued that it held exclusive allotment authority under its brochure, which reserved this right
¶ 9 · ¶ 18Private respondent No. 4 challenged maintainability, contending that the dispute was an inter se matter under s. 102 of the West Bengal Cooperative Societies Act, 2006 and that the petitioner had suffered no legal injury
¶ 20–2102Issues
i.1. Whether the writ petition is maintainable at the instance of a registered cooperative society, notwithstanding the contention that the dispute is an inter se dispute cognizable under s. 102 of the WB Cooperative Societies Act, 2006 and that no legal injury has been caused
¶ 24–27ii.2. Whether the KMDA, by issuing the possession certificate dated 06.04.2015 allotting open car parking space No. 23, exceeded its authority and acted contrary to law after the common areas had been handed over to the society
¶ 28iii.3. Whether the petitioner's failure to challenge allotments of spaces Nos. 19–22 renders the writ petition partial and liable to dismissal
¶ 3503Law Applied
The court relied primarily on s. 17 of the WB Cooperative Societies Act, 2006, which makes a registered society a body corporate with perpetual succession and capacity to sue and be sued, enabling it to protect its members' common interests
¶ 24–26The court treated the handover of common areas and services by the possession certificate dated 02.06.2009 as having vested those areas in the society's management, with the KMDA thereafter losing its right over them
¶ 30 · ¶ 33The court relied on the principle, drawn from the brochure and the model deed of conveyance, that common services and areas form part of the amenities attached to the apartments and are enjoyed in common by the members
¶ 31–32The court accepted the petitioner's characterisation of Mani Subrat Jain v. State of Haryana, (1977) 1 SCC 486, as supporting a body corporate's standing to protect its members' rights
¶ 26Counsel cited ss. 2, 3(d), and 5 of the WB Apartment Ownership Act, 1972 (undivided interest in common areas), Nahalchand Laloochand Pvt. Ltd. v. Panchali Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. (SC, 2010), and Basana Dutta v. State of West Bengal, 2004 SCC OnLine Cal 856
¶ 12–15Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens
West Bengal Apartment Ownership Act, 1972 Section 2Section 3Section 5Section 10
West Bengal Co-operative Societies Act, 2006 Section 4Section 17Section 102
04Reasoning
On maintainability, the court held that the society, as a body corporate under s. 17, represents its members and may sue or defend for protection of their common rights. Because the petitioner's case was that the KMDA's action itself impaired those rights, the dispute was not an inter se dispute between members
¶ 26–27On the merits, the court found that the 2009 possession certificate and sketch map, read with the brochure and the model deed of conveyance, established that the common areas and services belonged to the amenities enjoyed by the society's members
¶ 30–32The KMDA's 2015 sketch map, which earmarked part of this common area for space No. 23, was an unauthorised interference with the members' proportionate common interest, since the KMDA had already divested itself of those areas before the conveyances
¶ 33–34The court rejected the partiality argument as irrelevant, because the challenge was confined to the allotment of space No. 23 alone
¶ 35–36The petitioner's failure to object to spaces 19–22 in 2009 was noted but did not affect the outcome
¶ 30 · ¶ 3505Holding
The writ petition is maintainable, as the society may enforce its members' common rights under s. 17 of the 2006 Act, and the KMDA's allotment of open car parking space No. 23 from the common area is unlawful
¶ 27 · ¶ 34 · ¶ 36WPA 14463 of 2015 is allowed. The possession certificate dated 06.04.2015 is quashed
¶ 37 · ¶ 38The KMDA must refund the consideration paid by respondent No. 4, less ₹3,000 per month as occupational charges from handover until cancellation, with 6.7% per annum interest, within sixty working days; the deducted occupational charges must be deposited in the society's account within fifteen working days thereafter. The time limits are peremptory and mandatory
¶ 39 · ¶ 40Respondent No. 4 is permanently injuncted from using space No. 23 with effect from 1 December 2026, and the space shall be treated as common area
¶ 41Original Court PDF
DAKSHINI APARTMENT OWNERS ASSOCIATION & ANRvsKOLKATA METROPOLITAN DEV AUTHORITY & ORS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
