01Facts
The plaintiff, a Class-I registered civil contractor, was awarded the "Muruhallada Kere" formation work under the 5-L Sub-Distributary of D-72 by tender accepted on 14.02.2008.
¶ 4Agreement No. 163/2007-08 dated 31.03.2008 fixed the contract value at Rs.62,64,200.
¶ 4The plaintiff claimed to have completed about 90% of the work by 24.02.2009, while the defendants pleaded 82% completion.
¶ 4, 8On 17.04.2009 the defendants directed him to stop work, citing non-receipt of designs and approvals.
¶ 4, 25The defendants pleaded payments totalling Rs.50,88,000 and, by letter dated 29.12.2012, called upon the plaintiff to collect a balance of Rs.1,47,711.
¶ 8–9, 26The plaintiff issued representations and a legal notice (02.09.2013), which was replied to on 04.12.2013.
¶ 7, 33The plaintiff sued for Rs.1,75,27,456 with 12% interest under 21 heads.
¶ 7The Commercial Court decreed Rs.19,03,170 with 9% interest from 28.08.2009, relying on Kailash Nath Associates for interest.
¶ 16Both sides appealed under s. 13(1-A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015.
¶ 17–1802Issues
i.1. Whether the plaintiff proved the execution of the additional and excess quantities claimed, given the Measurement Book (Ex. P-29), the unsigned First and Part Bill (Ex. P-8), and the defendants' report and statements (Exs. D-19, D-25, D-26).
¶ 24, 27–31, 38ii.2. Whether the suit was barred by limitation, including whether the 02.09.2013 notice and 04.12.2013 reply extended limitation.
¶ 32–33, 36iii.3. Whether the Rs.2,00,000 overhead and Rs.2,00,000 idle-charge awards were supported by evidence.
¶ 37iv.4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to enhancement of the decree to the claimed amount of Rs.1,75,27,456 with 12% interest.
¶ 39–4003Law Applied
The Court applied s. 13(1-A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 as the appellate route against the commercial decree.
¶ 17The Court relied on s. 3 of the Limitation Act, 1963, which requires the court to examine limitation even if not properly pursued by the parties.
¶ 36The Court relied on s. 18 of the Limitation Act, 1963, which requires a subsequent written acknowledgment of liability to extend limitation.
¶ 33The Court applied State of Gujarat v. Kothari & Associates (2016) 14 SCC 761, holding that each distinct breach in a contract gives rise to a separate cause of action, so suits must be filed within three years of each breach.
¶ 34The Court applied OPG Power Generation (P) Ltd. v. Enexio Power Cooling Solutions (India) (P) Ltd. (2025) 2 SCC 417, holding that a partial acknowledgment extends limitation only for the specific sum or right acknowledged, not the entire claim.
¶ 35The Court treated the Measurement Book as the best evidence of executed quantities and held that a contractor must prove each additional item and its execution and acceptance; oral instructions from site engineers are insufficient, and photographs do not substitute measurement records.
¶ 28, 31, 40The Court required proof of actual expenditure and causation for overhead and idle charges.
¶ 37The Commercial Court's interest award was based on Kailash Nath Associates (2015) 4 SCC 136.
¶ 16Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Section 13
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 18Section 3
04Reasoning
The Court found the plaintiff's assertion of 90% completion inconsistent with the contemporaneous Measurement Book and with his admissions in cross-examination (PW-1, dated 02.12.2015).
¶ 27Ex. P-8 was prepared by PW-2, a retired official working in the plaintiff's office, and bore no departmental signatures, so it lacked the assurance of acceptance.
¶ 29Ex. D-19 showed that some items were not executed and others exceeded Schedule-B.
¶ 30The defendants' admission of Rs.7,22,000 for excess quantities was held not to prove the other claims, which required item-wise proof.
¶ 31, 38On limitation, the Court treated the 17.04.2009 stoppage and the 29.12.2012 balance-payment letter as the relevant starting points, so a suit was due by about December 2015.
¶ 32The 2013 notice and reply did not revive the claim, and no s. 18 acknowledgment was shown.
¶ 33The Court noted that the Commercial Court failed to frame a limitation issue, but held that this omission could not defeat a plea going to maintainability.
¶ 36The Court found that the claim of Rs.1.75 crore substantially exceeded the Rs.62.64 lakh contract value without convincing proof.
¶ 40The Court observed that the Commercial Court did not explain how the individual findings produced the Rs.19,03,170 decretal figure.
¶ 38The Court's reasoning on limitation is internally inconsistent on the filing date: para. 7 and 26 record institution on 09.06.2014, while para. 33 refers to a suit "instituted in the year 2020".
¶ 7, 26, 3305Holding
The plaintiff failed to prove the executed quantities and extra claims, and the suit was barred by limitation.
¶ 41COMAP No. 29/2026 was allowed, the judgment and decree dated 28.03.2025 in Com. O.S. No. 1/2020 was set aside, and the suit was dismissed as time-barred and for want of sufficient proof.
¶ 42(i)–(iii)COMAP No. 468/2025 was dismissed and the plaintiff's enhancement claim was rejected.
¶ 42(iv), 39No order as to costs.
¶ 42(v)Original Court PDF
MR JAVAREGOWDAvsTHE MANAGING DIRECTOR
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
