Karnataka High CourtContract LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Contractor's Rs 1.75 Crore Claim Against Cauvery Neeravari Nigam Barred by Limitation; Karnataka HC Sets Aside Rs 19 Lakh Decree

MR JAVAREGOWDAv.THE MANAGING DIRECTOR

Contractor's Rs 1.75 Crore Claim Against Cauvery Neeravari Nigam Barred by Limitation; Karnataka HC Sets Aside Rs 19 Lakh Decree. MR JAVAREGOWDA vs THE MANAGING DIRECTOR. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the plaintiff proved the execution of the additional and excess quantities claimed, given the Measurement Book (Ex. P-29), the unsigned First and Part Bill (Ex. P-8), and the defendants' report and statements (Exs. D-19, D-25, D-26).

The court held

The plaintiff failed to prove the executed quantities and extra claims, and the suit was barred by limitation.

It also directed

COMAP No. 29/2026 was allowed, the judgment and decree dated 28.03.2025 in Com. O.S. No. 1/2020 was set aside, and the suit was dismissed as time-barred and for want of sufficient proof.

COMAP No. 468/2025 was dismissed and the plaintiff's enhancement claim was rejected.

No order as to costs.

01Facts

The plaintiff, a Class-I registered civil contractor, was awarded the "Muruhallada Kere" formation work under the 5-L Sub-Distributary of D-72 by tender accepted on 14.02.2008.

¶ 4

Agreement No. 163/2007-08 dated 31.03.2008 fixed the contract value at Rs.62,64,200.

¶ 4

The plaintiff claimed to have completed about 90% of the work by 24.02.2009, while the defendants pleaded 82% completion.

¶ 4, 8

On 17.04.2009 the defendants directed him to stop work, citing non-receipt of designs and approvals.

¶ 4, 25

The defendants pleaded payments totalling Rs.50,88,000 and, by letter dated 29.12.2012, called upon the plaintiff to collect a balance of Rs.1,47,711.

¶ 8–9, 26

The plaintiff issued representations and a legal notice (02.09.2013), which was replied to on 04.12.2013.

¶ 7, 33

The plaintiff sued for Rs.1,75,27,456 with 12% interest under 21 heads.

¶ 7

The Commercial Court decreed Rs.19,03,170 with 9% interest from 28.08.2009, relying on Kailash Nath Associates for interest.

¶ 16

Both sides appealed under s. 13(1-A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015.

¶ 17–18

02Issues

i.1. Whether the plaintiff proved the execution of the additional and excess quantities claimed, given the Measurement Book (Ex. P-29), the unsigned First and Part Bill (Ex. P-8), and the defendants' report and statements (Exs. D-19, D-25, D-26).

¶ 24, 27–31, 38

ii.2. Whether the suit was barred by limitation, including whether the 02.09.2013 notice and 04.12.2013 reply extended limitation.

¶ 32–33, 36

iii.3. Whether the Rs.2,00,000 overhead and Rs.2,00,000 idle-charge awards were supported by evidence.

¶ 37

iv.4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to enhancement of the decree to the claimed amount of Rs.1,75,27,456 with 12% interest.

¶ 39–40

03Law Applied

The Court applied s. 13(1-A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 as the appellate route against the commercial decree.

¶ 17

The Court relied on s. 3 of the Limitation Act, 1963, which requires the court to examine limitation even if not properly pursued by the parties.

¶ 36

The Court relied on s. 18 of the Limitation Act, 1963, which requires a subsequent written acknowledgment of liability to extend limitation.

¶ 33

The Court applied State of Gujarat v. Kothari & Associates (2016) 14 SCC 761, holding that each distinct breach in a contract gives rise to a separate cause of action, so suits must be filed within three years of each breach.

¶ 34

The Court applied OPG Power Generation (P) Ltd. v. Enexio Power Cooling Solutions (India) (P) Ltd. (2025) 2 SCC 417, holding that a partial acknowledgment extends limitation only for the specific sum or right acknowledged, not the entire claim.

¶ 35

The Court treated the Measurement Book as the best evidence of executed quantities and held that a contractor must prove each additional item and its execution and acceptance; oral instructions from site engineers are insufficient, and photographs do not substitute measurement records.

¶ 28, 31, 40

The Court required proof of actual expenditure and causation for overhead and idle charges.

¶ 37

The Commercial Court's interest award was based on Kailash Nath Associates (2015) 4 SCC 136.

¶ 16

Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Section 13

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96

Limitation Act, 1963 Section 18Section 3

04Reasoning

The Court found the plaintiff's assertion of 90% completion inconsistent with the contemporaneous Measurement Book and with his admissions in cross-examination (PW-1, dated 02.12.2015).

¶ 27

Ex. P-8 was prepared by PW-2, a retired official working in the plaintiff's office, and bore no departmental signatures, so it lacked the assurance of acceptance.

¶ 29

Ex. D-19 showed that some items were not executed and others exceeded Schedule-B.

¶ 30

The defendants' admission of Rs.7,22,000 for excess quantities was held not to prove the other claims, which required item-wise proof.

¶ 31, 38

On limitation, the Court treated the 17.04.2009 stoppage and the 29.12.2012 balance-payment letter as the relevant starting points, so a suit was due by about December 2015.

¶ 32

The 2013 notice and reply did not revive the claim, and no s. 18 acknowledgment was shown.

¶ 33

The Court noted that the Commercial Court failed to frame a limitation issue, but held that this omission could not defeat a plea going to maintainability.

¶ 36

The Court found that the claim of Rs.1.75 crore substantially exceeded the Rs.62.64 lakh contract value without convincing proof.

¶ 40

The Court observed that the Commercial Court did not explain how the individual findings produced the Rs.19,03,170 decretal figure.

¶ 38

The Court's reasoning on limitation is internally inconsistent on the filing date: para. 7 and 26 record institution on 09.06.2014, while para. 33 refers to a suit "instituted in the year 2020".

¶ 7, 26, 33

05Holding

The plaintiff failed to prove the executed quantities and extra claims, and the suit was barred by limitation.

¶ 41

COMAP No. 29/2026 was allowed, the judgment and decree dated 28.03.2025 in Com. O.S. No. 1/2020 was set aside, and the suit was dismissed as time-barred and for want of sufficient proof.

¶ 42(i)–(iii)

COMAP No. 468/2025 was dismissed and the plaintiff's enhancement claim was rejected.

¶ 42(iv), 39

No order as to costs.

¶ 42(v)
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

MR JAVAREGOWDAvsTHE MANAGING DIRECTOR

Karnataka High Court · October 06, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment