01Facts
Dhirendra Singh was engaged as a daily-wage Junior Clerk on 20 April 1992.
¶ 3–15, 19–22After his oral termination, the High Court directed that he be permitted to continue, subject to the condition that his juniors remained in service.
¶ 3–15, 19–22He later received the minimum of the regular pay scale from 7 February 2005.
¶ 3–15, 19–22Two employees junior to him were absorbed with retrospective effect from 3 April 1997.
¶ 3–15, 19–22Following consideration by an Absorption Committee, Singh was adjusted against a vacant Junior Assistant post by order dated 10 January 2014.
¶ 3–15, 19–22The Director cancelled his absorption by order dated 7 November 2014.
¶ 3–15, 19–22Singh challenged that cancellation, alleging that it was made without reasons or a hearing; the State maintained that his case did not satisfy the absorption rules.
¶ 3–15, 19–2202Issues
i.Whether the cancellation of Singh’s absorption was invalid for being an unreasoned order that did not identify the applicable absorption requirement he had failed to meet.
¶ 19–25ii.Whether cancellation of his absorption without notice or an opportunity of hearing violated the principles of natural justice.
¶ 19, 21, 25–2603Law Applied
The Court referred to the Uttar Pradesh Regularisation of Persons Working on Daily Wages or on Work Charge or on Contract in Government Departments on Group “C” and Group “D” Posts (Outside the Purview of the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission) Rules, 2016, observing that the cancellation order did not specify which provision had not been satisfied.
¶ 24It applied the principles that an administrative order must state reasons supporting its conclusion and that a person affected by an adverse decision must be afforded notice and an opportunity of hearing; an order made in breach of those requirements is liable to be set aside.
¶ 25–2604Reasoning
The cancellation order merely concluded that Singh did not fulfil the absorption requirements, without identifying the provision or explaining the basis for that conclusion.
¶ 24–27The Court therefore found it unreasoned.
¶ 24–27It also relied on the pleaded absence of notice and hearing, which the respondents had not denied in their counter-affidavit, and held that the cancellation violated natural justice.
¶ 24–27On those grounds, the order could not stand.
¶ 24–2705Holding
The Court held the order dated 7 November 2014 unsustainable because it was unreasoned and passed in violation of natural justice.
¶ 27–29It set the order aside and allowed the writ petition, with no order as to costs.
¶ 27–29Original Court PDF
Santosh Kumar VermavsState Of U.P. Through Prin. Secy. Deptt. Of Medical Edu. Lko
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
