Allahabad High CourtCriminal Procedure and EvidenceCriminal Law

UP HC Sets Aside Order Converting Man’s Plea To Prosecute Police Into Complaint, Directs Statewide BNSS Hearings For Proposed Accused Before Cognizance

Manoj Kumar Paswanv.State Of U.P. And 5 Others

UP HC Sets Aside Order Converting Man’s Plea To Prosecute Police Into Complaint, Directs Statewide BNSS Hearings For Proposed Accused Before Cognizance. Manoj Kumar Paswan vs State Of U.P.  And 5 Others. Allahabad High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Special Judge lawfully converted the Section 173(4) BNSS application into a complaint without recording adequate reasons or satisfying himself that the allegations disclosed a prima facie offence.

The court held

The Court set aside the Special Judge’s order dated 9 July 2025 converting the Section 173(4) BNSS application into a complaint, holding that the order could not be sustained.

It also directed

The appeal was disposed of, and general directions concerning applications for investigation, complaint proceedings and safeguards for public servants were issued for judicial officers in Uttar Pradesh.

01Facts

The appellant alleged that police personnel assaulted him and a relative, used caste-based insults, and falsely implicated him after intervening in a dispute with his neighbour.

¶ 3–6

He claimed that complaints to police authorities had not resulted in action and sought relief under Section 173(4) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS).

¶ 3–6

The Special Judge declined to direct police investigation and instead registered the application as a complaint, fixing it for examination of the complainant under Section 223 BNSS.

¶ 7

The appellant appealed, seeking an order directing registration of an FIR.

¶ 8

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Special Judge lawfully converted the Section 173(4) BNSS application into a complaint without recording adequate reasons or satisfying himself that the allegations disclosed a prima facie offence.

¶ 25–27

ii.2. Whether, before proceeding with the complaint against police personnel, the Special Judge was required to consider and comply with the safeguards in Sections 175(4), 223(1) and 223(2) BNSS.

¶ 11–13, 21, 28

iii.3. Whether the material before the Special Judge disclosed a prima facie case warranting investigation or complaint proceedings.

¶ 15–16, 25, 31

03Law Applied

Sections 173(4) and 175(3) BNSS require an application seeking investigation to meet the statutory requirements, including prior recourse to the Superintendent of Police, a supporting affidavit, such inquiry as the Magistrate considers necessary, and consideration of the police officer’s submissions.

¶ 9–11, 18

Under Section 175(4), where an investigation is sought against a public servant for alleged conduct arising in the discharge of official duties, the Magistrate must obtain a report from a superior officer and consider the public servant’s assertions about the circumstances of the incident.

¶ 10–11, 18

The judgment treated the first proviso to Section 223(1) as requiring an opportunity of hearing before cognizance, and Section 223(2) as requiring the specified safeguards for complaints against public servants where applicable.

¶ 12–13, 19–21

It further relied on *Babu Venkatesh v. State of Karnataka* and *Om Prakash Ambadkar v. State of Maharashtra* for the need for judicial application of mind before ordering investigation; *Kushal Kumar Agarwal v. Directorate of Enforcement* and *Parvinder Singh v. Directorate of Enforcement* on the pre-cognizance hearing; and *Bhajan Lal*, *Popular Muthiah* and *Ishwar Chand Sharma* on judicial scrutiny of whether allegations disclose an offence and whether criminal process is being misused.

¶ 17–24

The Court directed that applications for investigation be assessed on their merits and not automatically converted into complaints; if treated as complaints, the applicable BNSS procedure must be followed.

¶ 29

Provisions in the judgment · 17 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 13 provisionsSection 126Section 135Section 170Section 173Section 175Section 210Section 212Section 218Section 223Section 224Section 225Section 226Section 227

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 155Section 156Section 386Section 482

04Reasoning

The Court noted that the police had intervened in an existing neighbourhood dispute and initiated preventive proceedings against the appellant, but held that this did not by itself resolve the separate allegations of assault and caste-based abuse.

¶ 14

It also observed that the specific allegation of repeated blows was unsupported by reliable medical material, while cautioning that this circumstance was not conclusive proof that no offence occurred.

¶ 15

The Special Judge had relied on earlier decisions without sufficiently considering the facts and the BNSS requirements, and had not recorded the requisite judicial satisfaction before converting the application into a complaint.

¶ 16, 25–27

Because the proposed accused were police personnel, the Special Judge also needed to consider whether the public-servant safeguards in Sections 175(4) and 223(2), and the hearing requirement in Section 223(1), applied to the allegations and, if so, comply with them.

¶ 21, 28

The Court concluded that neither a prima facie case nor compliance with the relevant procedural safeguards was demonstrated.

¶ 31

05Holding

The Court set aside the Special Judge’s order dated 9 July 2025 converting the Section 173(4) BNSS application into a complaint, holding that the order could not be sustained.

¶ 32

The appeal was disposed of, and general directions concerning applications for investigation, complaint proceedings and safeguards for public servants were issued for judicial officers in Uttar Pradesh.

¶ 29, 33–34
Allahabad High Court

Original Court PDF

Manoj Kumar PaswanvsState Of U.P. And 5 Others

Allahabad High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment