01Facts
The petitioner brought a suit under Section 144 of the U.P. Revenue Code, 2006, seeking declaration of rights in agricultural holdings based on an alleged oral family settlement, and challenging two sale deeds.
¶ 3Respondent No. 3 objected to the suit’s maintainability. On 20 March 2026, the Sub-Divisional Magistrate rejected that objection, finding triable issues.
¶ 3Respondent No. 3 appealed under Section 207; the Commissioner dismissed the appeal on 12 May 2026.
¶ 3Respondent No. 3 then sought revision before the Board of Revenue, which allowed it on 17 June 2026. The petitioner challenged that order by writ petition.
¶ 302Issues
i.Whether an order rejecting an application challenging the maintainability of a Section 144 suit was appealable under Section 207 of the Code.
¶ 4, 9, 13ii.Whether the Board of Revenue could entertain a revision under Section 210 where the challenged proceedings also included an order of the Commissioner appealable by second appeal under Section 208.
¶ 5, 10–14iii.Whether the Board of Revenue exceeded the proper limits of revisional jurisdiction by deciding issues going to the merits of the declaratory suit.
¶ 15–1903Law Applied
Section 207 of the U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 provides for a first appeal against a final order or decree; an order rejecting an application to dismiss a suit for maintainability does not finally adjudicate the parties’ rights while the suit remains pending.
¶ 4, 13The Court treated such an application as analogous to an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC: allowing the application is appealable, whereas rejecting it is open to revision.
¶ 13Under Sections 208 and 210, a Commissioner’s order under Section 207 is appealable by second appeal to the Board of Revenue, while the Board may exercise revisional jurisdiction over orders of subordinate Revenue Courts.
¶ 10–14Revisional jurisdiction does not permit the Board to act as a court of first instance or determine disputed merits reserved for trial.
¶ 18–19Provisions in the judgment · 4
U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 Section 144Section 207Section 208Section 210
04Reasoning
The SDM’s order merely rejected the maintainability objection and left the suit for trial; it was therefore not a final order appealable under Section 207. The appeal to the Commissioner was consequently not maintainable.
¶ 13Although a second appeal—not revision—would ordinarily lie against a Commissioner’s order under Section 207, the revision before the Board also challenged the SDM’s order, and the Court held that the revision was maintainable under Section 210.
¶ 14The Board nevertheless failed to examine whether the Commissioner’s appeal was maintainable and went on to assess the alleged family settlement and other merits without trial or evidence.
¶ 16–19In doing so, it exceeded its revisional jurisdiction and intruded on matters for the trial court.
¶ 16–1905Holding
The Court set aside the Board of Revenue’s order dated 17 June 2026 and allowed the writ petition.
¶ 20–21It directed that the Section 144 declaratory suit be concluded expeditiously, preferably within six months of service of the certified order, in accordance with law and without granting adjournments to either party; no order as to costs was made.
¶ 22–23Original Court PDF
NikhileshvsBoard Of Revenue And 37 Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
