01Facts
The petitioners were appointed by the Governing Bodies of affiliated, deficit grant-in-aid Sanskrit colleges in Bihar between 2008 and 2015, against posts within the staffing pattern sanctioned by the State Resolution dated 18.10.1976.
¶ 4 · ¶ 14 · ¶ 28 · ¶ 39 · p. 79Each selection followed a public advertisement and interview by a Selection Committee constituted under Sections 57A/57B of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976 ("the Act").
¶ 6 · ¶ 15 · ¶ 72 · ¶ 82The Governing Bodies then issued appointment letters and the petitioners joined and served continuously.
¶ 6 · ¶ 16 · ¶ 30 · ¶ 40The University's Approval, Seniority and Pay Fixation Committee and Syndicate approved the appointments, and the Registrar notified approval, generally with effect from the dates of joining.
¶ 7 · ¶ 16 · ¶ 31 · ¶ 41 · ¶ 64The University's approval was reportedly conditional on State verification or the State's objection, and salary was contingent on State grants.
¶ 16 · ¶ 36 · ¶ 49 · ¶ 79Salary was not paid. Several petitioners obtained writ directions to the State to decide fund allocation (e.g., C.W.J.C. No. 13845/2014; C.W.J.C. No. 19632/2019; C.W.J.C. No. 17153/2019).
¶ 8 · ¶ 16 · ¶ 42The Director, Higher Education, rejected the University's recommendations on 21.04.2022 and 02.11.2022, on the sole ground that prior State approval under Section 35(2) had not been obtained.
¶ 8 · ¶ 17 · ¶ 43 · ¶ 132The University then issued letters dated 16.06.2022, 20.06.2022 and related communications directing the colleges to terminate the petitioners' services.
¶ 8 · ¶ 17 · ¶ 43In C.W.J.C. No. 3415/2023, the University also issued Office Order Memo No. 8971 dated 02.09.2026, treating one petitioner's principalship as invalid.
¶ 51(c) · ¶ 5602Issues
i.1. Whether the Director, Higher Education's orders dated 21.04.2022 and 02.11.2022, rejecting the University's approvals of appointments made against pre-existing sanctioned posts solely for non-compliance with Section 35(2) of the Act, are legally sustainable.
pp. 78–79 · ¶ 141ii.2. Whether the requirement of prior approval under Section 35(2) stands read down, under the Full Bench decision in Braj Kishore Singh, so as to permit post-facto approval for appointments against sanctioned posts, rendering the consequential termination directions by the University arbitrary, illegal and violative of Articles 14, 16 and 21.
pp. 78–79 · ¶ 14103Law Applied
The Court primarily relied on Section 35(2) of the Act, which requires State prior approval for appointments by non-government affiliated colleges, and Section 35(3), which renders non-compliant appointments invalid.
p. 22 · ¶ 22–23 · ¶ 78It applied the Full Bench decision in Braj Kishore Singh v. State of Bihar, 1997 (1) PLJR 509, which held that: (a) posts within a general staffing pattern are deemed sanctioned; (b) individual sanction for each post is unnecessary; (c) "prior approval" in Section 35(2) must be read down to include post-facto approval; (d) the State's Section 35 power is directed at verifying sanctioned posts and eligibility and at preventing back-door entries, not at withholding funding for open, transparent selections; and (e) unsettling long, uninterrupted service after a protracted lapse is an improper exercise of discretion.
pp. 80–81The Court also relied on coordinate Bench decisions in Sanjeev Kumar Ishwar v. State of Bihar, CWJC No. 2022/2024 (decided 02.04.2025), and Shivchandra Pratap v. KSDS University, CWJC No. 17192/2022.
pp. 81–83Finally, it invoked Clause 4-C(1) of the Bihar State Litigation Policy, 2011, as explained in Lilawati Mishra v. State of Bihar, (2022) 2 PLJR 671, and Amresh Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar, (2018) 2 PLJR 929, on the parity of identically situated employees.
pp. 84–86Provisions in the judgment · 3
Patna University Act, 1976 Section 35Section 57Section 57
04Reasoning
The Court found that each petitioner's post was part of the 1976 staffing pattern and was filled through an advertised, interview-based selection under Sections 57A/57B, followed by University scrutiny and approval.
pp. 82–83, Considerations IV(a)–(b)Applying Braj Kishore Singh, the Court held that the absence of prior State approval did not invalidate such appointments, and that the State could not withhold grant-in-aid or disapprove appointments on that ground alone.
pp. 80–81 · pp. 83–84Following Shivchandra Pratap and Sanjeev Kumar Ishwar, it held that post-facto approval is not required once qualifications are scrutinised.
pp. 83–84, Considerations VI–VIIThe Court also treated the petitioners' long, unblemished service (over a decade) as making sudden termination arbitrary and violative of Articles 14, 16 and 21.
p. 83, Considerations IV(c)Because the rejection orders rested solely on Section 35(2), they could not stand, and the University's consequential directions fell with them.
p. 84, Considerations VII · pp. 87–88, XIII(b)The judgment does not expressly address the State's specific arguments that Section 57A(6) (2015 amendment) did not cover post-2007 appointments.
¶ 138It also does not separately discuss the University's conditional-approval argument beyond noting that the rejection was unsustainable.
¶ 36 · ¶ 49 · ¶ 104The Court's observations on the Litigation Policy (Considerations VIII–XII) are framed as directions for systemic compliance rather than as independent grounds of decision.
pp. 84–8705Holding
The Court held that the Director's rejection orders, founded solely on non-compliance with Section 35(2), cannot be sustained in law, and that the petitioners were lawfully appointed against sanctioned posts under Braj Kishore Singh.
p. 84, VII · p. 88, XIII(c)All writ applications were allowed. The Court quashed the impugned Director's orders dated 21.04.2022 and 02.11.2022 and all allied rejection orders, and quashed the consequential University letters, including those dated 16.06.2022, 20.06.2022, 11.01.2023 and Memo No. 8971 dated 02.09.2026.
pp. 87–88, XIII(a)–(b)The petitioners were declared lawfully appointed and permitted to continue with all consequential service benefits.
p. 88, XIII(c)The State (Respondent No. 2, Director, Higher Education) was directed to release grant-in-aid/funds to the University for current and arrears salary from the respective dates of joining or approval within three months of receipt of the order.
p. 88, XIII(d)A copy of the judgment is to be sent to the Advocate General and the Chief Secretary for action under the Bihar State Litigation Policy, 2011.
¶ 142No order as to costs was made.
¶ 143Original Court PDF
Minu MishravsThe State of Bihar
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
