Patna High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Reconsideration of a voluntary retirement application is unnecessary once departmental proceedings culminate in punishment.

Kanhaiya Singhv.The State of Bihar

Reconsideration of a voluntary retirement application is unnecessary once departmental proceedings culminate in punishment.. Kanhaiya Singh vs The State of Bihar. Patna High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the termination order dated 12.01.2023, communicated through press note without personal show-cause notice during the pendency of the LPA, is legally sustainable.

The court held

The impugned order dated 12.01.2023 contains no legal infirmity warranting interference, and reconsideration of the VRS application no longer survives because the departmental proceeding culminated in punishment.

It also directed

The writ petition, including I.A. No. 1 of 2023, was dismissed.

The Court did not expressly address the petitioner's reliance on Vijay Kumar or on the Article 311 and nullity arguments.

01Facts

The petitioner joined as Medical Officer on 26.03.1988 and was posted at Sub-Divisional Hospital, Jhanjharpur, Madhubani.

¶ 4

On 03.07.2010, citing his wife's illness, the petitioner applied for voluntary retirement (VRS). The Civil Surgeon-cum-CMO recommended the request on 30.07.2010.

¶ 4

Follow-up representations in 2010, 2011 and 2016 produced no decision.

¶ 5

Earlier, a punishment for unauthorised absence was quashed in CWJC No. 12145 of 2017 on 14.03.2018.

¶ 6

A writ directing disposal of the VRS representation (CWJC No. 10660 of 2018, 26.02.2018) was not complied with, leading to contempt proceedings.

¶ 6

In CWJC No. 20149 of 2018, the Single Judge on 31.07.2019 directed that a charge-memo be served and the departmental proceeding completed within six months, with the VRS application to be decided within one month only if the petitioner was exonerated.

¶ 8

In LPA No. 1140 of 2019, the petitioner's appeal was pending when the Joint Secretary issued a termination order dated 12.01.2023, communicated through a press note without personal show-cause notice.

¶ 8 · ¶ 2

The petitioner later challenged Memo No. 105 dated 23.01.2023 by I.A. No. 1 of 2023.

¶ 3

On 15.03.2023, the Division Bench disposed of the LPA with modifications.

¶ 14

The State contended that the termination resulted from the departmental proceeding, which the petitioner did not participate in.

¶ 11–12

02Issues

i.1. Whether the termination order dated 12.01.2023, communicated through press note without personal show-cause notice during the pendency of the LPA, is legally sustainable.

¶ 8 · ¶ 11 · ¶ 16

ii.2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to grant of VRS under Rule 74(b) of the Bihar Service Code, notwithstanding the pendency and outcome of the departmental proceeding.

¶ 10 · ¶ 11 · ¶ 15

iii.3. Whether the VRS application must be reconsidered in light of the LPA Division Bench's directions.

¶ 14 · ¶ 15

03Law Applied

Rule 74(b)(i) of the Bihar Service Code permits voluntary retirement on three months' notice, subject to the employee's suspension being the only bar absent State approval, as quoted from Vijay Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2015 (2) PLJR 625, paras. 54–56.

¶ 13

Pendency of a departmental proceeding was held not to be a valid ground for refusal under Rule 74(b), as quoted from Vijay Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2015 (2) PLJR 625, para. 59.

¶ 13

Treating an employee as having ceased to be in service amounts to removal, which without hearing contravenes Article 311 of the Constitution, as held in Shamim Ahmad Khan v. State of Bihar, 2004 (4) PLJR 554, paras. 21–22.

¶ 13.1

Orders passed in disregard of a court's order are a nullity, as held in Union of India v. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal, 2014 (2) SCC 286 (SC), para. 25.

¶ 13.1

VRS would be reconsidered only upon quashment of the outcome of the departmental proceeding or exoneration, as held by the LPA Division Bench in LPA No. 1140 of 2019, para. 22.

¶ 14

A VRS decision cannot be taken without considering the pendency and outcome of the departmental proceeding.

¶ 15

04Reasoning

The Court reproduced the petitioner's authorities but did not expressly apply the Vijay Kumar or Shamim Ahmad Khan principles to the facts, nor did it expressly distinguish them.

¶ 13, 13.1

The Court's reasoning rests on the LPA's conditional direction. The LPA had made reconsideration of VRS contingent on the departmental outcome being quashed or the petitioner being exonerated.

¶ 14

The Court observed that the departmental proceeding had ended in a punishment, which is the penalty the petitioner faced, so the contingency had not occurred.

¶ 15

The Court therefore held that reconsideration of the VRS application "does not survive".

¶ 15

The Court did not separately examine whether the press-note termination complied with the principles of natural justice or Article 311, although those authorities were cited.

¶ 13.1

The Court upheld the impugned order by finding "no legal infirmity".

¶ 16

05Holding

The impugned order dated 12.01.2023 contains no legal infirmity warranting interference, and reconsideration of the VRS application no longer survives because the departmental proceeding culminated in punishment.

¶ 15–16

The writ petition, including I.A. No. 1 of 2023, was dismissed.

¶ 16

The Court did not expressly address the petitioner's reliance on Vijay Kumar or on the Article 311 and nullity arguments.

¶ 10, 13, 13.1
Patna High Court

Original Court PDF

Kanhaiya SinghvsThe State of Bihar

Patna High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment