Calcutta High CourtAdministrative and Public LawConstitutional Law

Calcutta HC Orders Review of Abhishek Banerjee's Z+ Security Downgrade, Asks Officials To Weigh Attacks Since May

ABHISHEK BANERJEEv.UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

Calcutta HC Orders Review of Abhishek Banerjee's Z+ Security Downgrade, Asks Officials To Weigh Attacks Since May. ABHISHEK BANERJEE vs UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the reduction of the petitioner's security from "Z+" to "X" category on 12.05.2026, made on the Joint Commissioner's proposal without a prior Review Committee meeting or a demonstrable threat assessment, was arbitrary and requires judicial interference.

The court held

The Court did not decide whether the 12.05.2026 reduction from "Z+" to "X" was itself invalid, and left the threat assessment to the executive, consistent with the principle that courts do not sit in appeal over threat perception. It held that the authority must consider the petitioner's reported incidents from 30.05.2026 to 07.11.2026, together with his request for enhancement, before deciding the security category.

It also directed

The writ petition was disposed of with a direction that the Principal Secretary, Home and Hill Affairs Department, Government of West Bengal, convene a Review Committee meeting for re-categorisation of the petitioner's security within two weeks of receipt of the order, and pass an appropriate order in accordance with law.

01Facts

The petitioner, a sitting Lok Sabha Member of Parliament from Diamond Harbour and General Secretary of AITC, had held "Z+" category security since 2016, having been upgraded progressively from "Y" in 2013.

¶ 2

On 12.05.2026, on a proposal from the Joint Commissioner of Police (Security), Kolkata, which relied on a Special Branch assessment finding no specific threat input, the Director, Security, West Bengal, re-categorised the petitioner's security from "Z+" to "X" with immediate effect as an interim measure and asked for a review of threat perception.

¶ 1, 11, 17

The record before the Court did not show the materials on which the Joint Commissioner's proposal was based, and no Review Committee meeting preceded the downgrade.

¶ 18

A Review Committee meeting held on 29.05.2026 confirmed the "X" category.

¶ 12, 19

The petitioner alleged six incidents between 30.05.2026 and 3.09.2026, including attacks on 30.05.2026 and 19.06.2026, vandalism of his constituency office on 18–19.07.2026, and an armed trespass at his Camac Street office on 3.09.2026, each of which he stated was reported to the police; he made representations on 26.09.2026 seeking restoration of "Z+" security.

¶ 4–7

Further incidents were alleged on 7.11.2026, and the Ministry of Home Affairs, by letter dated 5.10.2026, asked the State to provide adequate security based on local threat perception.

¶ 8

The State's report showed that two of the six reported incidents had resulted in cases under investigation, and that no steps were shown to have been taken on the petitioner's representations.

¶ 21

The Union stated that the MHA had not recommended "Z+", and the State contended that the Yellow Book guidelines were complied with and that Kolkata Police found no actionable threat.

¶ 13, 16

02Issues

i.1. Whether the reduction of the petitioner's security from "Z+" to "X" category on 12.05.2026, made on the Joint Commissioner's proposal without a prior Review Committee meeting or a demonstrable threat assessment, was arbitrary and requires judicial interference.

¶ 3, 17–18

ii.2. Whether the competent authority is bound to consider the petitioner's post-downgrade incident reports and his request for enhancement of security before deciding the category.

¶ 21–23

03Law Applied

The settled position of law that a court, in exercising judicial review, does not sit in appeal over the executive's decision on whether a threat perception exists.

¶ 22

The procedural requirement, as described in the State's report, that a high-level Review Committee (Special Branch, SIB, Home Department and Police representatives) evaluate protected persons' security at least once every six months.

¶ 20

The principle that an authority must consider the relevant material before it decides, and that the petitioner's reported incidents and enhancement request are material to that decision.

¶ 23–24

The Union and State relied on Shri Ashwini Kumar Chopra v. Union of India (Del. HC, 2010) and Ravi Kumar Rai v. Union of India (Del. HC, 2021) for the threat-perception deference principle; the petitioner's authorities, Rajesh Ranjan v. Union of India (Pat. HC, 2026), Naresh Agarwal v. State of U.P. (All. HC, 2012), Pankaj Kumar Gupta v. State of West Bengal (Cal. HC, 2023) and S.P. Kapoor v. State of Himachal Pradesh (SC, 1981), concerning reasoned orders, fair exercise of discretion and hasty executive action, were noted but not expressly applied.

¶ 9–10, 14–15, 22

04Reasoning

The Court found that the downgrade rested solely on the Joint Commissioner's proposal, that the underlying material was not disclosed, and that no Review Committee met before 12.05.2026, and the Review Committee's confirmation on 29.05.2026 came after the downgrade had taken effect.

¶ 18–19

The Court did not decide whether the downgrade itself was unlawful; it applied the threat-perception deference principle and so did not reassess the threat. Its concern was with the decision-making record: the incidents reported from 30.05.2026 onward had not been addressed by any authority, and the State had not shown any response to the petitioner's representations.

¶ 21–22

Because the petitioner had reported every incident and sought enhancement, the Court held that the authority must consider those incidents, and the request, in a fresh Review Committee meeting; the Court granted a procedural direction rather than restoring "Z+" or quashing the "X" order, and the order does not decide the merits of the threat.

¶ 23–24

05Holding

The Court did not decide whether the 12.05.2026 reduction from "Z+" to "X" was itself invalid, and left the threat assessment to the executive, consistent with the principle that courts do not sit in appeal over threat perception. It held that the authority must consider the petitioner's reported incidents from 30.05.2026 to 07.11.2026, together with his request for enhancement, before deciding the security category.

¶ 22–24

The writ petition was disposed of with a direction that the Principal Secretary, Home and Hill Affairs Department, Government of West Bengal, convene a Review Committee meeting for re-categorisation of the petitioner's security within two weeks of receipt of the order, and pass an appropriate order in accordance with law.

¶ 24–25
Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

ABHISHEK BANERJEEvsUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

Calcutta High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment