Calcutta High CourtTax LawAdministrative and Public Law

Calcutta HC Sets Aside GST Order That Demanded More Than the Show-Cause Notice: Section 75(7) Bars Excess Demands

M/S. S N CHATTTERJEE AND COMPANYv.STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Calcutta HC Sets Aside GST Order That Demanded More Than the Show-Cause Notice: Section 75(7) Bars Excess Demands. M/S. S N CHATTTERJEE AND COMPANY vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the order of the Proper Officer (adjudication order dated 24 April 2024) can be treated as a show-cause notice.

The court held

1. An adjudication order cannot be treated as a show-cause notice, so the Single Judge's direction was set aside.

It also directed

2. The Proper Officer could not confirm a demand exceeding the show-cause amount under Section 75(7).

The appeal was allowed. The order dated 24 April 2024 was set aside solely on the Section 75(7) ground. The show-cause notice was not invalidated, and the respondents were granted liberty to proceed afresh strictly in accordance with law and the statutory limitations. CAN 1 of 2025 was disposed of, and no order as to costs was made.

01Facts

The appellant, a goods transport and loading contractor, was awarded work orders by Eastern Coalfields Limited (ECL) on 5 May 2018 and 26 July 2018 for coal loading, coal transportation and sand transportation.

¶ 9(b)–(c)

The appellant contended that its transport services fall under Goods Transport Agency services, taxable at 5% under reverse charge, and that ECL had discharged the reverse-charge liability and had confirmed that no GST was payable on consignments within the ₹1,500 exemption under Notification No. 12/2017.

¶ 9(d)–(f)

The Assistant Commissioner issued a notice in GST ASMT-10 on 6 October 2023 and a DRC-01A on 20 November 2023 for FY 2018–19.

¶ 9(g)–(i)

A DRC-01 show-cause notice followed on 26 December 2023, quantifying the proposed liability at ₹2,94,26,791.67 each under CGST and SGST.

¶ 9(j), 18

The appellant replied on 31 January 2024, paid a portion under DRC-03 on 18 April 2024, and attended personal hearing on 19 April 2024.

¶ 9(k)–(n)

On 24 April 2024, the Deputy Commissioner passed a DRC-07 adjudication order confirming CGST and SGST demands of ₹3,03,88,943 each, exceeding the show-cause amount.

¶ 9(o)–(p), 18

The appellant filed a writ petition seeking quashing of the show-cause notice and the order.

¶ 10

The learned Single Judge directed that the adjudication order be treated as a show-cause notice, with a three-week response period and a four-week decision timeline.

¶ 1–2, 11

The State did not object.

¶ 6

The appellant appealed.

¶ 3

02Issues

i.1. Whether the order of the Proper Officer (adjudication order dated 24 April 2024) can be treated as a show-cause notice.

¶ 8, 12

ii.2. Whether the Proper Officer was competent to confirm a demand exceeding the amount specified in the show-cause notice, in light of Section 75(7) of the CGST Act, 2017.

¶ 8, 15

03Law Applied

Section 75(7) of the CGST Act, 2017 provides that the tax, interest and penalty demanded in an order shall not exceed the amount specified in the notice, and that no demand may be confirmed on grounds other than those specified in the notice.

¶ 16–17

Section 73 of the CGST Act, 2017, including the demand-cum-show-cause mechanism under Section 73(2) and confirmation under Section 73(9), as noted by the Single Judge.

¶ 11

A show-cause notice, which initiates adjudication by putting allegations and proposed demands to the noticee, and an adjudication order, which is the final, reasoned determination of liability after considering the material and submissions, are distinct in nature, purpose and legal effect, so an adjudication order cannot be converted into a show-cause notice.

¶ 13

Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 Section 37Section 39Section 44Section 61Section 73Section 75

04Reasoning

The Single Judge erred in treating a quasi-judicial adjudication order, which had applied its mind, recorded reasons and determined liabilities, as a show-cause notice. That conversion was impermissible because the adjudication order was the culmination of proceedings, not their initiation.

¶ 13–14

The Court compared the figures and found that the show-cause notice quantified the liability at ₹2,94,26,791.67 under each head, while the order confirmed ₹3,03,88,943 under each head. The excess violated the express bar in Section 75(7), making the demand impermissible regardless of the merits.

¶ 18–19

The Court did not examine whether the appellant's reverse-charge contention or the ₹1,500 exemption was correct, and it expressly reserved opinion on the merits of the allegations and the substantive tax liability. The adjudication order was therefore unsustainable on the statutory ground alone.

¶ 20–21

05Holding

1. An adjudication order cannot be treated as a show-cause notice, so the Single Judge's direction was set aside.

¶ 13–14

2. The Proper Officer could not confirm a demand exceeding the show-cause amount under Section 75(7).

¶ 19

The appeal was allowed. The order dated 24 April 2024 was set aside solely on the Section 75(7) ground. The show-cause notice was not invalidated, and the respondents were granted liberty to proceed afresh strictly in accordance with law and the statutory limitations. CAN 1 of 2025 was disposed of, and no order as to costs was made.

¶ 20–22
Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

M/S. S N CHATTTERJEE AND COMPANYvsSTATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Calcutta High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment