01Facts
The State filed an acquittal appeal under Section 378(1) CrPC against the judgment of the Additional Sessions Judge (FTC), Bilaspur, dated 16.02.2021 in Sessions Trial No. 150 of 2018.
¶ 1The trial court acquitted the two respondents of offences under Sections 450, 376(d) and 506 IPC.
¶ 1The prosecution case is that on 08.09.2018, after the victim returned from a village cultural programme with her husband, the husband went outside to answer a call of nature.
¶ 2Respondent No. 1 (Om Prakash), the victim's brother-in-law, and his nephew entered the house and forcibly committed sexual intercourse with her.
¶ 2The prosecution alleges that when the husband returned, Om Prakash pressed his mouth while the offence continued, and that the second accused (Jan/Jaan Singh) then committed intercourse.
¶ 2The FIR was lodged at Police Chowki Belgahna and later re-registered at Police Station Kota as Crime No. 377/2018.
¶ 2The prosecution examined 12 witnesses and exhibited Ex. P/1 to P/22.
¶ 3The accused denied the allegations under Section 313 CrPC and examined DW/1 to DW/4.
¶ 3Dr. Renuka Samuel (PW/3) found the victim habituated to sexual intercourse but gave no definite opinion on recent intercourse.
¶ 4 · ¶ 11Chemical examination detected human sperm on some articles, but the quantity was insufficient for matching.
¶ 4The trial court held that there was no cogent, reliable evidence of guilt and acquitted the accused.
¶ 5The State contended that the victim's testimony was of sterling quality and was supported by PW/12 and that the trial court erred in discarding it.
¶ 6The respondents contended that the acquittal rested on a proper appraisal, citing material inconsistencies, Dr. Sandeep Dwivedi's (PW/8) finding of no injury, and a prior pathway dispute.
¶ 702Issues
i.1. Whether the trial court's finding acquitting the respondents suffers from perversity or illegality warranting interference by the High Court in an appeal against acquittal.
¶ 903Law Applied
The Court applied Section 378(1) CrPC, which governs State appeals against acquittal, and the offences charged under Sections 450, 376(d) and 506 IPC.
¶ 1The principle, drawn from Santosh Prasad v. State of Bihar (2020) 3 SCC 443, is that a prosecutrix's solitary version cannot be accepted at face value where it contains material contradictions, is improbable, or is unsupported by medical or forensic evidence, and that the accused is then entitled to the benefit of doubt.
¶ 20Nirmal Premkumar v. State (2024) 20 SCC 293, following Rai Sandeep v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2012) 8 SCC 21, holds that a "sterling witness" must be of very high quality, with a version that is consistent, unassailable and corroborated by other material.
¶ 21Krishan Kumar Malik v. State of Haryana (2011) 7 SCC 130 holds that the solitary evidence of a prosecutrix suffices for conviction only if it inspires absolute confidence and, where it is flawed, corroboration is needed.
¶ 23Constable 907 Surendra Singh v. State of Uttarakhand (2025 INSC 114) holds that an appellate court may interfere with an acquittal only where the judgment suffers from patent perversity, a misreading or omission of material evidence, or where only a view consistent with guilt is possible.
¶ 24Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 378Section 313Section 164Section 161
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 450Section 506Section 354Section 376
04Reasoning
The Court first tested the victim's testimony against the record. Her cross-examination admitted that the husband returned within 10–15 minutes, that a quarrel was in progress, that hue and cry raised by her produced no neighbour, and that she had informed a relative whom she could not explain was omitted from her police statement and who did not support her.
¶ 12Dr. Sandeep Dwivedi (PW/8) found no injury on the accused, and PW/3 found no definite evidence of recent intercourse and no sperm matching.
¶ 13 · ¶ 18The husband's testimony (PW/12) described the accused as standing outside and pushing him back, and also described the assault on the victim, but the Court noted that he disclosed the incident to no one, sustained no injury despite alleged assault, and conceded that villagers would have gathered had such an incident occurred.
¶ 14 · ¶ 19The Court also found his account at variance with the victim's on who first committed the offence.
¶ 7 · ¶ 18The defence witnesses (DW/1 to DW/4) established a prior pathway dispute and a counter-complaint, and DW/2 confirmed that noise from the spot would be audible to him.
¶ 15 · ¶ 16 · ¶ 19Measured against Santosh Prasad, Nirmal Premkumar and Krishan Kumar Malik, the Court held that the victim's testimony was not of sterling quality and that the cumulative contradictions and omissions created a reasonable doubt.
¶ 18–19 · ¶ 23–24The trial court's finding that the alleged disclosure to the relative was doubtful, since PW/5 denied it, was found to rest on a proper appraisal of oral evidence.
¶ 22The Court concluded that the trial court's view was plausible and that no view consistent with guilt alone emerged from the record, so the Surendra Singh threshold for interference was not met.
¶ 24–2505Holding
The trial court's acquittal of the respondents under Sections 450, 376(d) and 506 IPC was based on a proper appreciation of the evidence and did not suffer from perversity or illegality.
¶ 25The appeal was dismissed as devoid of merit, and the judgment of acquittal dated 16.02.2021 in Sessions Trial No. 150 of 2018 was affirmed.
¶ 26Original Court PDF
The STATE OF CHHATTISGARHvsOM PRAKASH @ LODHI PAW
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
