01Facts
The petitioner was a conductor with the respondent Corporation.
¶ 2On 16.04.2014, while on duty on bus KA-25/F-2932 (Mantralaya to Haliyal), a checking squad inspected the bus at Shivalli Stage No. 8.
¶ 2The bus carried 25+2+6 passengers. The petitioner had not issued tickets to four passengers, though he collected Rs. 40 from each.
¶ 3A charge sheet for "NIAC" (Not Issued Amount Collected) was issued on 21.05.2014. The four passengers paid penalty amounts.
¶ 3A full domestic enquiry followed, with management witnesses examined and cross-examined by the petitioner.
¶ 4The enquiry officer found the charges proved, and the Disciplinary Authority dismissed the petitioner from service by order dated 15.09.2016.
¶ 5The petitioner's claim in KID No. 56/2016 was dismissed by the Labour Court by award dated 15.12.2017.
¶ 6, 10 · p. 1The Labour Court held the enquiry fair and proper.
¶ 8The petitioner then filed this writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution seeking quashing of the award and the dismissal order.
p. 102Issues
i.1. Whether the non-examination of the four passengers who were not issued tickets is fatal to the charge against the petitioner.
¶ 12 · ¶ 14ii.2. Whether the charges of NIAC stand proved against the petitioner on the evidence on record.
¶ 14–16iii.3. Whether the punishment of dismissal from service is disproportionate to the small amount involved (Rs. 160).
¶ 12 · ¶ 17–1803Law Applied
The court exercised supervisory jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 and reviewed the original Labour Court records.
¶ 11, 18The court treated the enquiry as fair, so no violation of natural justice arose.
¶ 14The prosecution may prove a charge through documentary evidence; here, the receipt at Ex. M-4 showing that the four passengers paid penalty amounts was held sufficient proof of non-issuance, making examination of those passengers unnecessary.
¶ 14The past-misconduct record at Ex. M-20, including an incident where fake wrapper sheets were issued, was relied upon to show the petitioner was a habitual delinquent.
¶ 15A conductor holds passenger fares in trust for the employer, so misappropriation of public money is a serious offence warranting a heavy hand.
¶ 16Regional Manager, Rajasthan SRTC v. Ghanshyam Sharma, (2002) 10 SCC 330, holds that reinstatement of a conductor, once such charges are proved, is misplaced sympathy.
¶ 1704Reasoning
The court first held that the four passengers' non-examination was irrelevant, because the Ex. M-4 penalty receipts established that they had paid for travelling without tickets, which in turn proved the petitioner had not issued tickets to them.
¶ 14On the proof of charge, the court found the management had discharged its burden.
¶ 14The court treated the Ex. M-20 history as corroboration that the petitioner was a habitual offender who had repeatedly attempted to retain passenger money, including through fake wrapper sheets, and that prior recoveries had been made in instalments.
¶ 15Applying the trust relationship between a conductor and the Corporation, the court characterised the conduct as pilfering of public money.
¶ 16Relying on Ghanshyam Sharma, the court rejected the argument that the amount was small and that dismissal was disproportionate, finding that the Labour Court had rightly declined to interfere.
¶ 17–18The court did not separately discuss proportionality beyond this reliance on Ghanshyam Sharma and the repeated-misconduct record.
05Holding
The charges were held proved by documentary evidence (Ex. M-4), and the non-examination of the four passengers did not vitiate the enquiry.
¶ 14The petitioner's history of similar misconduct supported dismissal.
¶ 15–16The court found no error in the Disciplinary Authority's order of 15.09.2016 or in the Labour Court's award of 15.12.2017.
¶ 18The writ petition was dismissed, with no order as to costs.
¶ 19Original Court PDF
SRI.DADU S/O POORU NAYAKvsTHE MANAGEMENT OF NWKRTC
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
