01Facts
On 25.03.1995 at about 8:00 P.M., near a courtyard at Gulela Bhitha, Giro Mandal was resting on a cot after watching television. The prosecution alleges that Pradeep, Ravindra, Nawal, Kesho and Manoj Mandal surrounded him.
¶ 2On Pradeep's instruction, Kesho and Nawal held his hands, Ravindra fired a country-made pistol at his back, and Manoj stabbed him with a dagger after he fell. The alleged motive was a land dispute over Sonbarsa Adivasi land.
¶ 4The fardbeyan was recorded on 26.03.1995 at 1:45 A.M., and the FIR was registered under Sections 302/34 and 120-B IPC against eleven accused.
¶ 5The prosecution examined eleven witnesses. P.W.2 (son), P.W.5 (brother) and P.W.6 (informant) were the alleged eyewitnesses. P.W.2 and P.W.6 attributed holding the deceased to Kesho and Nawal, and P.W.3 is an independent witness.
¶ 6P.W.7 and P.W.10 did not support the prosecution, and P.W.10 was declared hostile.
¶ 6P.W.11, a member of the medical board, proved the attested postmortem report (Exhibit 4) and deposed to a sharp-cutting injury, with no definite firearm injury.
¶ 6The defence examined D.W.1.
¶ 7The trial court convicted the present three appellants under Section 302/34 IPC, sentencing each to rigorous life imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 20,000/- (default: four months). Eight other accused were acquitted.
¶ 3 · ¶ 9, 1402Issues
i.1. Whether the ocular testimony of P.W.2, P.W.5 and P.W.6 is reliable, given their improvements and the absence of any recovered bullet or firearm injury.
¶ 8, 11ii.2. Whether Exhibit 4 (attested postmortem report) is admissible without laying a foundation under Section 65 of the Evidence Act, and whether medical evidence can corroborate ocular testimony.
¶ 8, 13iii.3. Whether the non-examination of the Investigating Officer and the non-seizure of the lantern and weapons vitiate the prosecution case.
¶ 8, 12iv.4. Whether mere presence, or holding the deceased by Kesho Mandal, attracts liability under Section 34 IPC in the absence of prior concert.
¶ 8, 12v.5. Whether the trial court erred in convicting three accused while acquitting eight on the same evidence.
¶ 14vi.6. Whether the land-dispute motive can sustain a conviction where eyewitness evidence is doubtful.
¶ 1403Law Applied
The court examined the charges under Sections 302 and 34 IPC, with Section 120-B IPC also invoked in the FIR.
¶ 5Section 34 IPC requires a common intention shared by the accused, and mere presence or surrounding without proof of shared intent to kill is insufficient.
¶ 12Under Section 65 of the Evidence Act, secondary evidence of a document requires a foundation (non-availability of the original and permission to lead secondary evidence).
¶ 13The court relied on Ashok Dulichand v. Madhavlal Dube, (1975) 4 SCC 664, for the principle that mere marking of a document does not dispense with its proof.
¶ 13The court relied on Abdul Sayeed v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (2010) 10 SCC 259, for the principle that eyewitness testimony may be disbelieved where medical evidence contradicts and completely rules out its possibility.
¶ 13The court applied the rule that an Investigating Officer's non-examination, where it causes prejudice, impairs a fair trial and the defence's ability to prove prior statements under Section 161 CrPC.
¶ 12The court applied the principle that suspicion cannot replace proof beyond reasonable doubt, and that motive alone cannot sustain a conviction.
¶ 14The State's reliance on Bahadur Naik (requiring proof of actual prejudice) was noted but not expressly resolved.
¶ 9Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302Section 34
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 161
04Reasoning
The court found that P.W.2, P.W.5 and P.W.6 improved their earlier accounts. They added that Manoj's dagger blow fell on the gunshot wound to cover up the firing theory, and P.W.2 admitted in cross-examination that he reached the scene only after an alarm.
¶ 11Since no bullet was recovered from the scene or the body, the firing story, which is the prosecution's specific case against Ravindra, was unsupported. The court therefore held that the eyewitness evidence was seriously dented and that the case was one of "implication by improvement".
¶ 11Exhibit 4 was held inadmissible because the prosecution gave no Section 65 foundation, and P.W.11's oral testimony could not cure the defect since he admitted that the report was joint and did not prove the original.
¶ 13Without reliable medical corroboration, and with the gunshot version contradicted by P.W.11's finding of no firearm injury, the court applied Abdul Sayeed to find the ocular account unreliable.
¶ 13Regarding Kesho, the court found no evidence of prior concert or active participation with intent to kill. The identification of the holding was doubtful because the lantern was never seized in a night occurrence.
¶ 12Non-examination of the I.O. deprived the defence of the means to prove prior statements and contradictions, which the court treated as prejudicial rather than a mere irregularity.
¶ 12The court also held that the trial court erred by believing the same witnesses against three accused while disbelieving them for eight, without reasons.
¶ 14The land-dispute motive was treated as double-edged, capable of explaining both the murder and false implication.
¶ 1405Holding
The prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
¶ 15–16The judgment of conviction dated 24.09.2018 and the sentence order dated 26.09.2018 are set aside as to these appellants. The appellants are acquitted of all charges and discharged from their bail bonds. Manoj Mandal, who is in custody, is to be released forthwith unless wanted in any other case.
¶ 15–17The appeals are allowed and interlocutory applications, if any, are disposed of.
¶ 18–19Original Court PDF
Manoj MandalvsThe State Of Bihar
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
